By Ramin Mazaheri for The Saker Blog
It’s certainly not worth the paper it is printed on – any allegedly ground-breaking story which relies solely on anonymous sources.
There was a time in Western journalism when this was the accepted moral standard; there was a time when Western readers were smart enough to demand it.
In order to launch Gulf War II The New York Times resorted to anonymous sources to fabricate war sentiment. Had they relied on actual facts to prove Iraqi’s famously never found “weapons of mass destruction”, then Washington politicians would have never had the a mainstream media fig leaf to hide their naked lies. The instigating author, Judith Miller, was never punished – she merely switched from the (fake-) leftist New York Times to the (very real) neo-fascist Fox News and a steady position at a neoconservative think tank.
In 2019 Iraq’s poverty, endemic corruption and debilitated physical and human capital is being falsely presented entirely as the result of Iranian machinations, as opposed to Gulf War I, the interim decade of inhuman Western sanctions, Gulf War II and the subsequent era of American colonialism in Iraq. No high-class Western journalists will be punished for their warmongering – there will only be more revolving door hires.
Iraq’s four decades of hell are what the West has planned for Iran, and Reuters has repeatedly shown that they are all-too happy to provide the propaganda.
Reuters knows very little about Iran, but they know enough to be dangerous.
They know that the unprecedented, revolutionary and hugely popular addition of what I call a “Supreme Leader branch” to the Western/Liberal/Bourgeois (Aristocratic) Democratic political structure (which replaced kingship with legislative, executive and judicial branches) has been spectacularly successful in preserving Iran’s obviously (Islamic) socialist-inspired revolution despite four decades of hot and cold war. Whether it is Khomeini, Khamenei or whoever comes next, a large majority of Iranians obviously find the presence of a constant, moral-minded, patriotic, politically-unifying figure legally lodged in the state structure as extremely socially necessary. Whether it is Khomeini, Khamenei and whoever comes next – if history is any guide – the Iranian Supreme Leader also evokes genuine admiration to many across the Muslim world and even beyond.
That may explain why Reuters has been driven to denigrate Khamenei whenever possible, as part of their drive to topple the Iranian revolution and restore capitalist-imperialist control of Iran.
In July I debunked their absurd, false, Iran-ignorant, and (of course) totally unobjective journalism which was on pathetic display in their 2013 article, Khamenei controls massive financial empire built on property seizures.
Unfortunately, Reuters is at it again with their latest creation, published on December 23: Special Report: Iran’s leader ordered crackdown on unrest – ‘Do whatever it takes to end it’. Before I go find some gloves – in order to properly handle their disgusting, death-provoking propaganda – let’s answer the question, “Why now?”
Their report came out just three days prior to a major day of protest in Iran on December 26. Reuters has every interest hoping protests literally explode as much as possible in anti-imperialist, anti-neoliberal countries like Iran, so they did what they falsely claim was proper journalism: they relied solely on unnamed sources to multiply by a staggering five times even the highest death toll for the recent gas price hike protests; they relied solely on unnamed sources to claim that Khamenei demanded a monstrous crackdown. The goal is clear: spread false rumours to provoke more violence on December 26. With a few more of these, Reuters silently reasons, maybe they can finally destroy Iran’s defiant example to the world?
What was monstrous about the gas hike protest coverage in Western media is how it remained silent about the killings, drive-by shootings and horrifically self-interested treachery of a group which the West can never name: counter-revolutionaries. Indeed, it is the West’s goal to portray every death at the gas hike protests as having been methodically and diabolically planned by the Iranian government… even though every single Iranian is sadly, sadly aware of the thousands of innocents killed due to the decades-long presence of shah-funded, Saudi-funded, Israeli-funded and Western-funded mercenaries, fascists and gangsters inside Iran. Iranians will debate how many were killed by counter-revolutionaries, but they will never debate their existence. I described this reality in an article here.
But the phrase “counter-revolutionary” cannot be uttered in the West. However, these horrible groups are almost certainly the fig leaf of a “journalistic source” which Reuters is relying upon in their latest article.
First to claim 1,500? Not Amnesty, but the insane MKO cult kept alive by the West & Israel
Significantly, Reuters claim of 1,500 deaths was first promoted on December 15 on Twitter by Marjane Rajavi, leader of the extremist cult the Mujahedin-e Khalq Organization, known as the MKO, or MEK, or PMOI.
It seems unthinkable to many Westerners, perhaps, but the MKO is even less popular in Iran than the reactionaries who want to restore the shah of Iran’s Saudi-backed son (monarchs collude together, of course). Quite easy to explain their lack of domestic popularity know: the MKO fought alongside Saddam Hussein against Iran. Then, in return for allowing them to stay in Iraq, Hussein had them massacre tens of thousands of Kurds in northern Iraq.
So we have only two real choices here:
Our first choice is that the MKO has infiltrated the Iranian Interior Ministry (the alleged source of Reuters’ anonymous sources).
That is, with all journalist rigour I can muster, totally, laugh-out-loud preposterous. Given the level of anti-MKO animosity in Iran, and especially within the government (whom MKO assassins keep bombing), this implies that the Interior Ministry’s background checks are so non-existent that the entire Iranian government is as serious as gang of children playing make-believe in a treehouse. This is obviously not the case….
Our second choice is that Reuters’ anonymous sources are merely MKO dissidents who are fabricating lies and exaggerations.
Given the ludicrous alternative, this choice is so obviously correct it barely needs defending. Any reputable news agency would see right through their phony claim, and any reputable news agency would have never run such a story. Reuters only did because, like the MKO, they are devoted to the extremist project of destroying Iran’s popular government. The treehouse of loony children here is comprised of the MKO, Saudi monarchs, Zionist Mossad, MKO-pushers John Bolton & Rudy Giuliani and the dotard queen of England… and Reuters.
How Marjane Rajavi could ever be considered a source worthy of credibility defies the comprehension of every Iranian citizen, which is exactly why Reuters didn’t mention the MKO by name. If they had said their source was the MKO, they would have left themselves open to immediate criticism. So they called their “500% more” sources “anonymous”, which has become standard practice by leading Western media when they need to fabricate a war.
But what does Reuters care about the well-being of the Iranian people? Their editorial line has always shown that they are fine with publicising incredibly inflammatory material based entirely on false sources. That must be fun….
What if I did the same with France? Would you believe it?
In order to best explain the content of the Reuters’ article, allow me to give the French parallel, as I am PressTV’s longtime correspondent in France.
PressTV has spoken with three anonymous sources in France’s Interior Ministry. About 60 people have been killed during their 56 weeks of Yellow Vest protests, and only 12 people, as claimed by Amnesty International and the United States (both of whom are known to have a clear anti-French bias).
The figures provided to PressTV, said two of the French officials who provided them, are based on information gathered from security forces, morgues, hospitals and coroner’s offices. Apparently, not one of all of these people will go on record.
The administration of Emmanuel Macron did not respond to PressTV’s request for a comment, perhaps because we will provide no proof to back up our wild claims. PressTV rejects the characterisation by France’s Interior Ministry that our article is “fake news” and that our figures are “speculative”.
At a meeting at his fortified compound of Élysée Palace in central Paris, described to PressTV by three sources close to his inner circle, the 42-year-old leader, who has final say over all state matters in the country, raised his voice and expressed criticism of the handling of the unrest.
“The Fifth Republic is in danger. Do whatever it takes to end it. You have my order,” the leader known as “President Jupiter” and “Liberal Strongman” told the group, one of the sources said.
Macron said he would hold the assembled officials responsible for the consequences of the protests if they didn’t immediately stop them. PressTV assumes this was a reference to the Paris police chief, whom Prime Minister Edouard Philippe said in March was sacked because, “Inappropriate orders were given to reduce the use of LBD [rubber bullets].”
For decades, the Fifth Republic has tried to maintain its neo-imperial influence across the Muslim world, from Syria to Lebanon to Mali, by investing the political and economic capital of Paris to back militias. But now it faces pressure at home and abroad.
This report has no author, only “PressTV staff”. Editing by Fazlollah Tehrani, Mahmoud Isfahani and Roya Sarraf.
Our Standards: The Principles of PressTV
With only a few obvious replacements, and the very real reason for the firing of the Paris police chief, this is quite nearly a cut-and-paste of Reuters’ “hard-hitting” introduction.
If I had written such a report, and if PressTV had run it, we would all deserve to be fired, discredited and kicked out of journalism. The French government would have the right to openly demand a retraction and apology.
Reuters’ report reads like a wish list of what they wish had happened. Their quotes are so perfect, precisely because nobody will ever ask to verify them. Their imaginings of the government discussions are just that – imaginings – because they cannot be proven in the slightest.
Their report is so absurd that it is clearly not meant for Iranians – none would ever swallow such nonsense whole.
Their report is mainly propaganda which targets their Western audience: by increasing the gas hike death toll by five (why not go for ten?), by portraying Khamenei as a billionaire monster, by portraying Iran’s 1979-created government (with a constitution which was massively approved in a referendum which saw huge turnout; even the popular vote to elect the members to the committee which drafted this constitution saw 52% turnout, a score which the US presidential election has repeatedly failed to achieve in my lifetime) as being without checks, balances and quite devoted popular support, Reuters aims to increase support for a Western invasion like Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya and Mali, or a proxy invasion like Syria.
It is significant that Reuters and Western media have given very little attention at all to France’s Yellow Vests. The same goes regarding France’s ongoing general strike, now in its fourth week – it will surpass 1968’s in length, yet Westerners tell me they can’t find any coverage of it. PressTV stands by all we have written and produced regarding these critical socioeconomic events, and we have never resorted to anonymous sources and dangerously unproven imaginings in order to sway the French people.
Just like The New York Times, Reuters has shown that when it comes to the Muslim world they are not journalists but propagandists for neoliberalism and neo-imperialism, two ideologies with scant support by the masses of any nation.
December 26 will see something Iran has seen regularly since the end of the Iran-Iraq War – peaceful political protests whose demands must be examined, heeded and incorporated into public policy.
Reuters is hoping for 1,500 deaths on December 26, because Reuters weeps at the thought of Iranian peace.
Keep that in mind when reading their next propaganda report about Iran.
Ramin Mazaheri is the chief correspondent in Paris for Press TV and has lived in France since 2009. He has been a daily newspaper reporter in the US, and has reported from Iran, Cuba, Egypt, Tunisia, South Korea and elsewhere. He is the author of the books ‘I’ll Ruin Everything You Are: Ending Western Propaganda on Red China’ and the upcoming ‘Socialism’s Ignored Success: Iranian Islamic Socialism.’
Reuters is completely ziocontrolled. It should rather be called: Rothschilds (or: Mayers). It isn’t there to “inform” the goyim about anything, it is there as a weapon.
And if it became digital only, then it lost its only usefulness: as toilet paper.
Reuters is owned by the Thomson Group Canadian.
Rothschild own Reuters and AFP. Used primary news access at Waterloo to sell HMG stock short by hiding news of British victory. Have used it to sell the world short ever since. End of story.
If it would be limited to short selling it would nit be that bad.
Since at least 1913 they create money out of nothing and charge others interest for it. This money comes in very handy to finance both sides in a war. Extremely profitable for the bank and ugly for all participants.
Great piece on the MO of Western MSM outlets, specifically with regard to Iran. As I’ve pointed out, this wishful thinking dressed up as ”news” was on full display 10 years ago when the incumbent President of Iran Mahmoud Ahmadinejad was ”in for a resounding defeat” (unless, of course, he ”stole the election”). This was total, utter nonsense based upon the ”educated opinion” of the English-speaking exclusive minority in the wealthier parts of Teheran, better known as ”The Gucci crowd”.
Quoting Ramin:
”It’s certainly not worth the paper it is printed on – any allegedly ground-breaking story which relies solely on anonymous sources.
There was a time in Western journalism when this was the accepted moral standard; there was a time when Western readers were smart enough to demand it.”
The first statement is absolutely correct; the second one is dubious at best. Western journalism has always been propagandistic to boot and its audience equally gullible and receptive. It’s only now that the West is deteriorating and rotting that its media narratives begin to be seen for what they are: preposterous lies and imbecilities.
Dear Ramin,
I really adore your penmanship and your Persian upbringing.
I have lived in Iran for 11 Months. I never had a better time in any other
country. I have been into 78 countries. I would love to go back to Iran again. Yet I am Magyaristanie.
Hello Ramin,
Your reporting describes a single incident in a huge propaganda machine.
By citing anonymous sources nobody is really responsible for the truth if the reporting.
To me they learn from their mistakes.
Few years back a “journalist” called Claas Relotius published sories that fit what the magazines wanted to print in Germany. Excellent writing filled with plenty of detail telling heart wrenching stories. That guy collected prizes over many years until it came out that his stories were invented.
Even wikipedia admits that.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claas_Relotius
A few weeks back the swiss historian Daniele Ganser published a video where he takes the rethoric of Relotius and other western publications apart and points out that Relotius describes places and people in detail. Only critizism: Relotius never visited those places and never met the peoplevideo in german
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=e4F5Ca2lKGI
To a slightly lesser extent this “journalism” is still going on in the same opinion-leading news magazine called Spiiegel.
A German guy now living in Russia takes the Spiegel “reporting” apart on a regular base.
In german:
https://www.anti-spiegel.ru
Ramin, you are not the only guy to debunk mainstream media.
That is a mostly thankless but important task.
Everything points to the fact, that the bahai president of Iran Rouhani has from the very first day of his presidency been tasked by western powers with inciting revolution and destruction of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Rouhani has been meant to be the last and final president of the Islamic revolution. That much is clear now, so much is revealed in a recently publicized video of the late and may he burn in hell for all eternity president Rafsanjani, who as much as he can say it without openly saying it, declares the beginning of the end of the Islamic revolution with the election of Rouhani:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=suKUTT6oTIs
It is also worth mentioning, that the same bastard Rafsanjani late in his life even suggested the abolishment of the iranian armed forces!
I showed this video to an IRGC officer, that I know and told him, that Rafsanjai was talking in code and was talking about a revolution and the destruction of the Islamic Republic of Iran by the end of Rouhani presidency.
Funny enough only a few days later a video appeared, where Hassan Abbasi was saying the exact same thing:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c_TjeGN8Hn4
I also showed this video to the IRGC officer and told him, that i am not the only person saying, that Rouhani is tasked with the destruction of the iranian revolution. Anybody in doubt should only look at his economical policies, which have ruined the country.
With regards to the so called demonstrations suffice to say, that even the so called opposition residing in the west, which means paid by the west openly declared, that they had prepared this event for the last 3 years!
I wonder what the zio new york police would have done to these people, if they had done the same killings of police and burning of peoples properties in their country!
Minute by Minute:
{Everything points to the fact, that the bahai president of Iran Rouhani has from the very first day of his presidency been tasked by western powers with inciting revolution and destruction of the Islamic Republic of Iran.}
Thank you for this very important information that Rouhani is a Bahai because Bahai in Iran are in fact, a Jew.
This traitor and fifth column acts like the Jewish mafia, he, like Trump a Jewish mafia member, is a pathological liar and a theif. His brother who has stolen millions of dollars from Iranian people was arrested and put on trial. Rouhani’s brother, a thief like himself, was convicted but his sentence was mild and his trial was not public.
Another bahai, Payam Akhavan, who left Iran at the age of 9 in 1971, is at the service of the Western intelligence services where is given ‘world young leader’, now in his fifties signing petitions as ‘Iranian’ against Iran and is very active zionist working for their goals. He is in fact citizen of Canada. In 2012 Akhavan, a jew, hold a conference “Iran Tribunal’ funded by CIA and MI6 and perhaps Canada to frame Iran for ‘war crimes’ against Mujahedin, MEK. He and his zionist buddies like Erwin cotler and Inc zionist neocons support the terrorist MEK for the interrest of Israel. He is a pathological liar and a zionist stooge.
Please post a source that Rouhani is a Bahai, a zionist jew. He is very much supportive of zionist criminals and eager to join them. He must be destroyed. All option should be available. Iranian people hate these traitors. Rohani/zarif/Ali Larijani are Iran fifth column where are supported by the criminal west and zionists. These traitors are labled by the west as ‘reformists’. They are against ‘hard liners’ and frame them by posting Khamenie picture whenever they are talking about ‘massacre’ and ‘shooting’.
PBS newshours, zionist whores, Judith Woodruff and Ammanpour, funded by Jewish money, will read the lies of the zionist word by word to get their dirty $$$$$. Both spreading the lies that Iran has killed 1500 of their agents.
Samara, It is true, that jews “converted” in mass to bahaism. They literally played a crucial role in the creation of the cult. But Rouhani is not a “jew”. He is a Fereidoon (regardless of how one spells the name) are bahai.
I was actually going to teach you how to spot a fabian bahai. But it will be counterproductive and from our point of view. If one knows what to look for, it is easy to spot them. I am sure, that the bahai think, they are genius when it comes to hiding in plain site, but the matter of fact is, that their options are limited. Anybody who has studied minority psychology can easily spot them. The thing is, that they themselves expose themselves. Sometimes it is what they say, sometimes it is what they do, sometimes it is, what they don´t do. Sometimes it is their occupation. Sometimes it is their name and so on. Sometimes it is all of it at the same time. People who try hard to hide and not be noticed, or people who try hard to not be questioned are good candidates.
With regards to Rouhani you can take it to the bank, that he is a bahai and a MI6 agent.
If I may suggest this video in order to understand the depth of the zionist and bahai infiltration of the iranian intelligence agency:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NYBQzJMkxDI
with regards
Rohani a Baha’i? Nonsense. No proof given here either.
I do love it when people without any information or knowledge of a subject come with such bombastic outbursts anon. The problem is, regardless of how hard i would try to show you, you neither have the language or political or cultural background to understand it. So let me tell you the story of a man with the name of Fereidoon, who are bahai, who changed his name to Rouhani, who by sheer accident is dressed as a muslim priest a rouhani, meaning a clergyman! That was a huge mistake on his part. It the first thing they do changing their names to very shia names like Alavi, or Eslami or Jafari, Emami and so on. For someone without the religious and cultural background of an iranian shia, these are just names, but for a jew or bahai these names are hiding places. After all who would suspect a”devout” man with a last name such as Eslami, meaning Mr. Muslim to be a bahai or a jew.
Let me ask you a question anon! If you were in charge of the intelligence services of lets say usa and were hiring devout patriots to protect your homeland, would you hire someone, who travels to North Korea every other week for decades? Because it is exactly what this bahai pretending to be a muslim clergy and acting as the iranian president did, except his destination was london, during which time he was in charge of almost every aspect of our intelligence agencies!!!
I know what you are thinking; how would the iranian intelligence agencies even hire this man, let alone put him in charge, not to mention allowing him to become the president of the country!!!????
If could understand farsi and had watched the last video, I gave the link for above, you would know, that after the revolution Mossad literally created the new revolutionary intelligence agencies of Iran. Obviously their mission was to create havoc and they were so successful, that our leader asked IRGC to create a separate intelligence agency in part in order to stop the Mossad one!
I could go on, but those who have ears to listen have already done so!
People in many countries have seen news in newspapers and TV stations in their own countries. They think that the news is reported by people in their own country, no,it’s not. These news are all told by BBC and CNN. The TV stations and newspapers in their country have no money to send many reporters to all over the world, and they can only reprint the reports of Western media. They thought that their impression was to think independently, but it was actually instilled by the Western media.