by Gilad Atzmon
I am not the only musician whose career they try to destroy. Roger Waters is also subject to a vile Zionist smear campaign. The Jewish press reports that a documentary titled Wish You Weren’t Here by Ian Halperin is about to hit the screens in every shtetle around the world.
According to the Wish You Weren’t Here trailer, Waters is to blame for the rise of anti Semitsm, the failing of Israel and, for good measure, all other current Jewish problems. Impressive achievement, I must admit.
Halperin says, “To me, an attack on Israel is an attack against the Jewish people.” I guess Halperin deems both Israel and Jewish people beyond criticism. At least we know what choseness means these days. The question that remains open is whether the so-called Goyim are going to buy into this intense delusional nonsense.
Halperin says he met with psychologists who work with Holocaust survivors and their families. After the meeting, he could diagnose the effect of Waters’ floating pig bearing the Star of David as “unforgiveable” for survivors. For once, I see Halperin’s point, as an ex Jew who eats everything BUT kosher, I was also a bit offended by Waters’ attempt to give pork a kosher stamp.
The cinematic tactics used to defame Waters are boiler plate by now. The film juxtaposes Jewish suffering with Waters. ‘The terrorist’s friend’, the one who supports Arabs and Muslims. Halperin attempts to score points by appealing to the lowest xenophobic, racist intuitions. Waters, I guess, will easily survive this bombastic Zionist campaign for the same reason Corbyn survived the ‘anti-Semite’ slur. People out there aren’t as stupid as the Hasbara book wants them to be.
Waters’ opposition to Zionism and Israel is anti authoritarian and consistent with his long standing general message of peace and reconciliation. The British Jewish Lobby failed to detect that the more they attacked Corbyn and his amicable attitude towards Hamas and Hezbollah, the more popular he became. The same happened to Donald Trump. The more he was branded as a Jew hater and a dog whistler, the more Americans saw him as their savior.
Wish You Weren’t Here is set to portray Waters as a bigot, but instead it will be a window into tribal vindictiveness. Portraying an endless stream of right wing ultra Zionists denouncing a dedicated peace advocate as a bigot and an anti-Semite for criticizing Israeli apartheid is a dangerous game. It could easily backfire, it might well prove very dangerous for the Jews.
If you want to understand how they made us all into Palestinians, Being in Time is the book for you: Amazon.co.uk, Amazon.com and gilad.co.uk
Nice commentary. Indeed we live in an age when many ugly attacks fail in their attack and succeed only in their ugliness.
Heil Roger Waters !
I very doubt that if Roger Water is really a fighter for truth and peace he would like to be greated that way. Identifying anybody who criticize Israel with your hateful and disgusting ideology is really missing the point.
It is up to me how I wish to great him.
And by the way only a fool associate Heil with XX century events.
Roger is definitely the real thing. He despises Nazis as he very well showed in his opera The Wall.
The Saker
Roger Waters has no use for ‘heiling’ supporters.
Also, if you have nothing to say – don’t.
The Saker
Israel (the state) will never be in peace with their neighbors because their rulers (their deep state) do not want that. They will keep on playing victims and at the same time attacking (and killing) about anybody for whatever reason (like Syria now). What they (their deep state) fails to realize is that the world around i becoming more and more aware of Israels actions in spite of their control of MSM. People are able to see through their lies. Is becoming more and more difficult for them to paint themselves like victims all the time.
No nation that believes itself to be a Master Race or a Chosen People can live in peace with its neighbours. Because, essentially, it does not concede that they are its equals.
Incidentally, you don’t have to be a Nazi or a Zionist for this cap to fit. Throughout recorded history, it is far harder to find nations that have never considered themselves superior than those that have.
What is this mysterious power of the Jews and their allies in the West ?
This power of framing anyone who speaks up against Israel as anti-Jewish (anti-Semitic) ?
Why are the White Western people who are not Jewish upholding this power and this propaganda of fear ?
How did the Western people become slave of the Jews and cowards ?
If you are slaves of the Zionist Jews, how do you expect to defend yourself against any kind other abuse, taking away your rights, upholding family and Christian values, stopping the erosion of your culture and heritage, financial abuse by the banks and corporations ?
The Muslims of the Middle-East and Asia in their current most pathetic state in probably their entire history right now have more courage and balls then the entire Western-countries combined when it comes to standing up to these Zionist Jewish scum.
Western societies should be ashamed of this cowardliness.
Its because of the diaspora Jewish prominence in the media,academia,entertainment,government,capitalism,the law,and as writers,throughout the West (and Russia).When you control those basic elements of a society. You can shape it to the way you want it to think. Add in the Western “guilt” over the Hitler period.And the Islamophobia pushed by those Jewish groups I mentioned and you can see how its done. There is a saying that goes something like “give me control of the youth’s education.And I can control the future”. The zionists and their supporters took control of that at the start in the West.
The over-represantation of dual citizens in the US government and deep state also plays a role. Their loyalty to US interests is dubious, to say the least, and their involvement makes US foreign policy – particularly MENA policy – even worse than it would otherwise be.
Harry_Red:
You wrote:
This is a very good question, but please, don’t resort to “Western societies should be ashamed of this cowardliness.”, in an apparent absence of understanding of the situation.
Many of us in the west are asking ourselves the same question… but not talking about it openly, because there seem to be reliable consequences to doing so.
The first colonists of North America were predominantly northern European, with the intrinsic cultural norms of socialist tendencies, common in more agriculturally challenged geographies and lower population densities; during the 1st millennium AD, when the earth was cooler than it is now, if you were living in Scandinavia, and your closest neighbour, living 10 km away, had a crop failure, you’d be likely to help him out, to survive the winter, because next year it might be you who had the crop failure.
Higher density cultures typically have an iterative, incremental gaming approach to neighbours, and thus have culturally well-developed (negative sum gain) ‘gaming’ cultures.
For reasons which I have not yet closely looked in to, the Khazar tribes, which migrated from south central Asia to occupy the territory between the Black Sea and Caspian sea, subsequently strategically adopting Judaism, before breaking up, and migrating through Ukraine and establishing the cradle of western Jewery in Poland (for the fully developed historical explanation, I recommend the seminal work by Arthur Koestler, “The Thirteenth Tribe“), had a particularly virulent systematic (negative sum gain) ‘gaming’ culture.
Indigenous populations (particularly the ruling elite) sooner or later recognized this undermining of their own negative sum gain gaming of the population, and established deep biases against these virulent ‘gaming’ norms of the foreigners, which ‘trickled down’ to the lower social strata, thus forming the basis of the ‘prejudice’ against the Jews in Europe.
Fast forward to the modern era (c. 1800+), these peoples, with international cohesiveness, much like the ‘super-colony’ ants, originating in South America, now taking over the world, cleverly and opportunistically bank-rolled much of the war-making activities between their host countries, leading up to and including the Great War (WWI), and amassing significant financial base, while infiltrating key sectors beyond banking, i.e. law, publishing, and medicine.
From this base, in the lead up to, and during the events of the ‘second world war’ (WWII), a massive propaganda program was enabled, to clean the slate of historical anti-social (negative sum gain) gaming, and enable powerful ‘anti-discrimination’ agencies both in host country governments and budding non-governmental agencies, across host countries.
In the immediate post-war (WWII) era, with sympathies at their maximum, and a preponderance of affiliates in policy and decision-making capacities, British Mandate of Palestine, established in the aftermath of the First World War, was modified to enable the establishment of a designated ‘homeland’ for these ‘displaced’ peoples (regardless of the fact that the vast preponderance had no heritage from the middle east).
The well-educated and politically active Khazar/European people had little difficulty assuming political control of the designated area over the indigenous populations (likely including the descendants of the so-called biblical Jews, many long since converted to Islam) to set up nation-state infrastructures to advance their program.
As the decades after WWII progressed, the ‘anti-discrimination‘ agencies both in host country governments and non-governmental agencies, bolstered by increasing penetration of affiliates in policy and decision-making capacities, particularly in judiciary, academia, and MEDIA, and anchored by developed ‘home country’ nation infrastructures, i.e. intelligence agencies, modified their passive approach to a much, much more active approach, proactively seeking out progressively more benign objectors to the growing hypocrisy of the movement, and aggressive perception management of the host country populations following the general deception/approaches inherent in the Hasbara.
It is in this environment for the past 30 years, the program has enabled such astounding idiosyncrasies as making the seminal freedoms of peaceful demonstration and right to expression illegal when it comes to discussing the horrendous apartheid/genocide being conducted in the Mandate of Palestine lands illegal, but furthermore, having acquired the preponderance of decision-making positions within host country government agencies, has enabled systematic discrimination against citizens who even have a high probability of increasing opposition to such anti-social negative sum gain ‘gaming’ on a global scale, a capability to effectively marginalize actors before they become effective!
Thus, for those not blinded, the fear, pervasive, but difficult to pinpoint, seemingly impossible to fight (but nonetheless, all systems that can be understood, can be broken, and this system gets shallower and shallower and the operators get more and more emboldened by their remarkable, and admirable, it must be admitted, success).
So, it is not helpful to try to shame the victims of this oppression.
All in good faith help and encouragement will be beneficial to you and your offspring, for do you really think that such a program will stop at only the so-called “West”?
Think about it, and maybe get a Roger Waters recording and see if you can figure out what all the fuss is about.
You forgot to mention that Waters was wholly responsible for The Holocaust.
Starting ten years before he was born.
After reading this, i think i’ll just go listen to my cd of ‘The Wall -live in Berlin’ , Roger’s music works for me
Please tell us which ‘holocaust’ that was, the one of 1915, 1918, 1919 (“6 million souls completely exterminated”), etc. etc. …., or the one of 1938 maybe? The earliest of these holocausts starting at least 28 years before Roger was even born.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OtAnuXl5VZY
Jewish World Almanac population numbers: http://www.thetruthseeker.co.uk/?p=85432
Thank you Gilad!
Is it not better to live in the present and try to make and act rightfully?
We ARE living in the present, all of us. No escaping. But why don’t you just follow the links and learn something, for once? Without knowing and understanding history we’re bound to repeat it, and that’s not always a good idea.
Great to see an article by Atzmon here again. He’s dead on right about the zionazi attack on Waters. The sodding things should be renamed chickenshit smears, inc.
Roger Waters, do not worry: we are standing right behind you, no matter whatever comes of it!!!
Yes, this smear campaign is only preaching to the converted.
It will indeed backfire, as the apartheid state has little or no moral ground to stand on.
I actually pity the Israelis, much as I do the Ukrainians.
They cannot control the globe, despite their insane ambition. Even the US is undergoing a groundswell of awakening, and Zionism is becoming ideologically suspect.
A far cry from the Bush era.
Mass – psychosis will eventually reach its inevitable conclusion.
Semite means language, and nothing else.
In fact ” Arabs ‘ are the largest group of Semites. So if Semite now means “Jew”, the Arabs are the ” jews”
Actually ” Arab is a misnomer, when it should be Aramaen; like the Syrophonecian Aramaens who were expelled from Egypt. This expulsion was reconstituted as the exodus.
Aramaen was quintessential Hebrew. The Hebrew of the current designated of Hebrew really doesn’t historically qualify as ” Semitic”. So just because someone doesn’t by into the narrative, doesn’t make them ” Anti- language.”
The one thing both the left and the right can agree on is that the Zionist racist agenda is well past it’s best before date. The bullying is just not effective any more.
I do not mean to be a pedant or a quibbler, but I think if you ask a Palestinian, or a WTC family member, or grand-kids of the USS Liberty sailors, or the family of the Englishman who was jailed in five years for volunteering to fight Fascist terrorism in the Donbass, they would not say Zionist policy was ‘ineffective’. It is deadly effective. But it is perhaps no longer convincing or tolearable to an awakening international polity.
PROsemitic ——- what is it?
If there is an “antisemitism” you must ask: “What is PROsemitism?”
PROsemitism must be a supporter of “semitism”, which really means Judaism (though most Moslems are SEMITIC and most JEWS are NOT). So what are you supporting if you are a PROsemite? Well first of all we must define Judaism:
Judaism is neither a race or a religion, it is Xenophobic Tribalism.
XENOPHOBIC: n.
A person unduly fearful or contemptuous of that which is foreign, especially of strangers or foreign peoples.
TRIBALISM: n.
1. The organization, culture, or beliefs of a tribe.
2. A strong feeling of identity with and loyalty to one’s tribe or group.
So right off the get-go you hate all NON-Jews, NON-members of YOUR group(TRIBE).
You “bundle together” for support and safety, the very definition of Fascism
THAT means, that if I am not one of the TRIBE, you do not like me.
Since Jews BRAND all NON-Jews “gentile” automatically denigrating them, to be PROsemitic one must by definition be ANTI-GENTILE.
They hate all NON-Jews so fundamentally, that they have to SPECIFICALLY name “RIGHTEOUS GENTILES”.
Those are NON-Jewish HUMANS that went so far out of their way to help/save Jews that the Jews were FORCED to ACKNOWLEDGE the humanity of that specific ‘gentile”. You see, PROsemites do not acknowledge the EQUALITY of spirituality and humanity of “gentiles”
According to the SPLC & ADL an organization is a “HATE GROUP” if it has
“beliefs or practices that attack or malign an entire class of people”.
Jews have HATED Egypt for 3,500 years.
Jews have HATED Babylon for 2,500 years.
Jews have HATED CHRIST and his followers for 2,000 years.
David Ben-Gurion, one of the father founders of Israel, described Zionist aims in 1948: “A Christian state should be established [in Lebanon], with its southern border on the Litani river. We will make an alliance with it. When we smash the Arab Legion’s strength and bomb Amman, we will eliminate Transjordan too, and then Syria will fall. If Egypt still dares to fight on, we shall bomb Port Said, Alexandria and Cairo… And in this fashion, we will end the war and settle our forefathers’ account with Egypt, Assyria, and Aram “………….. read that again
“and settle our forefathers’ account with Egypt, Assyria, and Aram”
They are STILL HATING and planning deadly attacks after 3,500+ YEARS .
How do you think they feel about JESUS CHRIST whom they HATE most of ALL.
Israel’s MOTTOES:
(1) NEVER forgive & NEVER forget.
(2) By Way of Deception you will Do War.
Their ONLY(monotheistic) “god” is a WAR god
PROsemitism is ANTI-HUMANism
“…the general cause of anti-Semitism has always resided in Israel itself and not in those who have fought against Israel. ” Bernard Lazare (1894)
Thanks for your insights. In speaking of “settling our forefathers accounts with . . . . . ” (fill in the blank: “The Others”) people like Ben-Gurion neglect that sometimes a man’s own worst enemy can be himself. When I was younger I read the Bible a few times, and the frequently occurring idolatry of Israel and its frequent sin and disobedience towards God caused a complete reversal of this whole “settling of accounts” issue — namely, it was God who was frequently settling accounts with Israel. This may be a tough thing for the “chosen” people to swallow , but it was their disobedience that caused them ultimately to forfeit God’s protection and they were overrun by other nations (yes, idolatrous nations) who were used to exercise God’s judgments. A truly wise people would then be more concerned with the needful issue of repentance, instead of “settling accounts” with God (of all creatures) — something tells me that God will have the final word. — It makes sense that a faithful servant will do what his master commands him to do, and thus he deserves the commendation “Well done, my good and faithful servant”. Please check out this revealing website: Michael Hoffman, On The Contrary for further insights into the mindset of those who have made themselves and their suffering an idol.
Nobody says anyone has to belong to a death’s head cult. I was born Catholic. I thought Catholic sucks so I quit. If Jews think their religion sucks, they can quit. Many do. Jew isn’t a race. If you don’t want to be a Jew you don’t have to be one.
Being a bit late to comment here… but it is never too late anyway!
I would like to break a lance for Roger Waters.
Long ago, he was already a visionary with his epic music. I was one of those kids to whom he showed a candle in the dark. Never ever I have seen so deep friendship in a man as Roger holds for “Diamond” Syd.
Today, his actions are about to become even more important than his music.
Roger – if ever you should have a look at this site – let me tell you that your action is very important and the right thing to do.
I share and endorse your views, Sir.