by Jimmie Moglia
The Italians said “no” in the recent referendum. Its main objective was to reform the Italian Constitution, strengthen the authority of the government and reduce the power of the electorate at large to influence political outcomes.
Unskilled in political autopsies, I will not discuss details amply elucidated elsewhere, in the mainstream and alternative media.
But ever prone to scour the useless in search for the irrelevant, I will talk about the 3 regions that voted ‘yes’ in the Referendum.
The most unusual of the three is Alto Adige (South Tyrol). It is a land that Austria was forced to cede to Italy at the end of WWI. The cost was 600,000 Italians dead and probably as many Austrians. South Tyrol is and was inhabited for centuries by German speaking people of German (Austrian) roots and culture.
Mussolini first destroyed the old Tyrolean structure of the capital (Bozen – Bolzano) and replaced it with fascist-style architecture. Then he changed all toponyms of South Tyrol with Italian names, banning from use the historical originals.
It’s a case where the old assumption that “… a rose by any other name would smell a sweet” does not apply, because the obliteration of names was to signify indirectly the obliteration (or at least the inferior status) of the natives.
This and other issues caused continual friction between the established Germans and the newly established Italians. In recent decades the situation improved and the friction, by and large, subsided.
But before the referendum, the Italian government apparently promised that, in case of a yes, the original German names would be fully restored.
The other two regions that voted ‘yes’ are Emilia and Tuscany. Here, rather than dealing with the finer details of the reform, I will suggest a wider historical view.
For we can still travel upstream in time towards the origins that led to today’s events, before these origins fade into a shadowy past and sink into darkness. Or turn into arguments treated by bespectacled and respectable historians, writing histories read by the chosen few and ignored by the other many.
At the end of WWII, as we know, Italy and most of Europe lay in ruin (both winners and losers). And as per the Yalta Allied Agreement, Europe was divided into two spheres of influence, East and West.
Western Europe was ripe for social reforms, which – it is fair to say – would never have been possible without the fear of popular revolutions. Revolutions that America was determined to block with any possible means.
The social reforms of Western Europe (as well as the current Italian Constitution) were born in the period 1946-1950.
Even so, the Italian Communist Party was the most powerful in Europe – its leader, Togliatti, had even been secretary to Stalin. The Communist threat enabled America to convert Italy into an American military base – there are currently 114 military offices and massive land, naval and air bases throughout the peninsula and the islands. All this to defend a land that has no enemies.
Then in the 1960s the situation somewhat changed. The USSR continued to subsidize the Italian Communist party, but it was the proverbial chicken feed, compared to the dollars freely printed by the Federal Reserve for use by the CIA everywhere, including Italy.
Partly through a softening of the Vatican position towards the political infidels, (after the Second Vatican Council), partly through the irresistible appeal of power, and of access to the government trough, the Communist intelligentsia (at least some of them) began talking with the their opposition.
Meantime, the Italians were first softened and treated to “words more sweet, and yet more dangerous.”
New expressions came into circulation, for example:
** “Parallel convergences” (read, we, Communists and Christian Democrats can feed at the trough together while keeping our nominally separate aims), and,
** “Historic compromise” (read, Communists in government).
This (Communists in government), was anathema to the colonial master, who needed then (as now), an enemy, so as to keep feeding the trillions to the military & associates. The issue cost the Italian Prime Minister of the time, Aldo Moro, his life.
Eventually, the “parallel convergences” and the “historic compromise” came about in an unusual and unpredictable way. The third or fourth “republic” was declared ended, to be replaced by a new “republic”, not much different in substance from the one just ended, except for the fanfare and the “hunt for the corrupt.”
This resulted in the substitution of a corrupt legislature, (but with some lingering restraints due to the historical ideological differences), with a much more corrupt legislature, uncontrolled, uncontrollable and unrestrained, given that the Communist party had blended with its enemy and, together with them, became known for what it is now, the PD (Partito Democratico).
Something similar occurred elsewhere in Europe. For example, to call the French party currently in power “socialist” equates to choosing “House of Virginity” as a title-name for a brothel.
Back in Italy, now everything was possible, starting from the gradual removal of the social structures installed after the war, followed by the entry into the European Union. A wonderful device, for now the national government could claim no responsibility in the dismantling of the social system, for “it is the will of Europe.” In the meantime, gone was too the old structure of production, caused by globalization.
With everyone (in government and in the opposition) at the trough, all restraint was (is) eliminated. Easiest way to riches was (is) through pharaonic never ending projects, producing a cornucopia of friendly subcontractors and marvels of financial engineering (read fraud).
Just the cost of the study for a potential and very questionable bridge between the mainland and to Sicily is in the billion $. Old Olympic villages costing other billions now lay in ruins. No one but the profiteers want the high-speed train line that is defacing the beautiful Alpine Susa Valley. There are already two tunnels, road and railway.
One of the latest venture was last year’s Milan Exhibition, whose mega-losses were only modestly mentioned by the government media.
Even so, given that the Communists were historically strongest in Emilia and Tuscany, there is some logic in believing that remembrance of things past may have driven some older Emilian and Tuscan citizens to vote accordingly. The majority of the ‘yes’ came from the older generation. Emilia, in particular, was ever the hot bed of Italian hot heads, Mussolini included.
In Tuscany, the wide net of nepotistic alliances fostered by the Florentine prime minister and his associates, may have played a role.
Talking of nepotism, the word “nepotismo” comes from the Latin “nepos”, “nephew”, or “nipote” in Italian. But why not relative (“parente”), for example, or familiare (“family member”) – what has a “nipote” to do with it?
Being a “snapper up of unconsidered trifles” here is a brief excursion in the world of the not-usually-talked-about.
Back in 1154 AD, there occurred the schism that divided the Catholic from the Orthodox Church. Some of the points of difference were abstruse and theological. In practice, one of the items of contention was the celibacy of the priests, or lack thereof. Priests can marry, said the Orthodox – no they should not, said the Catholic. The two parties ended up following their own separate ways.
Unable to marry, Catholics priests, including the Popes, chose alternative options. For example, Alexander VI Borgia had 4 children from his favorite lover Vannozza Cattanei, and 5 from other “unknown Roman women” – at least this is in the official records.
Popes were generous with their offspring, but they could not claim them as sons or daughters (remember the schism). So they were all nieces and nephews (nipoti), hence “nepotism.”
Back to the referendum. The prime minister resigned from the government but not from the party – hence his political death was greatly exaggerated. Do not consign, as yet, the Florentine Renzi boy to the archives of Italian politics. One Italian newspaper defines him as a “baboon taught by J.P. Morgan to perform in the Italian political circus.” And training a baboon is still an investment not to be disposed off too easily.
The statistics on Italian unemployment are a joke. To understand them would “dizzy the arithmetic of memory”. Or rather, to quote Churchill in one of his rare moments of sincerity, “The only reliable statistics are those that we falsified.”
If you work for an hour a week at a MacDonald you count as employed. Most young people struggle to find employment. The job un-protection measures recently imposed in Italy and France have just about written off the last remnants of the post WW2 social reforms.
Chronicles frequently report of middle-age men killing themselves after their employer closed down or moved operations to the Orient – and they cannot find other employment. Many young people still live with their parents. Unable to find a job, let alone a steady one – their majority voted “no”.
The Italian Internet exudes happiness at the defeat of the referendum, as if it signaled a new era of hope and resurgence. I think the hopes are unwarranted.
Something similar has occurred in the US with the recent elections. Given the Clintons’ stench-machine and their porno-pedo-homo-maso-transgender entourage, even a skunk would have felt as a breath of fresh air. But as for meaningful changes, (other than, hopefully, avoiding WW3), we can already smell disappointment in the air.
Some very amusing, creative turns of phrase there.
“even a skunk would have felt as a breath of fresh air” , ya Trump is also a real stinker
“to call the French party currently in power “socialist” equates to choosing “House of Virginity” as a title-name for a brothel” Can say the same about both the Canadian Liberals or New Democrats
“to quote Churchill in one of his rare moments of sincerity” Lord Acton would be proud!
Could we borrow your time-machine that you obviously used to ‘prove’ “Trump is also a real stinker”?
America has always been built-up and run by the ultra-powerful, ultra-rich, and ultra-well-connected. So Trump’s cabinet picks are about the most *honest* you could possibly imagine- laying bare the real actual American system for all to see. Trump doesn’t even attempt a fig-leaf of deceit, unlike every other president before him- he doesn’t see the point, and good for him.
As the above article proves, the Italian people have just wasted their time, given how powerful the Vatican and the Anglo-zionist Empire is in Italy. There is nothing worse than self-fooling sheeple who think their ‘vote’ has achieved anything.
America is different because Britain wanted Britain 2 to be a *very* new form of nation- one that ran to completely different rules to those seen in the ‘Old World’ of Europe. This has made the USA an unprecedented power in Human History- but with that extraordinary power comes a unique vulnerability to ‘people power’ that just doesn’t exist anywhere else.
Why do you think we witnessed a co-ordinated attack (by the press, leaders of the West and even leaders of the Republican party) never before witnessed against Trump? Why do you think we are witnessing a “Trump will never make it to the inauguration” movement in the USA? You really think that’s because Trump is another Bush or Reagan?
You may hate Trump for a whole bunch of reasons (most of which boil down to the jealousy beta males feel toward very successful alpha males), but one thing he is not is another standard politician. The Blair years (the time from the rise of Tony Blair to the present) have been pure demonic madness- and no way any part of that makes sense to a man like Trump. Why on Earth should Trump think the USA should be at loggerheads with Russia- what possible logic does that have? None!
Why should the USA support wahhabi horrors, and bring down modern secular nations with an Islamic tradition- like Libya, Iraq and Syria? To Trump such a strategy is the most moronic thing in the world. This is why you are seeing so many forces rally against Trump- including people you were convinced were on our side. The Deep State has agents embedded in every major supposed pro-Human movement- most of the agents being in leadership or moderation positions. And they are activating these agents as I type- even at the cost of losing the influence these agents have as many of them make their true masters all too clear.
The left-right paradigm is the ultimate *fake* in the West. But too many awake people naively think the *organised* left as more trustworthy than the organised right. Nothing could be further from the truth. Blair came from the left as did Clinton. The Deep State has far more difficulty fully compromising the organised right- for powerful psychological reasons – the right has too many powerful independent alpha males who *hate* thinking of themselves as followers. Many of these are wicked, wicked people, of course- but even so they are extraordinarily hard to control.
The significant players in the organised left tend to be very psychologically weak people by comparison- and co-opting them is usually childs-play.
The demons do not fear revolt in any non-english speaking nations of the West- certainly not in France, Germany or Italy. Learn a little History to understand why. *But* the demons fear people power in the UK a little, and people power in the USA a very great deal indeed. Trump can set something in motion that will set back the plans of the demons for maybe 10-20 years, and that is something they cannot accept.
I Hope You’re Right About Trump.
Now Twilight, that’s a fine, bold comment
That makes good points, and has more balls.
Long ago we knew what Natural Law meant.
And that partly reflected in Government’s halls.
The Donald, our brand new President-Elect?
I don’t know him all that thoroughly well, yet.
For sure he’ll need much help, so I do expect,
A lot more real Americans to finally show a set.
@ Twilight and Bro 93:
WOW, Saker being on that WaPo list must have directed some partisan USicans here. Enjoy your stay, but don’t look for a lot of attaboys (unless you get your sockpuppets to do it for you), tough crowd here, you’re not on Breitbart anymore.
It doesn’t take a crystal ball to see that “post truth” (not so much intentional lies, just garden variety bullshit-baffles-brains) Trump will be a lame duck from the day he swears the Oath (McConnell stated as much today, no Congressional Repuglican support for big tax cuts or Donny-boy’s “uuuge” spending plans). Is Trump going to rule by Executive Order like he criticized Obama for doing?
A serial (intentional) bankrupt/tax-dodger and morally questionable game show host ended up headed for the Oval Office by the admitted MSM manipulations of the Dumbocrat Clinton Machine which saw him as more “beatable” than the other Repuglican contenders. I don’t “hate” Trump, I just think he’s not Presidential material, which Mrs. Clinton isn’t either, her demonstrated psychopathic corrupt warmonger past on full display. It is doubtful the US party system can produce a real leader anymore, too many interests (think Citizen$ United) to be repaid in kind. Don’t pretend Trump doesn’t owe anyone anything or is not required to at least somewhat toe the Washington establishment line, his projected appointments are just more deceptive Wall Streeters and deluded dick-swinging MIC Generals. He’s not rich enough run much afoul of the ambitions of Soros, Koch Bros, Rockefellers et. al. He very carefully pledged allegiance to Israel, so to not overtly piss off the Rothschilds and their powerful minions.
That you can’t see Trump’s obvious relevant flaws, or choose to misdirect readers from them, is the weakness in your argument (if it can be called that, mostly a lot of pseudo-philosophical/psychological bullshit-baffles-brains twaddle).
Saker readers can’t avoid the Trumpist talking points and bully-pulpitisms in any MSM and too many internet “news” outlets, so no need for you to restate it in the comments here.
The apple doesn’t fall far from the tree, and the Trump family fortune was instigated by his grandfather skipping out of mandatory military service back in Germany (illegally immigrating, how ironic) to find fortune running brothels in the US/Canadian gold rushes. How different today would be if the US had deported grandpa Trump as Donny wants to do to so many now. So not so different from the other US (or anywhere else in the world) elite families lying, cheating and bullying their way to the top.
So ya, I think Trump will be as big a stinker as any President, given few managed to actually do what was in the best interests of most US citizens, without running roughshod over the rights and best interests of the citizens of other countries. The Ugly American stereotype didn’t invent itself in the minds of other countries’ citizens, USicans created it all on their own. And you just perpetuated it…
Thank you Jimmie, if for nothing else, the rich accompaniment of hyperbole and metaphor to enliven a dead-beat topic – Italian politics. Yet, we are none the wiser about the referendum (I mean, me) and how the result might impinge on other developments elsewhere, notwithstanding your admission that you don’t like to dissect political events. For instance, is there a likelihood of a “nationalist” consensus emerging from the NO factions and leading to the removal of the US occupation forces from Italy?
Thanks for this article – it really clarifies what went in and the real implications of the vote.
The establishment will regroup and try to carry on business as usual – it will be interesting to watch to see if alternative political parties have been strengthened by their referendum campaigns to get more votes in the future
The 5 star movement is almost as strong as Renzi’s party, and the hope of many is that they will win the next elections. They are for bringing back democracy, calling a referendum on staying in the euro zone with a strong emphasis on alternative energy. .They are also for changes to the european union and against globalisation in the form it has become.
Italy being threatened by the global financial mafia one more time
http://bit.ly/2gteoQI
You are way too negative. Trump will do all he has said and much, much more. Please don’t look on the’ everybody’s doing it’ meme and sink. This guy is made of sterner stuff. Really.
There is a huge battle going on at the moment in the US but the bad guys eventually are taken out if my foresight is in full working order. The elites will simply go down in a non-French revolution manner i.e. a manner more dignified and more thorough than ‘la Revolution’. Fidel might be dead but he has been resurrected in thousands of hearts nay millions nay hundreds of millions nay billions of hearts. One might reasonably conclude this little rant with “Its all over red rover …if your are a pig with its snout in the trough.”
Regards
Trump is not cut from the same cloth as Fidel, doesn’t deserve mention in the same breath. You are correct, Fidel IS getting a great deal of traction, despite the US/NATO/MSM’s attempts to bury his memory. But occasionally even the US/NATO echo-chamber BBC can’t keep the truth from being broadcast.
http://medialens.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=834:bbc-propaganda-watch-tell-tale-signs-that-slip-through-the-cracks&catid=54:alerts-2016&Itemid=248
Trump is all great and wonderful when his wealth and a legion of media spinners, lawyers and tax accountants can cow underlings and opponents, or manipulate the system in his favour. Convincing both Congressional Houses full of anti-Trumpers to pass his seat-of-the-pants foreign policy and voodoo economics will be nearly insurmountable. He can’t just tell Congress “you’re fired”, and he’ll have to start goring some working class MAGA supporters’ oxen to satisfy other (wealthier) supporters. Gonna be a LOOOONG 4 years for Trumpites.
can somebody in the media ever talk about facts?
please read the changes to the constitution they wanted
art 70 where it is established had the laws would be approved in the priposed changes is unreadable and incomprehensible.
do you pro renzi want a country where we don t even know how to pass a law ?
come on !!!!!!
The article also lacked to name the new prime-minister Giraldi – who wasn’t elected but named – who is the-facto continuation of Renzi, and the fact that the new elections cannot be hold before amending the new law of elections. Another miss, is Beppe Grillo and his Five Stars movement which have a great impact in the outcome of the referendum.
Of course, Paolo Gentiloni
Congratulations Moglia, very much to the point
Thanks for that Jimmy, I particularly liked your explanation of ‘nepotism’ and the old warmonger Churchill’s quote is a classic.
Since the Troika’s financial dismemberment schemes for Greece became obvious, everyone has been wondering who is next, Spain, Portugal or Italy, who were all seduced into a similar state of bankruptcy for which draconian austerity for the masses is the only solution on offer.
TINA, there is no alternative, was Thatcher’s warcry, and here it comes again. It is stultifying and monotonous and clearly intended to smother any alternative possible solutions.
I hope the resistance builds but fear that the old ‘strategy of tension’ that took out Aldo Moro has been dusted off for another outing ‘pour encourager les autres.’
Muito bom esse artigo.
Aqui no Brasil (República das Bananas) seguimos com fidelidade a desgraça do NEPOTISMO… herança maldita das oligarquias.
Acredito que em todo o mundo tem sido usada a maior arma de DESTRUIÇÃO EM MASSA a “Prestitute” infelizmente o ÓPIO soprado ao povo tem causado delírios de libertação… Que sabemos que assim como os efeitos do ópio são de momentosa euforia e depois vem acompanhado de profunda angústia e depressão…
Aqui um congresso bandido GÂNGSTERES tirou Dilma honesta e colocou Don Corleone e seus Capangas…
Computer translation from Portuguese:
Very good this article.
Here in Brazil (Banana Republic) follow with fidelity the misfortune of NEPOTISM… inheritance cursed the privilege of a few.
I believe that the whole world has been used the greatest weapon of MASS DESTRUCTION the “Prestitute” unfortunately the OPIUM blown to the people has caused delusions of liberation… That we know that as well as the effects of opium are of momentous euphoria and then comes with deep anguish and depression…
Here a congress thug GANGSTERS took Dilma honest and put Don Corleone and his Henchmen…
Regarding South Tyrol:
http://www.suedtiroler-freiheit.com/neue-regierung-in-italien-das-chaos-regiert-weiter/
Article translated from the original German via Google Translate:
“New government in Italy: chaos continues to rule.
press release December 12, 2016
Süd-Tiroler Freiheit expects the new Italian Prime Minister to continue chaospolitics in Italy and thus have a negative impact on South Tyrol. Paolo Gentiloni is now the fourth Prime Minister in a row, whose government was not elected by the people. Through these undemocratic conditions, more and more citizens are losing their trust in politics and turning to opportunistic parties and politicians who demand a withdrawal from the euro and from the EU.
With this policy, Italy is heading against the wall with full throttle and South Tyrol is in the lead with ─ thanks to the courtesy of the SVP ─.
In Italy, nothing is as certain as the uncertainty. It is therefore time to finally create security for South Tyrol and to look at exit scenarios from Italy, says Sven Knoll, Member of the Parliament of the South Tyrolean Freedom.
The SVP will surely call Gentiloni again as a great friend of South Tirol and advocate of autonomy. That this is not much more than a desperate wish of the SVP, which has inflicted great damage with their agreement to the constitutional reform of South Tyrol, shows the previous political behavior of Gentiloni.
Already 10 years ago (!) ─ on 22 November 2006 ─ between Luis Durnwalder and Paolo Gentiloni (at that time still telecommunication minister) was negotiated the transfer of the administrative powers in the matter of postal by the country. Gentiloni had promised a quick solution. Nothing happens. On the contrary! The conditions at the post office are now worse than ever.
L.-Ed. Sven Knoll.”
My thoughts :
Süd-Tiroler Freiheit is a political party in South Tyrol with representation in the regional parliament.
Since the majority of South Tyroleans voted “yes,” does this mean the promise of reintroducing German would be kept? (sarcasm)
Regarding “…everyone (in government and in the opposition) at the trough,” the SVP is a local German party that has routinely been accused of “selling out” to the Italian government. Many South Tyroleans tend to equate the Italian government with Mussolini and with financial engineering (fraud) and therefore would prefer to leave Italy and merge South Tyrol with either Austria or Switzerland.
Jimmie Moglia wrote: “This and other issues caused continual friction between the established Germans and the newly established Italians. In recent decades the situation improved and the friction, by and large, subsided.”
This is why the frictions in South Tyrol have subsided. No other region in Italy enjoys this benefit:
From Wikipedia:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_South_Tyrol#The_second_agreement
“The new autonomous status, granted from 1972 onwards, has resulted in a considerable level of self-government, also due to the large financial resources of the province of Bolzano/Bozen, retaining almost 90% of all levied taxes.”
Who benefits from all of the ongoing chaos in Italy? Why can’t the Italians organize their government structures to resemble the institutions in Germany?
Holy Cow! Great post, LK! Good eye! Thank you for reading and contributing to The Vineyard of the Saker.
“Who benefits from all of the ongoing chaos in Italy? Why can’t the Italians organize their government structures to resemble the institutions in Germany?”
I love Italy. I love Germany.
So don’t throw stones at me when I report that a German explained the essential difference between the two places when he answered your 2016 question in 1990:
“Here we like efficiency and order, and being on time.”
“In Italy what they like is to park a bus in the traffic circle in the middle of town and cause a massive traffic pile-up. Then everyone can pile out of the shops and cafes and shout at each other and wave their arms and make gestures with their hands.”
‘But as for meaningful changes, (other than, hopefully, avoiding WW3), we can already smell disappointment in the air.’
I concur
The ‘elite’ are well organized and well resourced
The great unwashed are disorganized and because of that their resources compared to the ‘elite’ are as a flea trying to rape an elephant.
As the ‘elite’ are fully aware of, the great unwashed need a leader to spur them into action. Oh, they will grumble and grumble, but do nothing of their own accord, essentially because they are deeply conservative and do not like change. On that, the elite are as one with them.
If a leader does emerge, it is oh so easy to either corrupt or silence that leader.
http://www.voltairenet.org/article194423.html
I’ve sent this through. But in future please post a comment also. We don’t normally accept just links to articles.MOD
So true just like the 1970’s Who song made reference to WE WONT GET FOOLED AGAIN. “The parting to the right is parting to the left “Look at the new boss same as the old boss.””. Its we the sheeple that always get the short end of the stick. I might add Gentiloni the new PM has said that he is in favour of government reform and that both houses had passed the suggested proposals that failed at the referendum. Which is double speak for we will let the waters settle and since parliament has passed the reforms anyway stuff the referendum. I being of Italian background know to well how things work in Italy. The whole left right divide are all smokey mirrors.