By Anwar Khan
What is the moral difference–if any– between the intentional shooting at fleeing civilians and using them as human shields on the one hand, and the flattening of entire neighborhoods, killing hundreds of innocent civilians, on the pretext of the presence of enemy fighters there-in, on the other? The answer is that there is no moral difference. Both are high crimes under any book, and it is being perpetrated on the people of Mosul as we speak. The first is done by ISIS– the Frankenstein that crept out of the Empire’s Research and Development labs, with the sole aim of destroying Muslim societies, disparaging the name of Islam, and advancing the march towards Full Spectrum Dominance— and the second is perpetrated by the Empire’s military might in broad day light, on the pretext of annihilating the very monster that it created. In between a most vicious massacre of innocent people is being perpetrated, with an almost complete media blackout.
(Side Note: Not that the knowledge of such crimes would bother much the moral nerves of the western world, who have come to accept scenes of dead Muslims as a phenomenon as normal as cloud formation. Between slavish work to pay for what they call life, celebrity worship, and the collective immolation of the soul that takes place in the dark temples we call cinemas— mirroring very much the darkness that encompasses the modern conscience—one wonders if idle time could be spared to show moral revulsion to such crimes. Yes, candles are lit and tears shed to the unfortunate victims at home, but the Muslim lands are simply too far, too unknown, and too “other” to cause any discomfort of the conscience)
While the Syrian and Russian offensive to retake Aleppo from the terrorists saw much crocodile tears from the Empire’s media, the Mosul offensive or Inherent Resolve—where Coalition air strikes have turned the city into a heap of rubble hiding a virtual urban graveyard inside its belly— is not even mentioned in passing. The amount of suffering that the people of Mosul have faced since the operation began is difficult to compare to anything in our times, including the Syrian war theatre which is as cruel as modern warfare can be. The scenes from Mosul Jadida(New Mosul) area are reminiscent of Dresden during the Second World War.
The Guardian reported Chris Woods, the director of monitoring group Airwars, to have said: “The Jadida incident alone is the worst toll of a single [airstrike] incident that I can recall in decades. The coalition’s argument that it doesn’t target noncombatants risks being devalued when so many civilians are being killed in west Mosul.” He is referring to a coalition airstrike that killed over 200 civilians mostly children, women and elderly seeking shelter in a building. The mounting human suffering and infrastructural destruction is of such a scale that the Iraqi Army, conducting the ground offensive, had to call off its advance fearing that the operation has slid into a catastrophe, thanks to the coalition’s Make America Great Again strategy.
(Side Note: You wonder where is Hollywood and George Clooney and their crocodile tears which they shed incessantly for the people of Sudan– who we were told were going through a “genocide”– eventually leading to imperial intervention and creation of South Sudan. How courageous of these celebrities to root for imperial causes and then hide in their holes when true courage is needed?)
Those who still harbor any doubts about the Empire being beyond redemption and salvation need to see its conduct in Mosul to realize how utterly indifferent it is to human suffering, or even to public opinion, which was of some concern, purely for PR reasons, not too long ago. But when the imperial hubris has reached such proportions that it cannot be even bothered to explain why shelters housing children and women are blown into oblivion for the sake of one ISIS fighter, you surely have entered what I call the Curse Stage, a particular stage in the stagnation of empires when there is not even a veneer of moral pretense behind its conduct. It is the homestretch of the unraveling. It cannot possibly be reversed.
“Once the Heavens cast the dice of fate, it shall not be reversed, even when a million supplication intersect its path”. Hafiz Shirazi
What is also there to be witnessed is that the same western world that always held Russia to be morally inferior to the ideals of the Enlightenment, part of “the primitive and cruel East”, have fared infinitely more inhumane and cruel in its conduct of warfare under very similar circumstances. The Russian method displayed in the Aleppo offensive was one that regarded avoidance of civilian suffering as the driving factor in its formation. Humanitarian corridors were formed with aid and shelter also being provided in some areas. It took months of meticulous planning and coordination with local partners, and even with the rebels to guarantee their and their families’ safe passage. It was a diplomatic and humanitarian master class of an act. Carpet-bombing of Aleppo would have been a rather easier choice. But the “primitive and cruel” Easterner had a soul after all.
The Coalition on the other hand, forbade the creation of any human corridors which would have allowed many inhabitants to leave the city. This was proposed by the Iraqi government but refused by the Coalition. Their rationale to the Iraqi government was that “they feared ISIS will trickle out of the city with the civilians”. They were told to have faith in the Coalition’s “precision strikes”. To the media they would say “well its ISIS that is not allowing civilians to leave, not us”, which actually is not entirely true. The fact is that they wanted to send a clear message to the world with the new administration’s military strategy in the Muslim lands, featuring Trump as Krishna: Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds.
This article can go in many directions. I can begin with how Mosul fell in ISIS hands to begin with; the conduct of ISIS terrorists of systematic terror to “reform” its citizens; the role of Turkish, Gulf states and the Kurdish intelligence agencies with ISIS during its four year occupation (yes, even the “anti-ISIS” Kurdish leaders like Jalal Talabani and Masoud Barzani had intimate relationship with ISIS and often allowed them safe passages to conduct its operations. The ultimate Kurdish goal was to annex Mosul to Barzani and Talabani’s fiefdoms when the conditions were ripe). But today I have one concern only and that is the plight of the innocent civilians and the dead children under the rubble.
I am embedding a video here (with my edits and translation) that my Iraqi friends (whose families are still trapped in Mosul) sent me to watch, and help spread the word on the unspoken suffering that the people of Mosul have to persevere. I promised them to do my part, knowing well the fate of such writings when it meets the dead conscience of the modern media consumer. God forbid that the comrades here on this site have such a disposition. But the fact remains that in our times, no matter how deeply shocking an event comes to our knowledge, it does not stay long enough deep inside our conscience to bother the usual trajectory of our lives (this happens even to the most soft-hearted amongst us) But it has to be said nonetheless, whether it finds the desired place or not. That’s the least we owe to the dead children under the rubble–their little bodies still warm from the not too long ago association with life.
The Prophet of Islam is reported to have said “whosoever see an evil, let him stop it with his hand; if he is not able, then with his tongue, and if he is not able to do so, then with his heart— and that is the least of faith.” (The masculine pronoun is inclusive of the feminine, lest the more gender-sensitive raise an issue with that). I am doing the least of what the faith and humanity requires.
The video shows a government official inspecting the part of Mosul most affected by the coalition airstrikes, and gathering first-hand information on the nature of the offensive and plight of the people. Please do watch the entirety of it. I will leave you with one quote from her that sums up the Mosul offensive:
“After meeting many people and hearing the reports from all sides, it has become abundantly clear to me, and I can swear to God on this, that there are no more than 6 or 5 ISIS fighters in the entire New Mosul area and they walk around freely in open streets and amazingly they are not targeted. Yet what is targeted are entire neighborhoods and houses containing shelter seeking civilians. And all this on the pretext of targeting these ISIS fighters. It is very clear that the idea is to just destroy Mosul and nothing else”. Basma Basem, President of Mosul Judiciary Council.
{From God we come and to Him shall we return}–Common Muslim statement on hearing the news of death.
Post Script: Since this article, which was first written on March 20th, there finally has been some media coverage. RT has been especially active and credit should go to them. But the scale of suffering is still far from being portrayed accurately.
Also, the subtitles could have been more viewer friendly, alas, that’s the extent of my video editing skills.
It’s a great article. Thank you for it. I’ve not watched the video yet: I’m depressed enough as is.
One trivial matter: you referred to Trump as Krishna, “Destroyer of Worlds.” It was actually the god Shiva (known as “The Destroyer”) who referred to himself that way.
I used to be proud to be an American. I felt sorry for anyone was a citizen of any other country in the world. The Vietnam War began to change my attitude. And now… I shall stop here. I really don’t want a surprise visit from the FBI. But at times I’m torn between wanting to cry, or vomit—or both.
Thanks for that article, Mr. Khan. And thanks for posting it, Saker.
David Ronin,
Thanks for the comment. Though I am no expert in Hinduism, I believe that comment is indeed subscribed to Krishna.
The above popularized by J. Robert Oppenheimer actually comes from a longer version:
“Lord Krsna said: I am terrible time the destroyer of all beings in all worlds, engaged to destroy all beings in this world; of those heroic soldiers presently situated in the opposing army, even without you none will be spared”.
Chapter 11 verse 32.
http://www.bhagavad-gita.org/Gita/verse-11-30.html
Hi Anwar, it took me a while to read your article because I had to get it printed as I don’t have great comprehension reading a deep moving article on the screen.
Thank you for the sad and shocking aritcle. Is it getting any better in Mosul ? Are there people helping ? I have never been to a war zone, but your article has made it very clear what an awful think the States has done there.
It seems obvious to me that Trump did that air strike to get the attention diverted from this mess in Mosul. What you say is so true – people are used to hearing about decimation in the East and because its so far away, nobody even cares too much, or only for a moment. So sad. I wish I could help somehow.
What we all need to understand is that all this is the plan, has been since 91 and before. In the west our leaders are evil and population blinded by cnn. And could care less anyway. Our elections rigged and people miss informed. The elected mear spokesman, actor’s really.
Thats the good news. The bad news is that we likely cant be eliminated without smoking the whole planet, so far.
‘The elected mear (sic) spokesman, actor’s really’
That was glaringly obvious with the election of Ronald Reagan – the ‘gentlemen’ stopped even pretending then, but the world did not notice.
Think about how he changed America and what the world has been like ever since – 1987, he unleashed that spawn of the devil Greenspan and he unleashed the slave philosophy of neo-liberal economics
….. yes, we in the west are all being turned into slaves, as was so aptly put in a previous article – ‘Gentlemen and Slaves’
The mainstream media, the movies ….. all leading us to ignorance …. the slaves have no time or energy to think for themselves
….. and from our ignorance, black holes in the west’s soul are appearing …. like Mosul
Your last sentence looks like paranoid nonsense. Flu virus could cut a swathe of destruction through the human population , leaving the planet in good shape.
Sure politicians are paid shills but that is the inevitable consequence of the particular version of democracy currently in vogue. That could change. But if the population does not care, then little will change.
A relatively free existence is still available to those with the wit to decouple from the system, but it means going without a lot of modern conveniences.
You pays your money , and you takes your choices :-)
“A relatively free existence is still available to those with the wit to decouple from the system, but it means going without a lot of modern conveniences. You pays your money , and you takes your choices :-)”
Yes, Mr. Farmerbraun. I have been doing exactly this for the past 7 years or so since I was (very luckily) fired from my job. Until now, I have not realized how enjoyable and free life can be if you have “the wit to decouple from the system.” Actually, I am now reluctant to elaborate on my freedom for fear “they” might come back to force me to join the miserable mainstream by offering me a “good job.” It would be disastrous for me. I would probably not survive it.
How does it go? ‘Freedom is having nothing left to lose.”
Start sharing this article and vid as a matter of urgency.
Thank you Anwar for helping to expose the criminal enterprise that is the ‘liberation’ of Mosul.
The Innocent Must Die to evict ISIS.
And that you can thank Dem’s and Obama for.
ISIS is there creation.
And many more Innocents Will Die.
Cancer is a B@&$H!!
No, Anwar Khan is perfectly right. There’s no difference between the U$ Army/NATO and ISIS/Saudis. Both are a bunch of fortune seeking, deranged, Zionist indoctrinated, child mass murdering mercenaries. Both are intruders, and nothing but filthy contemptible whores of the Zionist banksters (Pharisaic Talmudism). Some of these psychopaths are Zionist ‘Christians’ (U$ Army) and some of them are Zionist ‘Muslims’ (Saudis/ISIS). The idea of these Zionist house negros’ masters (pedophiles) is to destroy Iraq. (very unlike the Russian Army)
Such a heart-breaking situation. The poor people losing whole families is beyond comprehension. The evil empire will pay dearly for such attrocities when war will visit them.
Its not about liberating Mosul or defeating the terrorist monster that the West along with her cronies created for the sake of the Ziocons . This death and destruction is about destroying the Iraqi Nation along with the Syrian Nation and guess what the next target is Iran . I recall Robert Fisk wondering why where they looting the Iraqi Museums in Baghdad during ‘shock and awe ‘ well Fisky the answer is simple -its to wipe the Iraqi Nation from the map . Something that the fanatical Likudniks were hollering about with regards to Ahmadinejad’ misconstrued statement .
Thanks for the Article and take care.
It’s very sad for those trapped in Mosul. First they must have had to put up with the corruption of the central govt, then the barbarity of isis, and now the “benevolent kindness” of the empire. They are already living in an apocalyptic world. May God protect the innocent and oppressed, and curse the oppressors.
Anwar Khan
Welcome to the zionazi and rightwing capitalist way of “doing business”. Not much has changed in the 21st century from the rightwing freakshow of the 19th century, other than the zionazis managed to hone the propaganda biz aspect of this sophisticated psywar against humanity into a psychopathic science.
Thanks Anwar, I had no idea it was so bad.
And mind you, not a single petition in sight from any of these organisations who want your signature for anything they can come up with. But then in situations were our voices are really needed, like for trying to save the people of Mosul and what’s left of their city, none of these jerks from Avaaz, Change, Activism, etc. seems to bother.
There is no justice on this earth
The wicked rule unhindered
But God sees all they do from birth
Their crimes will be remembered
The meek and merciful will be
rewarded for all time
But those who chose the evil way
will suffer for their crime
Very well said comrade!
This only goes to show that nations should have beefed up their anti-aircraft defense much much more. Libya should have spent their money on that while they still had it; and so should have Saddam Hussein, Assad and many others.
Plus Syria should have never de-mined its border with Turkey several years back when Turkey was feigning being a friend.
Harold Pinter’s 2005 Nobel Prize in Literature speech is even more relevant today in exposing the sickness that is the United States of America–and why so few people have the honesty or courage to call it out:
“Direct invasion of a sovereign state has never in fact been America’s favoured method. In the main, it has preferred what it has described as ‘low intensity conflict’. Low intensity conflict means that thousands of people die but slower than if you dropped a bomb on them in one fell swoop. It means that you infect the heart of the country, that you establish a malignant growth and watch the gangrene bloom. When the populace has been subdued – or beaten to death – the same thing – and your own friends, the military and the great corporations, sit comfortably in power, you go before the camera and say that democracy has prevailed.
[…]
The crimes of the United States have been systematic, constant, vicious, remorseless, but very few people have actually talked about them. You have to hand it to America. It has exercised a quite clinical manipulation of power worldwide while masquerading as a force for universal good. It’s a brilliant, even witty, highly successful act of hypnosis.
I put to you that the United States is without doubt the greatest show on the road. Brutal, indifferent, scornful and ruthless it may be but it is also very clever. As a salesman it is out on its own and its most saleable commodity is self love.”
http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/literature/laureates/2005/pinter-lecture-e.html
from an NPR interview with Amnesty International in which the spokesperson claims that instead of more appropriate bombs, the weapons being used have a large blast radius and that this contributes to the high death rates and lack of “precision” strikes.
sounds like war crime to me:
http://www.npr.org/2017/03/28/521823502/amnesty-international-criticizes-u-s-led-coalition-for-mosul-civilian-deaths
Shame, the poor, innocent ISIS supporting civilians, they are finally getting a slight taste of what their head chopping, human liver eating husbands, fathers, brothers and cousins have been inflicting on others in the region. Tragic.
Thank you Anwar for the heart rending account of the “Coalition” ‘s atrocities in Mosul. What’s new though? Their list of crimes is never ending and indeed the nasty American empire can’t care less for the mayhem it unleased against the “wrong” Arabs because they are there and in the way of the petrodollar and Jewish greed.
My only wish is that the criminal American-Zionist alliance and their supporters (namely the people who vote for such monsters) are one day visited by the horrors of their wicked deeds.
I think you have to realise that for most folk living in the dark evil that is the ‘free West’ just surviving day to day is about as much as most can manage.
Then there is the problem ‘it is dreadful what is happening in Mosul but what can I do as an individual about it?’ We write to our politicians about problems at home and they ignore us.
If we make too much fuss they put us in prison, or if you know and can prove the truth about our evil politicians and their masters, they declare you insane and put you in a mental hospital on medication.
It is reported that 40% of Britons have less than one hundred pounds (£100) in savings and that almost a third of the population do not have a bank account or access to loans.
Seventy years ago we were the greatest Empire the world has ever known on which the sun never set! Today we have food banks upon which several million people are dependent for food on a day to day basis. These people are either homeless sleeping rough, or if they have accommodation cannot afford heating or light!
Yes Mosul is dreadful, and yes we know our terrorist supporting government sells arms to terrorists and dictators as well, and yes we know the evil USA is the perpetrator of most criminal war crimes in the world, and yes we know our media lies to us…but just getting by ourselves is as much as we can achieve.
We live in a one party state, (the media lie is that we live in a multi party democracy), but we know fascism when we see fascism being exercised every day by our rulers.
We have Muslim problems of our own. And they are getting greater day by day as we indigenous are oppressed and the economic invaders, that pass themselves off as immigrants fleeing oppression, will not integrate and find every excuse for forcing change on us using our alien rulers to manipulate any and every situation they can create to get their own way.
While we have sympathy for your Mosul Muslims how will they feel when we get slaughtered in our homelands by their Muslim colleagues here when the SHTF and there is civil war?
The USA will bomb and terrorise us along with the EU military attacking us and our alien rulers will bring in mercenaries, to oppress us. It will happen, it may not happen, but we are fast approaching the point where we have nothing to lose (apart from the chains of economic slavery) to those people, those aliens who try to pass themselves off as part of us!
You expect too much Saker!
Pirouette
Thank you, Anwar.
Thank you Anwar for shedding light on the events in Mosul.
What I find most disturbing about this situation is that the so-called Iraqi government has teamed up with the American coalition in this demonic blood-letting of innocents. Very tragic!
This is not Trump. This is me. I did this.
This is not the pilot. Pilots cannot protest. They are punished for disobeying orders.
But if I would protest against Iraq war, nearly nothing would happen to me in US.
But I did not.
I did not when it started in 2003 and was going on all these 15 years.
I even cannot say “Sorry”. The comfort of my life and job in
Chicago means for me more than suffering people afar.
And please don’t blame me. I am not worse than other 100 million USAians who perhaps
even don’t know what Mosul or Iraq are. If each of us did even very little,
this war would not exist at all.
Frankly, the great human experiment failed so far. Humans are not able to be honest
and responsible. They even not able to admit the crimes they do.
There are only 500 photos published about Abu Graib, and the rest is still
covered up. Nobody wants to admit responsibility for MH17. After 2 years. Ha ha ha.
The race has been provided with the numerous humanity text books: Tora, Bible, Koran,
Yougasutra, … Instead of looking inside ownself with the aim of these books, humans
made these books a weapon of separation.
The future alien archaeologists will study civilization remnants and be surprised
what was wrong with the race.
Konstantin Kirillov
Chicago, USA.
PS:
https://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/09/opinion/evidence-of-prisoner-abuse-still-hidden.html?_r=0
Evidence of Prisoner Abuse, Still Hidden
9, 2016
“…Last year, Secretary of Defense Ashton Carter became the latest Pentagon chief to argue that the most damning images should remain concealed,..”
My comment: “What for does the nation lives with such point of view?”
http://landkey.net/Prosperity_pie/Perpetuum_Warbile.htm
I’m not one for collective guilt. How does it go ? You are not me….
But I am sorry for Iraqis. What can I say ? I watch everyday what the criminals are doing to the planet – and I hope that somehow the good people on this earth can get the planet out of the hands of the criminals. Its a long term thing I think.