by Pepe Escobar (cross-posted with The Asia Times – here and here – by special agreement with the author)
The new Great Game on the Roof of the World
On top of the graceful Baltit Fort, overlooking the Hunza Valley’s Shangri-La-style splendor, it’s impossible not to feel dizzy at the view: an overwhelming collision of millennia of geology and centuries of history.
We are at the heart of Gilgit-Baltistan, in Pakistan’s Northern Areas, or – as legend rules, the Roof of the World. This is an area about 70,000 square kilometers (27,000 square miles) crammed with spectacular mountain ranges and amidst them, secluded pristine valleys and the largest glaciers outside of the Polar region.
The location feels like vertigo. To the north, beyond the Batura Glacier, is the tiny northeast arm of Afghanistan, the legendary Wakhan corridor. A crest of the Hindu Kush separates Wakhan from the regional capital Gilgit. Xinjiang starts on Wakhan’s uppermost tip. Via the upgraded Karakoram highway, it’s only 240 km from Gilgit to the Khunjerab Pass, 4,934 meters high on the official China-Pakistan border.
What used to be called the Russian Pamir, now in Tajikistan, can be seen with naked eyes from one of the peaks of the Karakoram. To the east, past Skardu and an arduous trek that may last almost a month, lies K2, the second highest peak in the world, among a mighty group north of the Batura Glacier (also known as Baltoro), which is 63km long.
To the south lies Azad (“Free”) Kashmir and slightly to the southeast what locals define as Indian-occupied Kashmir. The former King of Kashmir agreed to be part of India after Partition in 1947 but troops were airlifted to the northern state and after a year of fighting, India went to the UN. A temporary ceasefire line was established in 1948 and runs down from the Karakoram towards the Nanga Parbat – the killer mountain, dividing Kashmir into two virtually sealed halves.
Massive mountain ranges
Driving across the Karakoram Highway (see part 2 of this report) we were face to face with three massive mountain ranges running in different directions. The Karakoram roughly starts where the Hindu Kush ends and then sweeps eastward – a watershed between Central Asian drainage and streams flowing into the Indian Ocean.
The Himalayas start in Gilgit and then run southeast through a cluster of high peaks, including the Nanga Parbat, directly on the Islamabad-Gilgit air route (flights by turboprop only take off if weather around the Nanga Parbat allows).
The Karakoram and the Himalayas are like an extension of each other, while the Hindu Kush starts in southern Afghanistan and ties up with the Karakoram north of the Hunza Valley. Within a radius of roughly 150 km from Gilgit and Skardu, there are no less than 90 peaks towering over 8,000m.
Strategically, this is one of the top spots on the planet, a protagonist of the original Great Game between imperial Britain and Russia. So it’s more than appropriate that here is exactly where a protagonist of the New Great Game, the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), the flagship project of the New Silk Roads, or Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), actually starts, linking western China’s Xinjiang to the Northern Areas across the Khunjerab Pass.
Karakoram politics
CPEC is the supreme jewel in the Belt and Road crown, the largest foreign development or investment program in modern China’s history, loaded with way more funds than years of US military aid to Islamabad.
And we are indeed in Ancient Silk Road territory. Looking at the millenary trail parallel to the Karakoram, lovingly restored by the Aga Khan Development Foundation, it’s easy to picture the great Chinese traveler Hiuen Tsang traversing these heights in the 7th Century, and naming them Polo-le. The Tang dynasty called it Great Polu. When Marco Polo trekked in the 14th Century, he called it Bolor.
Early last month, I was privileged to drive on the upgraded Karakoram Highway along CPEC all the way from Gilgit to the Khunjerab, and back, with multiple incursions to valleys such as lush, pine-forested Naltar, Shimshal (manufacturers of sublime yak wool shawls), Kutwal and receding glaciers, such as Hopper and Bualtar.
The Karakoram Highway was originally conceived in the 1970s as an ambitious political-strategic project able to influence the geopolitical balance in the subcontinent, by expanding Islamabad’s reach into previously inaccessible frontiers.
Now it’s at the heart of a trade and energy corridor from the China-Pak border all the way south to Gwadar, the port in Balochistan in the Arabian Sea a stone’s throw from the Persian Gulf. Gwadar looks likely to be a crucial springboard to China becoming a naval power – active from the Indian Ocean to the Persian Gulf and on to the Mediterranean, while CPEC, slowly but surely, aims to change the social and economic structure of Pakistan.
Previous Pakistani prime minister Nawaz Sharif, the controversial “Lion of the Punjab”, was an avid CPEC supporter after he won the 2013 elections. At the time current Prime Minister Imran Khan’s Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party, winner of elections held in July, had already polled second nationwide and rose to power in the strategic Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa province – straddling the area between Islamabad and the tribal belt.
Sharif, in June 2013, when he was about to enter negotiations with the Chinese, was lauding what would become CPEC as an infrastructure scheme that “will change the fate of Pakistan”. So far that has translated mostly into new hydroelectric dams, coal-fired power stations, and civil-nuclear power. The China National Nuclear Corporation is building two 1,100 MW reactors near Karachi for nearly $10 billion, 65% financed by Chinese loans. This is the first time that the Chinese nuclear industry has built something of this scale outside of their country.
More than a dozen CPEC projects involve power generation – Pakistan is no longer woefully energy-deprived. These projects may not be as sexy as high-speed rail and pipelines, which could arrive much later; after all CPEC in its planned entirety runs to 2030.
Of course, monumental business decisions will have to be addressed; the staggering cost – and state of the art engineering – involved in building a railway parallel to the Karakoram; and the fact that oil pumped via a pipeline from Gwadar to Xinjiang might cost five times more than via the usual sea lanes all the way to Shanghai.
What Imran wants
Imran Khan is way more cautious than Sharif, who had a “China cell” inside his office and commanded the Pakistani Army to set up a 10,000-strong security force to protect China’s CPEC investments.
But Khan knows well about the firepower behind CPEC: the Silk Road Fund, the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB), CITIC, Bank of China, EXIM, China Development Bank. The Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) projects that BRI could mobilize as much as $6 trillion in the next few years. What Khan wants is to negotiate better terms for Pakistan.
China’s ambassador to Pakistan, Yao Jing, never tires to stress that Pakistan’s serious debt problem relates to the initial phase of CPEC, due to the massive import of heavy machinery, industrial raw materials and services.
As I learned in Islamabad in various discussions with Pakistani analysts, Khan actually wants to expand CPEC and prevent it from leading Islamabad towards an unsustainable debt trap. That would mean tweaking CPEC’s focus away from too much infrastructure development to technology transfer and market access for Pakistani products. Financing for agriculture projects, for instance, could come via CPEC’s Long Term Plan, which unlike the so-called Early Harvest Plan does not come with a price tag attached and can be negotiated freely between Islamabad and Beijing.
According to a 2016 IMF report, $28 billion in projects included in Early Harvest will be completed by 2020: $10 billion to develop road, rail and port infrastructure, and $18 billion in energy projects via Foreign Direct Investment (FDI), with Chinese firms using commercial loans borrowing from Chinese banks.
CPEC though is an extremely long-term endeavor. Other CPEC investments in energy and transportation infrastructure financed by China will be finished only by 2030.
A new CPEC emphasis on industrialization via technology transfer would allow Pakistan to produce some of what China imports. That would imply renegotiating the Pakistan-China Free-Trade Agreement (FTA), getting to the level of preferential treatment that China offers to ASEAN. Essentially, this is what Imran Khan is aiming at.
Hail the Ismailis
Gilgit-Baltistan is the safest place in the whole of Pakistan. Here, there’s no “terror threat” by the Pakistani Taliban or dodgy al-Qaeda or ISIS spin-offs. Major spoken languages are Shina and Burushaski, not Urdu. The population is overwhelmingly composed of Ismaili Shi’ites – like Karim Shah, an encyclopedia of Central and South Asian history and culture reigning over a cave of wonders in Gilgit where anything from authentic heads of Gandhara Bodhisattvas to 18th Century silk Qom carpets from a Persian royal family can be found.
We spent hours talking about Khorasan, the original Kipling-esque Great Game, Col. Durand (who drew the Durand Line separating Pashtuns on both sides of an artificial border), the Kashmir question, the astonishingly complex geo-eco-historical system of the Northern Areas, and of course, China.
Shah imparted the impression – confirmed by other traders – that the local population may see some tangible CPEC-related benefits, but does not know exactly what Beijing wants. Chinese visitors – engineers, bureaucrats – are remote; tourism has not picked up yet, as in the case of the Japanese, who have been Northern Areas enthusiasts for decades. Thus, an improvement in Xi Jinping’s “people-to-people exchange”, a key component of BRI, seems to be in order.
Legend rules that Hunzakuts, the inhabitants of the glorious Hunza Valley, are descendants of three soldiers of Alexander the Great who married beautiful Persian women of high aristocracy. While Alexander campaigned along the Oxus, the three couples traveled across the Wakhan corridor, discovered the marvelous valley, and settled down.
The tolerant Islam they came to practice centuries later is impervious to Gulf proselytizing. When I crossed an austere village by the Karakoram, visibly out of place, my Ismaili driver Akbar noted that these were “Sunni Wahhabis”.
Finding Gandhara art in Gilgit made perfect sense. Gandhara historically formed a sort of fertile and irrigated triangle between the Iranian plateau, the Hindu Kush and the first peaks of the Himalayas. Between the 6th Century BC and the Islamic invasions, it was the crossroads of three cultures: India, China and Iran. And it was here that an extremely original Greco-Buddhist art and culture flourished, way after Greek power had waned.
The Kashmir question
As a new 21st Century crossroads, CPEC faces stern challenges – from geology (constant landslides and floods in Gilgit-Baltistan) to wobbly security in Balochistan, threatened by a combination of separatist and religiously or politically manipulated movements. I was not able to visit Gwadar and the south of CPEC even though contacts in Islamabad supplied military sources with an application for a NOC (No Object Certificate, as it is known on Pakistan) weeks in advance. The military response: too “sensitive”, as in dangerous, for a lone Western journalist, especially in the aftermath of the Aasia Bibi case.
China will need to find a way – perhaps via negotiations inside the Shanghai Cooperation Organization – to mollify India on CPEC’s route straddling Kashmir.
In 1936 the British made a deal with the Maharaja of Kashmir, getting Gilgit on lease for 60 years. But then came Partition. At the time the Kuomintang – in power in China, before Mao’s victory – was engaged in secret negotiations to restore Hunza’s fabled independence as a new state allied with China. But the Mir of Hunza finally decided to join the newborn Pakistani nation.
Few may remember that, during the 1950s, way before the India-China border war in 1962, there was trouble on the China-Pakistan border, when Beijing seized 3,400 square miles of Kashmir, including parts of old Hunza, whose Mirs always recognized Chinese suzerainty. When the British had first seized Hunza in 1891, the Mir actually fled to China.
This puts into perspective some fabulous documents preserved at Baltit Fort, like China-Baltistan trade agreements and a picture of Zhou EnLai visiting the fort in the early 1960s.
It’s also fascinating to remember that at the time Zhou Enlai already thought about Karachi – no Gwadar at that time – connecting to an “ancient trade route, lost to modern times, not only for trade but for strategic purposes as well”. Xi Jinping has definitely read his Zhou EnLai thoroughly.
Nowadays, the President of Azad (Free) Jammu and Kashmir, Sardar Masood Khan, always stresses that “unlike Indian propaganda”, the Pakistani side is “thriving politically and economically”, and CPEC could also be beneficial for Indian Kashmir. As it stands, this remains a red line for New Delhi.
Once in a lifetime chance
At the National Defense University in Islamabad, I was shown a paper by Li Xiaolu, from the Institute of Strategic Studies at the National Defense University of the PLA detailing how Beijing hopes that “by opening China’s west to Central and South Asia, building better transportation infrastructure, and by encouraging trade with South and Central Asian countries, the development of manufacturing, processing and industrial capacities in Western China can be promoted”.
Now compare it with road and rail infrastructure improved across Pakistan being able to turn the whole nation into an actual trade corridor, while the Pakistani Navy improves its defense in deep-sea waters with Gwadar positioned as a third naval base and offering support for Chinese ships across sea lanes close to the Middle East and Northern Africa.
No wonder Chinese analysts share a virtual consensus about traditional Chinese wisdom favoring unity for prosperity – a key plank of CPEC and BRI – and prevailing over containment and confrontation.
For CPEC to work, Beijing needs three things: a political solution for Afghanistan, which is already being worked out inside the SCO, with China, Russia, India, Pakistan and Iran (as an observer) directly involved; stable relations between India and Pakistan; and certified security across Pakistan.
Beijing is actively encouraging closer connectivity between Afghanistan and Pakistan, with the Quetta-Kandahar railway and the Kabul-Peshawar highway. CPEC is actually expanding from the Karakoram to the Khyber Pass, trespassing the artificial Durand line along the way.
In contrast, multiple factions in Washington continue to twist all possible faultlines to thwart these projects, with a propaganda campaign designed to portray BRI as a swamp of corruption, incompetence, a “debt trap” and “malign” Chinese behavior.
Yet among all BRI corridors, material progress across CPEC is more than self-evident. I saw every village in the Northern Areas with electricity and most of them linked by fiber optics, a stark contrast to when I traveled a severely dilapidated Karakoram, twice, two decades ago.
Pakistan now has a once in a lifetime chance to harness its geographical location – with borders intertwining centuries of history and culture with Iran, Afghanistan, Central Asia and the Middle East – to set itself up as a key bridge between the Middle East and both the Mediterranean and Western China.
Rumors abounded in Islamabad that Imran Khan is aiming for an international standard university in the capital, positioned as a center of study and research tracking the new mosaic of an emerging multipolar world. Young people power will be more than available, like Jamila Shah, currently at the National Defense University, doing a masters in Peace and Conflict Studies, and working with an NGO, the International Rescue Committee. Jamila, from Hunza, in Gilgit-Baltistan, is the face of Pakistan’s future.
Still hostage to a corrupt oligarchy, cartelized industries, falling exports (60% of which are textiles), and with almost half of their youths aged from five to 16 out of school, Pakistan faces a Sisyphean task.
Economist Ishrat Husain has correctly noted that Pakistan’s model of “elitist growth” must be replaced by “shared growth”. Enter a modified CPEC opening the path ahead, hopefully like those cargo trucks defying the slippery, snowy Khunjerab full blast.
Up next: On the road in the Karakoram
On the road in the Karakoram
On the Pakistani side, a wooden house serves as a small customs office fronted by “the highest ATM in the world” – though you try a foreign credit card at your peril. The Chinese side boasts an intimidating, metal-plated James Bond-esque structure with no humans in sight.
This is ground zero of the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), the point where the revamped, upgraded Karakoram Highway – “the eighth wonder of the world” – snakes away from China’s Xinjiang all the way to Pakistan’s Northern Areas and further south to Islamabad and Gwadar, on the Arabian Sea.
From here it’s 420 kilometers to Kashgar and a hefty 1,890 km to Urumqi, the capital of Xinjiang. But going south is where the fun really begins.
Traveling the Karakoram from Gilgit, the capital of the Northern Areas, to the Khunjerab and back is an exhilarating road trip along CPEC and its spin-offs. And it’s a crazy carousel.
Psychedelic Pakistani trucks, Chinese container road warriors – some trying to subdue the Khunjerab without chains on their tires – packed minivans plying the Hunza-Xinjiang route, Silk Road motels, the smell of curry interfacing with the best apricot juice in the world, roadside butchers, shacks advertising themselves as “Silk Road Investment & Credit Society Ltd,” many a Pak China Gateway Hotel, checkpoints consisting of a roadside table and a bunch of papers kept from flying away by pebbles, stashes of yuan crisscrossing rupees and dollars and messy, multi-level “people to people exchanges.”
It’s one of the greatest road trips on earth. And in geopolitical terms, it may be the greatest.
Mind the yaks
Karakoram North starts at the environmentally protected Khunjerab National Park, where yaks roam freely on the road and ibex and marmots are easily spotted nearby. But there are no Marco Polo sheep, much less snow leopards. (Though local Ismailis insist a few dozen reside in the park.)
The first serious pit-stop in the Karakoram is Sost, which used to be the Pakistani border in the old days – as when I traveled the road, twice, 20 years ago by jeep from Kashgar. Now, the bustling trade entrepot is the HQ of the Silk Road Dry Port Sost. Chinese lorries unload their cargo and Pakistani trucks take up the relay to transport the merchandise all across the nation. It appears modern and well-organized. Everything proceeds smoothly.
Snaking south, we pass right under the spectacularly receding Passu Glacier. In a nearby village, a funeral is in progress, with the crowd taking over the road alongside yaks and buffalos and interrupting traffic at will.
The upgraded Karakoram is an apotheosis of Pak-China Friendship Tunnels – all exhibiting the obligatory commemorative billboard extolling a geopolitical friendship soaring “higher than the highest mountain.”
This is CPEC in effect. It is astonishing when compared to the recent past. Between the Hunza and Gilgit rivers flowing parallel to impeccable asphalt worthy of an autobahn, a fiber optic cable runs all across the Northern Areas.
Chinese engineering has performed miracles. Around 160km south of the Khunjerab we drive around Attabad Lake, which totally submerged the road after a landslide in January 2010. For over five years there was simply no China-Pakistan overland trade, although some went via Kashgar-Gilgit flights. The solution by the China Road and Bridge Corporation had to be a tunnel – completed in 2015.
Trade along the Karakoram is bound to pick up – after years at less than 10% of total China-Pak trade, which tends to flow especially from Guangdong and Zhejiang provinces, not Xinjiang. Some stretches of the highway remain prone to constant landslides, rockslides or floods, which require a number of 24/7 rescue and maintenance teams. These are Pakistani, while the SUVs of the police in the Northern Areas have been supplied by China.
The heart of the New Silk Roads, or Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) infrastructure projects are road and railway lines. These do not cost a fortune per se; the expense is in the construction costs for bridges and tunnels. Russia spent over $4 billion on its Kerch Strait bridge to the Crimea. New Silk Road costs will be exponentially higher. Tunnels can be way more expensive than bridges.
Where the Himalayas rise
From the Karakoram it’s sometimes possible to catch a glimpse of the formidable Nanga Parbat – Kashmiri for “Naked Mountain,” later nicknamed the “Killer Mountain.” It has never been climbed in winter, and is actually a series of ridges which anchors the western Himalaya range, culminating in an ice crest at 8,126 meters above sea level. That is the ninth highest peak in the world and the second in Pakistan after K2.
As we approach Gilgit, the road signs – in English, Mandarin and Russian – say 468 km to Abbottabad (site of the Osama bin Laden endgame) and 583 km to Islamabad. Way down south, in less mountainous terrain, I’m told the odd rockslide gives way to occasional floods.
South of Gilgit, the Chinese once again are in frantic building mode, attacking the road starting from the Karakoram to the strategic Mecca Skardu. The road, according to local Ismailis, should be ready before 2020.
And then, on a bend of the revamped highway, the intersection of the Karakoram, the Hindu Kush and the Himalayan mountain ranges – bordering the confluence of the Gilgit River with the Indus, now flowing south all the way to the Arabian Sea – spreads before us. Nearly 85% of the Indus discharge happens between May and September, out of snow and glacial melt, propelling the monsoons. Abdul, the painter of the Karakoram, is applying the finishing touches to a white-clad viewing point.
The China-Pak embrace
The building of the original Karakoram – an engineering tour de force – took no less than 27 years and claimed the lives of over 1,000 Chinese and Pakistani workers.
The Karakoram Highway is much more than a road; it’s a rolling, graphic emblem of the China-Pakistan geopolitical embrace, surmounting all manner of economic, cultural, geological and security barriers over decades to the benefit of a strategic objective. And the strategic objective now is CPEC as the flagship BRI project.
At the recent opening ceremony of the China International Import Expo in Shanghai, where he was guest of honor, Pakistani Prime Minister Imran Khan described CPEC, including the Karakoram highway, as a “vital link” for China and Pakistan with the Middle East and Central Asia. “CPEC is a mechanism to connect China, the Middle East and Central Asia that also opens ways for fresh investment and paves the way for new markets,” he said.
Khan also reassured his hosts – as well as domestic public opinion – that his new government is engaged in deep, meaningful reforms to ensure transparency and accountability; virtual ghosts as far as Pakistani business is usually concerned.
“Pakistan has an array of resources, minerals and renewables amidst the most diverse landscape,” Khan said, adding that his country is a leading exporter of sports goods, medical instruments and IT products, and has promising, 100 million-strong human resources under the age of 35. So, the potential is immense.
Islamabad is all in on completing CPEC up to 2030, with projections of up to 3% added to annual GDP growth, as industrial output is bound to rise with more electricity courtesy of CPEC investments and more production coming from Chinese-style Special Economic Zones.
The big plan
CPEC’s Long-Term Plan (2017-2030), released one year ago, defines four priorities in Pakistan: Gwadar Port; energy projects; transport infrastructure (as in upgrading of the Karakoram); and industrial cooperation. Imran Khan’s government (see Part 1 of this report) is aiming for Pakistan to position itself, via CPEC, as the key hub uniting the overland Silk Road Economic Belt and the Maritime Silk Road.
This implies, geopolitically and economically, an even stronger, trans-regional, China-Pakistan alliance in contraposition to India and Washington. The US reaction to BRI in 2018 was to unleash a whispering campaign to try to discredit it. Beijing, for its part, expects India and Pakistan to at least discuss their political differences inside the Shanghai Cooperation Organization.
From now on, China’s far west and south – Xinjiang and Yunnan – have to become the top drivers of the Chinese economy. Upgrading their road, rail and energy infrastructure and closely linking them to South Asia and Southeast Asia is essential for China to keep growing – all that boosted by crucial energy connectivity via a gas pipeline from Turkmenistan, an oil pipeline from the Caspian in Kazakhstan, further massive gas shipments from Siberia, and, further down the road, a possible gas pipeline from Gwadar port to Xinjiang parallel to the Karakoram.
Will it work? The Karakoram, Hindu Kush and Himalayas have seen it all come and all go over multiple millennia. So why not? The upgrading of the greatest geological and geopolitical road trip on earth is a start.
Excellent article. Wonderful pictures. Thumbs up, Pepe!
why don’t you consider political situation in Xinjiang. cultural genocide and arbitrary detention of Uighurs?don’t be too foolish to undestand China‘s Xinjiang. it’s also the hub of CIA. Mossad…ect. where is the justice of the world?
“China‘s Xinjiang. it’s also the hub of CIA. Mossad”
Why would Xi tolerate the CIA and MOSSAD inside China?
If they have agents and bases there, it is possible for Xi to be unaware of their presence?
I know there are CIA agents there and also media controlled by CIA. my speculations are:
1. Xi jinping government are too weak to control Xinjiang.
2. Xi jinping government is tolerate to them on the basis of secret agreement with neocons. why neocons? because neocons needs China and China also needs neocons in order to win in trade war with US.
the real situation in Xinjiang is rarely understood. punishment of Uighurs for tge sake of trade war is not justice. cultural genocide and arbitrary detention of Uighurs cause more panic in the region. how come Xi jinping don’t understand this simple logic?
the so called “arbitrary detention of Uighurs” articles published in CIA backed BBC and other corporate controlled Western media has already been disproven as yet another propaganda lie, the same lie the Western/USA has been running for daces, in the lines of the same big lies such as “Saddam has weapons of mass distraction”, Iran is building the bomb”, “Assad gassed his own people”, “Gadaffi ordered bombing of night club”, American ships owere attacked in the gulf of Tonkin by Vietnam”, “Japan attacked pearl harbor and USA didn’t know anything abut it” and so on and so on and so on. Shall I continue?
Western media lies and has been lying for decides, centuries even.
Funny how you arent concerned AT ALL about the genocide in Yemen by Saudi Arabia but you are oh SO concerned about “arbitrary detention of Uighurs”.
So basically you really OUGHT to be shamed of yourself. But I bet you NEVER are.
interesting comment.
Ziomedia lies I know it very well. but the problem what I am talking is the real matter. ziomedia may exagerate the situation in Xinjiang but the cultural genocide and arbitrary detention is 100% true. and you can’t deny the fact based on your previous experience.
if you are not zionist please stop your personal attack.thanks.
Pepe’s knowledge of world affairs is truly encyclopaedic.
William Engdahl wrote about the Uighur issue in which he says –
“In August Reuters published an article under the headline, “UN says it has credible reports that China holds million Uighurs in secret camps.” A closer look at the article reveals no official UN policy statement, but rather a quote from one American member of an independent committee that does not speak for the UN, a member with no background in China. The source of the claim it turns out is a UN independent advisory NGO called Committee on Elimination of Racial Discrimination. The sole person making the charge, American committee member Gay McDougall, stated she was “deeply concerned” about “credible reports.” McDougall cited no source for the dramatic charge.
Reuters in their article boosts its claim by citing a murky Washington DC based NGO, the Chinese Human Rights Defenders (CHRD). In an excellent background investigation, researchers at the Grayzone Project found that the CHRD gets hundreds of thousands of dollars from unnamed governments. The notorious US government NGO, National Endowment for Democracy, is high on the list of usual suspects. Notably, the CHRD official address is that of the Human Rights Watch which gets funds also from the Soros foundation.
Former Istanbul CIA station chief, Graham Fuller was one of the architects of the Reagan-Bush Iran-Contra affair, and a prime CIA sponsor or handler of Gülen who facilitated Gülen’s USA exile. He was also by his own admission, in Istanbul the night of the failed 2016 coup. In 1999 during the end of the Russian Yelstin era, Fuller declared,
“The policy of guiding the evolution of Islam and of helping them against our adversaries worked marvelously well in Afghanistan against the Russians. The same doctrines can still be used to destabilize what remains of Russian power, and especially to counter the Chinese influence in Central Asia.” This is what the covert US weaponization of ETIM is aimed at. Like most radical Sunni Jihadist groups, Turani’s ETIM got funding as most radical Sunni Jihadist groups from Saudi Arabia.
The context of events in Xinjiang needs to be made clear. The West and especially Washington is engaged in full-scale irregular war against the stability of China.”
And the Uighurs are simply being used. China however knows what the game is and will not tolerate US backed terrorism on it’s territory.
https://journal-neo.org/2018/10/05/china-s-uyghur-problem-the-unmentioned-part/
Joe, sometimes the concerns of local, backward and isolated clans which share little vision of the leadership of much larger aggregations of population…adjoining them…….are overwhelmed and outweighed…and they feel oppressed and disrespected, particularly if they have no representation in the process of change ….and are manipulated by even further away forces (CIA, MI6) to not even consider desiring such representation and share of resulting medium and long term benefits….their clannish short-sighted “leadership” preferring the short-term bribes and pay-off from far more foreign agents and far away “devils” than their unwanted CP leaders in Beijing
There are examples of this historically within the United States (your ancestral farm might now be under water because of FDR’s Tennessee Valley Authority project of the 1930….bringing electricity, flood control, water management, canals to tens of millions of other Americans…..benefits which slightly (sarc) outweigh your (hypothetical example) nostalgic attachment to your now under water family farm.
Same thing within more central areas of China, than its Far West. Villages now under water because of the largest hydroelectric project to date on Planet Earth…The Three Gorges Dam….and some disgruntled villagers whose feelings could be sympathized with. And perhaps placated with the benefits that finally, the millenia old periodic cycles of mass drowning death by the hundreds of thousands of Chinese at a time…by flooding of the Yellow River and the Yangtze, etc………. were finally solved.
In this case, what Pepe is talking about is globally paradigm changing stuff ..……..unlocking the productive, cultural, scientific potential of billions of human beings and freeing them from the divide and conquer geopolitical shackles of Empire. AND burying the “Great” Evil Empire Game of Divide and Conquer Endless War and Conflict in the Eurasian Heartland ….The World Island…the Empire has always sought to divide and bedevil.
In that process, it were useful if leadership within the Uyghers woke up and smelled the coffee…and got ready to negotiate and receive benefits for their people…………..rather than being recruited as disgruntled cannon fodder….for The Empire…..whose War not only on Russia, but on Humanity quite a few of us here are interested in stopping.
However, where there is stubborn blindness to the Greater Good…..”Where there is no vision….” the people suffer under bad leadership….if they don’t outright perish for their stubborn refusal to adapt to a greater Good than their perceived Local Good of “same old same old…going nowhere, fast”.
Y’all fell for a rhetorical trick…
“pick some small part and move attention to it…watch birdie everybody”
Ignore such attempts? Might be a good idea…
thanks for your clarification. China’s internal political situation is a mess. China also has its version of Atlantists they are known as Jiang Zemin fraction. Xi jinping center is not too strong as mass media claimed. the media in China controlled by CIA. why Xi jinping cannot stop this? it’s just like how Putin can’t stop Medvedev clans in Russia.
Uighur situation is the game between Jiang zemin fraction and Neocons. although Xi jinping want to control the situation in Xinjiang but Jiang zemin’s agents are controlling there very well. they are arbitrary detention of Uighurs and and using Chinese media provoke hatred between Uighurs and Chinese. outside of China they are using CNN, BBC…etc.
who can stop this and how could it be possible BRI without stability in Xinjiang? it’s just a dream now. you will see more game in Xinjiang. this is not only Uighurs problem. this is the political problem of Beijing.
Having spent the last 16+ years studying China on a daily basis, this guy posting as “Joe” is a Falun Gong propagandist if ever there was. Pure CIA-Falun Gong claptrap.
Jiang Zemin was “rehabilitated” by President Xi who totally crushed the Shanghai powers with his election and first term. Zemin is paraded (as best a near-cadaver can be) to show respect, but Shanghai is over. As is ex President Hu Jintao’s powerbase, Communist Youth League.
President Xi would never have been able to dominate if anyone had power in the Politiboro. He is Emperor now. President for life. Totally controls every aspect of the Military and Armed Police, and a the Ministries of State Security and Public Security.
mod-to: ad hominem removed
As for Xinjiang, up until the terrorists attacked and killed the Chinese police in vicious knife attacks, the Chinese government didn’t have armed police out in the society of Xinjiang. They didn’t have a pistol outside the police stations. Then the terror struck and they had to move in to control public safety.
Lies and propaganda have proceeded from the terror paid for and directed by CIA.
mod-to ad hominem’s removed.
Wow it seems I told the truth at the right place. what are you afraid of? you are very interesting. did Xi jinping crush Jiang zemin at his first election? what a nonesense! Xi jinping was selected by Jiang zemin power or Chinese version of atlantists. this is the naked truth! however after the election Xi jinping arrested Zhou yunkang and other CIA agents with the help of Wang qishan. past several years Putin and Xi jinping are helped each other in internal and international matters.
now I am suspicious about your identity. from today on I will speak about the real situation in China’s political mess. I am really surprise your comment. this is how CIA or Jiang zemin agent react.
Attention:
Vineyard needs to reanalyze political situation in China. Jiang zemin power is real matter in case of Xinjiang. please open your eyes!
Joe, you can stuff your “cultural genocide” where the sun don’t shine.
You want to know what “cultural genocide” is? The communists outlawing foot binding, or outlawing slavery, without which Tibet’s “traditional” economy could no longer function.
It is disgusting listening to weak-minded fools bemoaning loss of culture on the other side of the planet from where they are lounging on their plastic sofa in their generic western suburb. What would such a fool know or even care about traditional Uighur culture, where a child gets to choose between a life of herding goats and one of herding yaks? What about kids who want to be engineers? Or doctors? Or scientists? “Sorry kid, that’s “cultural genocide”! Now get out there in your smelly, lice-infested traditional clothes and look after your yaks!”
Thanks to “cultural genocide” little girls in China can grow up without being crippled, and Tibetan kids have life choices other than being a slave to the local monastery. Some “culture” genuinely needs to be discarded because it is not so wonderful as delusional fools in their generic western suburbs imagine it to be.
Bro 93, excellent comment: “what Pepe is talking about is globally paradigm changing stuff ..……..unlocking the productive, cultural, scientific potential of billions of human beings and freeing them from the divide and conquer geopolitical shackles of Empire. AND burying the “Great” Evil Empire Game of Divide and Conquer Endless War and Conflict in the Eurasian Heartland ….The World Island…the Empire has always sought to divide and bedevil.”
Thanks, Anon. Glad I had the opportunity to pop in here twice in one busy day.
It’s a bad week when I miss an article or two this good!
Sinjiang was once an independent country called East Turkestan, invaded and occupied by the PLA alongside Tibet and Inner Mongolia (none of these nations are ethnically Chinese)…so I don’t think it is really comparable to Tennessee :-)
you forgot the “explosion” of USS Maine in Havana which initiated the American-Spanish war in 1898:the first 9/11.
Dont forget how North Korea tortured its poor slave people with famines, slave camps, economic disasters and casual killings of generals and family members, and the few North Koreans who succeeded to escape and tell MSM about their horror and slavery and how happy they were to be in “the free and civilised world”.
China contemplated engaging Blackwater in that region some time ago to cater for the security aspect. Not sure if it was implemented.
Frontier Services Group, Hong Kong-based, has trained 5000 military, 200 plainclothes police, 500 SWAT specialists, 200 railway police and 300 overseas military police officers. Erik Prince owns it. It is his primary business.
This article has plenty of facts about Prince’s company entrenched with China in Africa and in China.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/world/wp/2018/05/04/feature/a-warrior-goes-to-china-did-erik-prince-cross-a-line/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.6b30a6cb5fda
I’ve read other articles that he is operational in Kunming, China, which is indicated in the above piece.
keep publishing those unique pictures of the painter and the Karakoram Highway checkpoint people, especially the pebble paper weights, and the lorries and the mountains. pictures make it so much more a reality than even inspired text. well done. more please
Good interpretation of important and unknown area
Keep reporting
Very informative. I love the pictures!
Karakoram Highway, 1300 km running from China to Pakistan. Incredible and awesome engineering
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=os1pJcdEwIg
The road that links China and Pakistan
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o5AAvnyexzY
Having grown up with the romance of the Karakoram and Samarkhand due to family connections I am delighted by your article. Hope that Pakistanis and Chinese can get to talk to Indians in a friendly way that allows an even more stunning potential for the region to be contemplated. Oh well. My childhood ambition of becoming Vice-roy of all India is going to happen after my death.
Regards, a great report,
IS
https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2018-12-30/president-reconsidering-syria-pullout-thin-ice-after-lunch-lindsey-graham
Trump is the watchman and the King of the South in Daniel 8. He will attack RF in Syria. There is no withdrawal.
Might you mean Daniel 11 as the source of the prophecy?
Enjoyed reading this article. Escobar doesn’t mention it, but one can see why the zpc/nwo are so interested in keeping Afghanistan in chaos.
Just a great read and really wonderful pics. Thanks so much Pepe and The Saker for posting. It made we want to sling on a backpack and go exploring right this minute.
Colin Thubrons books eg lost heart of Asia …shadow of the silk road etc are very good.
Wonderful and wondering descriptions of the highest global area on earth. I wish I had ancient lies to the Hunza Valley! China must save this part of the world from the racist, mendasicious, thieving, Americans
China need not steal these areas, just save them form the north Americans, please. When China stole Tibet it also destroyed at least three thousand years of human history we desperately need to be able to survive ourselves and the Americans.
I doubt you would have wanted to live the Tibetan feudalism of the Dalai Lama.
People were in desperate poverty, with no proper medical attention, destined to live the life better known by slaves, with the monks simply saying it was your destiny. During this period their Dalai Lama had only the finest phonograph, records and books while his people led a wretched life. The Dalai Lama would later collect 2 million USD annually from the CIA after his flight to India (geopolitics).
There was literally no mining the rich mineral resources of Tibet during his “stewardship” nor development of hydro-electric potential. The Chinese built the roads… some say just to be able to invade. Today there is even a railway all the way to Lhasa, the highest railway line in the world all built by China.
The “invasion” was a “liberation” for others. Your mileage might vary.
Strange then that 99.9% of actual Tibetan people think that their country has been seized by an oppressive and entirely unwelcome foreign power?
What a read!! Fantastically inspiring and worthwhile.
The statue head does not look like a bodhisattva. It has a dot on the forehead and a moustache. And a small ‘damru’ / drum on the head.more likely a hindu Shiva statue from pre buddhist hindu era.
The features are those of a genuine sculpture of a bodhisattva in the Indo-Greek Gandhara style, probably from a supporting figure in a frieze. Many Buddhist figures have mustaches and almost all of them have urnakosha and ushnisha. This type of sculpture is very rare and quite valuable (but hard to sell if obtained illegally).
Sorry bubba, you are completely right…I’ve just noticed a tiny lingam on the headdress, so it is after all Hindu and Saivite :-)
What little I know ( lack of info sources) about CPEC stems from Asia Times online. Mistakenly I have always focused on the south here Ghadar port. Whenever I looked at the port via Google Earth the port was yawning empty. A thriving international port also needs a modern airport. What I see at Ghadar International is an abandoned concrete strip and no facilities whatsoever. Only recently did I find the projected trasse for the highway leading north, actually east to begin with. Unfortunately I will not live long enough to see it completed. But I will copy all the interesting pictures out for my personal collection
I have to apologize. There is life at the Airport. I just looked and the latest satellite picture is from Aug. 31st. 18.A turboprop on the ramp. And pictures of new and/or freshly painted buildings.
The seaport however – empty.
There is no need to panic or be impatient at this point. While many of us in the West are accustomed to projects being measured in fiscal quarters and worry when profits are not returned straight away, the Chinese are comfortable working on projects that take decades to develop. Remember China’s “ghost cities” that the BBC breathlessly assured us were horrible economic catastrophes several years back? We don’t see those in the news anymore because a Chinese “ghost city” that now has millions of inhabitants isn’t the narrative the BBC or New York Times wants their audiences exposed to.
From China’s perspective, CPEC is in its infancy. They’ve barely started it. There is no need to be anxious at this point. The Chinese certainly are not. If when 2030 rolls around Gwadar port area remains desolate, then anxiety would be justified, but I rather doubt we need expect that. More likely is that by then the nearby town of Gwadar will have grown to a population of a quarter million or more, and local support industries will likewise grow dramatically.
https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2018/12/30/supreme-court-john-roberts-robert-mueller-investigation-223569
Is it England that Justice Roberts defends.?
I really like Pepe Escobar, and I have been following his writing for some time, finding myself mostly in agreement with his worldview. I have learned from his articles, and I have been impressed by his detailed investigations into China’s BRI and its potential implications for a large region of the world. I’m somewhat dismayed at his irrational exuberance and how his penchant for long pieces heavy on emotion and light on fact checking leave the reader wondering about the trustability of this commentator. I notice the same thing with Ramin Mazaheri, another writer here on the Saker blog that I enjoy reading. Pieces like this should be completely factual, and lines and lines of romantic language with misleading information detract from an otherwise accurate analysis. Pepe, there are to my knowledge 14 peaks on the earth over 8,000 meters in elevation, so I was greatly shocked to read “Within a radius of roughly 150 km from Gilgit and Skardu, there are no less than 90 peaks towering over 8,000m.” This kind of work is just plain sloppy, and it doesn’t belong in a serious piece about a serious topic. In addition, Pepe is either ignorant of or deliberately misleading when he says “Gilgit-Baltistan is the safest place in the whole of Pakistan. Here, there’s no “terror threat” by the Pakistani Taliban or dodgy al-Qaeda or ISIS spin-offs.” In fact, as recent as 2013, a group of 16 militants stormed the base camp of the very mountain, Nanga Parbat, that Pepe repeatedly mentions in this article. They killed 11 people, 10 foreign climbers and one local guide. The perpetrators of this crime later identified themselves as “al-Qaida” and “Pakistani Taliban”. Although this was the first attack on mountaineers in Gigit-Baltistan, there is sporadic violence against the minority Shia Muslims in the region.
Frankie P
Your points are well taken. However, in the old days, there were magazines which had editorial staff that took care of such details. Without editors, many western luminaries would have made numerous errors that might not, in the end, have detracted from the vibe of the article. Such an article would have been a “travelogue”, that rare creature very much missed most of the time in the blogosphere. I think P.E. did very well given the circumstances. In the Asia Times comments, there is a fellow who did a similar trip recently who found P’s article essentially accurate, while arguing that the Pakistanis and Chinese need to do more in the realm of cultural understanding. Outside of the biggest MSM, scarcely anyone can afford to pay people to edit or do research. That said, I don’t find the article “sloppy” in our unpaid blogosphere that is, for better or worse, most of what is left. The remaining paid MSM is 100% worse on statistics and facts these days.
Dear Mr Pepe
I was so glad to be standing on the Roof of the World on New Years Eve, and to embark upon that fabulous journey, thank you.
One of my all time favourite exploration/mountaineering reads, A Short Walk in the Hindu Kush by Eric Newby, perhaps you have also read.
Best wishes for 2019 and further successful explorations in the Great Game of the New Year …
Ras
regarding ” cultural genocide and arbitrary detention of Uighurs”
i give you
“The Rand Corporation defines America’s influence operations as… “the coordinated, integrated, and synchronized application of national diplomatic, informational, military, economic, and other capabilities in peacetime, crisis, conflict, and post-conflict to foster attitudes, behaviors, or decisions by foreign target audiences that further US interests and objectives. In this view, influence operations accent communications to affect attitudes and behaviors but also can include the employment of military capabilities, economic development, and other real-world capabilities that also can play a role in reinforcing these communications.”
taken from
https://www.strategic-culture.org/news/2018/12/20/influencing-foreigners-is-what-intelligence-agencies-do.html
I am somewhat puzzled – check that, dismayed – that Pepe casually noted that the “face of the future of Pakistan” is a Hunza women who works with the NGO “International Rescue Committee” without a single word about that entity …… another of the west’s “civil society” organizations that is likely up to no good.
A simple google search of that entity, which touts is goal “to shape humanitarian policy and practice in ways to improve the lives of more people worldwide, shows that on its board of Oversears is that great humanitarian Madelaine (killing 500,000 Iraqi children “was worth it” Albright, Morton Abramowitz of the Project for a New American Century crowd, and, to top if off, the foremost architect of “humanitarian” coups and interventions himself, Dr. Henry Kissinger. Fellow Overseers Condolezza Rice and world banker James Wolfenson are among dozens of other nefarious types who enlighten this “humanitarian” organization.
The President and CEO of that “humanitarian” organization is David Miliband, former UK Blairite Labor MP who voted in 2003 to free Iraq from its mythical stockpile of weapons of mass destruction, and later as head of this NGO advocated for military action to topple that other “dictator” Bashar al Assad who Miliband asserted was “dropping barrel bombs on its own civilians.”
Pepe really needs to fact check, and look for better faces for Pakistan’s future, unless he foresees a future as “bright” for Pakistan as Pinochet’s Chile, Suharto’s Indonesia, Vietnam, or Iraq or Syria, among other nations devastated by these luminaries and humanitarians of the International Rescue Committee.
I have to say…. I’m greatly disappointed in Pepe’s irrational exuberance on this one.
Very important and essential points you make, but again I would call this piece “road writing”, which used to be a genre in itself; for all we know he wrote parts of it in the Khyber Pass motel described, sent via the fiber optic cable described.
I caught the ref to the NGO and looked it up too. He said the lady pictured was the “face of Pakistan’s future”, not that future itself, which may be relevant or I may be nitpicking.
Nanga Parbat was successfully climbed in Winter in 2016. Mir Safdar Ali Khan actually sought refuge in Huijiang (Muslimland aka Sinjiang). Kucha was actually governed by China at the time, but it is disingenuous to suggest that he took refuge in China. In fact the historic connection is not between China and Gilgit-Baltistan but rather between Tibet and Gilgit-Baltistan (Baltistanis are Muslim Tibetans and the Balti language is Tibetan with Urdu loanwords). Beijing insists that Tibetans are just a variety of Han Chinese (this being their justification for invading) so Pepe daren’t mention the word ‘Tibet’ in this article for fear of offending them. This makes the article interesting but heavily distorted.
Ahhh….so you were there twenty years ago.
Hmmm…I was in the region in late autumn 1999 on my bicycle heading north thru Hunza, north from Gilgit, where I gathered some warm weather gear discarded by K2 (and other other mountain) climbers. It was the high point of a 2 year round-the-worls cycling tour.
What a geological and historical gem the Karakoram highway is. Your article wove these two threads together magnificently.
Love the article, thanks for mentioning the legendary insane Chinese truckers. Unbelievable that a truck that size is attempting/completing the journey without chains on the tires, or am I missing something.
Unfortunately China is still a totalitarian country. Oops, there goes my social credit score again ;)
The links of China with (((international finance))) go back right to the beginning of the communist project — it is still ongoing. Just like the West, we are all under the thumb of the banksters.
The China-nirvana project is just another silly revolution to turn your heads. The banksters will still be in charge whilst you (any Westerners reading this) will feel that you deserved to have your countries destroyed because some writer said so.
I see Pepe never addresses the historical elephant in the room, namely those who truly controlled the British Empire and were behind the notorious Opium Wars. Nevermind the clear and present banksters that still control China. “Communist” is the same as “ISIS” — a figment of the imagination of the Masters of Discourse.
That all being said — after the great, grand and entirely scripted collapse of Europe under a deluge of cultural marxist nonsense, I will gladly accept any Red Backs for re-construction purposes.
My social credit score just went up again. Just don’t expect me to swallow that China is bankster-free…