by Katerina for the Saker Blog
This is a follow-up to my previous contribution, the “Relentless March” and I have to warn you, this one will be much harsher as it will be highlighting some home truths for east Europeans. If you are not ready or simply do not want to face those, I suggest you stop reading now.
In this essay, among other things, I will also try to provide some explanations as to why Russian President (VVP as he is widely known) does not respond to western provocations the way some people would like him to and it seems to bother them, especially those who see the perceived lack of response on his part as an indication of some weakness and indecisiveness..
He is none of that.
Although I have to admit that once I was one of these people. When ukro-nazis embarked on their killing spree in Donbass (historically part of Russia) and started killing Russian population there, I was absolutely enraged that the Russian Government has allowed for this horror to take place.
Looking back at it in a much calmer light I eventually realised that THAT was, without doubt, the right response on the part of Russia. If it got itself involved in that provocation, the body count would have been much, much higher.. besides, Donbass was helped in other ways.
What is a provocation? It is something that your enemy sets up, expecting you to react to it the way they were hoping you would react. So, what you do not do is GIVE them what they expected.
I will also admit that my understanding of this and other things to do with the actions of the Russian President are entirely due to my very calm, collected and analytical husband of Scottish ancestry, who would very patiently explain to me as to why VVP is doing what he does. Although, he had to calm me down first! He understood much better the Russian President’s thinking and actions, better than his Russian born wife! Must be the man thing. : )
I will also touch upon the attitudes towards Russia by former Eastern Bloc allies – former Warsaw Pact members and the reasons for their disturbing Russophobia that is being displayed towards Russia in the last couple of decades.
First on VVP.
President Putin is an exceptional strategist, not to mention, analyst and he sees all of this as a long engagement, very much the same as Chinese in that respect. The short- lived satisfaction of hitting back at every provocation thrown at him is definitely not the way he operates. He will respond only when that response is absolutely required, as in retaliatory sanctions on EU, which apparently now costing them BILLIONS, and his response will be selective and painful. He has also very adequately retaliated for the expulsion of Russian Diplomats after the made-up by UK Skripal nonsense.
He looks far ahead and plans accordingly. Crimea is a very good example of that. He knew what was brewing up in Ukraine for much longer than anyone of us, the Russian intelligence service is second to none, and he was absolutely prepared for that. The speed of his counter-actions there was breath-taking.
And here I will describe the sheer imbecility and stunning ignorance of some morons (no other way to describe them) in the USA administration. Did you know that one of their main objectives in meddling in Ukraine was to remove the Russian Naval Base from Crimea and replace it with their own? They even made plans for the adaptation of the barracks there! Talk about absolute insanity and DELUSION. They actually thought that they could pull that off!! Beyond belief.. But that’s the mentality of the people Russians are dealing with here. The sheer ignorance of not only a country’s history but also it’s sacrifices is incredible! Russian Crimea has always been an extremely important asset to Russia, hence the several and very bloody wars it had to fight with the Ottoman Empire to wrench it back from them. Since then it has always been the home of Russia’s Black Sea Fleet- it is a highly strategic naval base, which also of course, gives Russia an access to the Mediterranean and beyond.
Those imbecilic morons, who planned such idiocy actually thought that they could just cruise in there!! Oh my God… what passes for brains among that lot?!
Their sanctions, which were wheeled out almost immediately when their plan did not succeed, was the result of what can only be described as “sour grapes”. Their Euro “allies” were rather reluctant to join them in those sanctions as most Europeans know very well that Crimea has always been Russian, for more than two centuries, and were fearing the reciprocal sanctions from Russia.
To force their Euro vassals to join them in imposing the sanctions, the imbeciles decided that something needed to be done to make that happen. And so, together with their ukie flunkies that is exactly what they have carried out – an unbelievably evil and shocking crime of shooting down a passenger airliner. The screaming headlines that Russia did it and not only that, Putin himself was responsible, were all over their Western media even before “the wreckage hit the ground”. Their Euro “allies’ had no choice now but to go along with the sanctions. Cui bono? I will repeat again – this is the psychopathic mentality Russia and her President are dealing with.
As for those sanctions – here is a good example of when you “get lemons you turn them into lemonade”. Again, things were anticipated and everything was in place. Since Russian retaliatory sanctions, which were imposed on EU immediately, were to do with banning food imports from Europe, Russia had to become much more self-sufficient in providing for itself what was needed, also including substitutions. In fact, having more adequate self-sufficiency was something that the Russian President had been advocating for years prior – all of this totally played into his hands.
Donbass also wanted to re-join Mother Russia, same as Crimea, but VVP sees it as a very useful buffer and wants to keep it that way. Donbass is protected and now it is de-facto Russian, with same currency, pensions (Kiev “government” stopped paying those when the conflict started), same education programmes as in Russia and of course Russian passports. Russia has got back most of what for centuries belonged to it. Two more regions of what used to be called Ukraine – the south east of it, Mariupol and Odessa in the south (as Russian as it gets!) will eventually follow Donbass, and the rest, as far as Russia is concerned, can go to hell. The western part of so-called Ukraine is former Galicia, the ukro-nazis breeding ground that Russia wouldn’t want to touch with a barge pole, Poland can have it back. In fact, welcome to it!
“Ukraine” as most people know by now, is an artificial construct, (same as EU by the way and as such, will also have no longevity), was created by the Bolsheviks – some territory was added by Lenin (Novorussia), later, the Western parts, by Stalin after WWII and in 1954 Khruschev has “gifted” them Crimea, probably after having one too many one evening. Even under the Soviet Constitution at the time, that was ILLEGAL, as such a move required a Referendum, but being one big USSR with no borders between Republics it did not matter that much at the time. After the break-up of the Soviet Union all historically Russian parts of it should have been returned back to Russia. Ukraine hung on to these for one simple reason – money. Novorussia, which includes Donbass, was the most industrialised part of that country, as for Crimea, well, they were getting paid by Russia for the base.
As for the rest of the former USSR – the cheap little Baltic prostitutes – well, those three have already paid a very heavy price for prostituting themselves to the West. Their economies are routed, population drastically shrunk. Once the supply of money from EU dries out, they will be thrown to the kerb. What’s called “used and abused” and it will be richly deserved. Under no circumstances Russia would want those back.
Georgia is facing a similar fate – the country which owes its very existence to the protection by Imperial Russia at the time, from the total annihilation by Ottomans, and of course with loss of Russian lives.. Rings the bell, doesn’t it? What some of these former Soviet republics have discovered, is that without Russia they are rather nothing, non-entities. The West is simply using them and the very thing that they all had eagerly engaged in, meaning Russophobia – as was demanded and expected by their new, western Master, is now coming back at them with a vengeance. Most of them are broke, depopulated, despised, with no future prospects. That is the price you pay for Russophobia. I believe other countries in Eastern Europe should take some serious notice here as they are pretty much in the same boat, whether they would want to admit that to themselves or not.
After the collapse of the USSR the former Warsaw Pact members, comprising of Eastern Europe states became immediately “invaded” – by various western NGOs, “experts”, “advisors” and what not. Same was happening in Russia – the goal there of course, was looting and pillage, in Eastern block the goal was also plain and simple – to convert them all into one Russophobic entity. And once these countries became members of EU and NATO, well.. what can one say.
It usually starts with the re-writing of one’s history and inventing lies to fit that, and then the insidious, constant and pervasive brainwashing that the Soviet Union (and by extension, Russia) was bad, was an invader and aggressor, no better than the Nazis and Stalin was just as bad as Hitler, etc and so on, was unleashed and has never stopped..
Ironically, these East European nations that have suddenly achieved their long-cherished dream of becoming a part of this “EUROPE”, did not realise at the time that to this “EUROPE” they were nothing more than holops, good old-fashioned Russian word for lowly servant. As they were gleefully giving a middle finger to their Slavic brothers in the East, their new Western Master fully expected them to polish his boots, muck out the stables and fetch and carry. Pathetic is not even a good enough word to describe it. The day might come when you would NEED that Russia, but by then you would have burned all your bridges..
Now, what we have there is at least two generations of these east Europeans that are totally brainwashed, indoctrinated and absolutely ignorant of their ACTUAL history.
Their grandparents and even parents perhaps could tell them that life as they knew it, wasn’t that bad being part of the Eastern Block alliance with the Soviet Union. There was no “ghastly tyranny”, “oppressions” or “massacres” – it was in fact a peaceful and friendly cooperation. In case of the “INVASIONS” of Hungary and Czechoslovakia, well, at the time, the usual EXTERNAL players were trying to foment there the early versions of what is now called “colour revolutions” – obviously those two had to be brought back in line. It was an alliance after all.
One would think that in today’s world where you can get any information you need, there would be at least some attempt to get a true picture of your own history and not become victims of this despicable indoctrination and the vile, “in your face” propaganda. Critical thinking is obviously no longer taught in the class, let alone the ability to have an INFORMED opinion as compared to an acquired attitude. As a result, most of them now have a firm belief that Russia was and is some “enemy” – EXACTLY what your NATO masters want you to believe. The “West” has done it’s job rather well with you – producing generations of dumb-downed, ignorant and brainwashed, and to that lot we can add the sold-out, totally self-serving and west-worshipping “elites” and the rest is just a silent mass.
This is what most East European countries have become. Only Serbia so far has not sold itself out, but her government, unfortunately has, as was amply demonstrated by the latest developments, which I am sure made most Serbs cringe. This, your sad quisling “government” needs to be replaced, and fast. There are, no doubt, lots of great people in Serbia who love their country. Vote for these.
As for the rest of Eastern Europe, I will say this – re-writing your history is never a good move and neither is inventing lies to suit. Pulling down statues of Soviet heroes that liberated your countries from the Nazi scourge is just as bad. And shameful.
I will repeat – the EU is an artificial construct and as such will have no longevity and THEN where would you be?
Unfortunately, Russia also has few of those brainwashed morons as well. This rather useless idiot, Navalny, whom the West has been lovingly grooming to be a “face of Russian opposition” and who is a long-time recipient of Soros’s grants, even he has some following. Not large but none the less showing the exact same mentality shaped by some delusional beliefs picked up from so-called “social media” and in a very much the same age group. They don’t even realise that what they are displaying is a dumb, sheeple mentality and of course, ignorance. It is truly sad to see. I wonder how many of them will believe another made up garbage with another alleged “Novichok poisoning”, now of this twat. By the way, these politicians in Germany that are actually promoting this, do they comprehend as to how utterly stupid they come across with this idiotic accusation? Feel like saying to them – for crying out loud, give it a rest!
Just to note, according to Lavrov, UK still has not produced ANY evidence to support THEIR accusations of the totally made-up and “highly likely” Scripal “poisoning” tale. Well, how can one? But never mind, meanwhile the Russian Diplomats were expelled, en-masse, and some diplomatic properties illegally seized. Mission accomplished.
Sometimes I feel really sorry for both Putin and Lavrov as to what kind of people they have to deal with..
As for the Russian President, it has been often said that he is a very good chess player, and for a chess player to be that good he needs to anticipate his opponent’s every move, well in advance. Besides, he is playing that chess not on just one chessboard, but several at once and dealing with SUCH people it becomes quite a challenge to anticipate every deranged MENDACITY as being displayed by them.
What makes the Russian President stand head and shoulders above those Western politicians is not only his strategic thinking, but his morals and also his unshakable belief in a lawful approach in everything that matters. If you have signed some agreement you absolutely keep to it, if you have given your word you honour it.
In addition, he is also of course a judo master and for these who are not familiar with this particular form of martial art, the objective is to defeat your opponent by using THEIR OWN bulk and strength against them to get them off balance and then throw them on the floor. Hmm..
This is what THE WEST is dealing with when it comes to the President of Russia. There will be some detractors here, sadly without much ability for an astute analysis, who would immediately label me as being Putin’s fan, but we will ignore them. The man is formidable, in every respect.
What most Russians want from their President now is to show a much harder edge, and THAT is actually happening. Lavrov, being a Diplomat Supreme, has been showing this lately, quite noticeably, in his responses, which are now much more pointed, direct and blunt. Still, caution is required.
The hegemon is collapsing in front of our eyes and this is one of the most dangerous moments, but as I have pointed out in one of my previous comments, there is a very wise saying, I believe by SUN TZU – why disturb your enemy when it’s self- destructing. The only question is how much destruction can it wreak on the rest of us in its death throes. A very careful approach is absolutely essential now – the aim is to make this collapse more of a “controlled demolition” than to have it as a very destructive explosion in which many could be very badly hurt as a result, especially with regard to their economies, already rather shaky amid this “scamdemic”.
That is what, I believe, VVP and Xi are now working on, very carefully. Hence the very calculated responses to numerous stupid and nasty provocations. And lots of patience.
We are indeed living in very interesting times.
Dear Katerina,
Let me be the first (or second) to comment. Thank you for your heartfelt and valid description of President Putin – he is exceptional in every sense – damn the doubters.
I would also like to amplify your point that the EU (German Europe) will be dead soon – and those lowly servants and horse grooms had better worry about their future.
I would just say that we (friends of Russia) need to go on the offensive. No need to explain anything to those who don’t want to be convinced.
The British have behaved beyond appallingly towards Russia and Serbia and this will also need to be addressed (by me).
The people who understand history know that Russia MUST prevail – not as an empire but as a source of hope. Keep writing and bringing us hope. My job is to take it away from our enemies. :-)
Ken, my dear, Russia MUST prevail. It is THAT fight betweem GOOD and EVIL and Russia is facing this EVIL
Let us hope that more and more people will come to realise that is exactly what is happening in our world right now…
and THANK you for your wonderful comment.
Katerina
Russia will prevail. However, as far as I can see, we are entering the most dangerous faze of globalist anti-Russian policies. The Warsaw Pact collapsed in 1998. NATO was not cancelled. It was kept on, to be used against Russia. The globalists were hoping to destabilize Russia, after which NATO would have moved into the country in order to ensure “human rights”, place Russian nuclear missiles under NATO control, and finally have the country broken up in the name of “democracy”. As the late political economist Lyndon LaRouche stated, the only thing which can save the US dollar is the break up of Russia and the plunder of Siberia and the Caspian region. This did not happen. What did happen was that the debts of individual nations increased, creating a huge global debt. The US dollar is still printed in huge amounts backed by nothing, followed by the euro, also printed without any backup. As for Russia and China, both have been accumulating gold, and both have much more than they are willing to admit. Both are preparing to introduce gold backed currencies, waiting for the right time. And then what ? What is going to happen to the dollar and euro ? How are the Western elites going to respond, especially the Military Industrial Complex and the bankers in the US ? Start another major war, which would be very foolish, to put it mildly.
The Navalny affair is the latest false flag directed against Russia. Personally I find it very interesting, not because of it’s sophistication, but because of it’s simplicity and naivete. Western centers of power must be running out of ideas how to destabilize Russia, using old, laughable, methods. Russia is again being accused of using military nerve gas to silence somebody. Navalny, like the Scripals, manages to survive the “attack”, without anybody explaining how such a thing is possible, bearing in mind that 2 grams of military nerve agent can kill up to 500 people. In England there were no bodies in the streets, while everybody on Navalny’s commercial flight managed to land perfectly healthy, with the exception of Navalny, of course. For years I have wondered who works in Western halls of power and what their qualifications are when they end up producing infantile propaganda nonsense which they expect people to believe.
Finally, when it comes to Germany, I am wondering if it has learned the lesson of the past two world wars. In both cases it was set up for war against Russia, and now it is following NATO tunes when it comes to accusing Russia for the Navalny “attack”. Some German politicians are even demanding that the Nord Stream – 2 gas pipeline be cancelled, which would be an extremely stupid thing to do, as it would cover 40 % of German energy needs. Should this happen, Germany would end up buying, at double price, American gas, which would need to be shipped to Europe. The US is stating that it can cover all of Europe’s energy needs. Private analysts are disputing this, stating this is not the case. The only political party in Germany which is showing common sense is the AfD political party, openly questioning official facts relating to Navalny. At the moment they are a minority.
And how will all of this end on the international stage ? Peacefully or are we going to see another major war, an old trick used by bankers when they face difficulties ? We shall see.
“Should this happen, Germany would end up buying, at double price, American gas, which would need to be shipped to Europe. ”
What they would do is buy Russian LNG and sell it (with an extra charge) to Germany. The distance is signifiantly shorter and the profit higher.
Chris, as far as I know, Poles are doing this already. They, if I am correct, built LNG stations on their coast (Baltic) for that purpose. I shall not comment (in my usual “french”) more on that move.
When humans refrain from doing evil and decide to do good, humanity wins. When we foresee the consequences of our actions we will defeat our detractors. Our detractors do not have foresight of the consequences for the human race due to their actions. This harm that they do must be pointed out to them by our actions. Keeping their acts in mind will give us willpower to resist.
I read and hear the slanders against Russia, China, Iran, Venezuela etc all the time. All based on lies. And every time I hear or read it, I challenge and condemn it.
I still occasionally hear the view expressed still, that if the U.S. goes down all hope is lost because it is the last standing bastion of freedom. What a joke! That horse left the barn long ago. If I had a choice to live anywhere right now it would be to a rural area of Russia.
Dear Craig,
Perhaps it’s not my place but I’d really like to encourage you to comment – your contributions have enriched our discussions considerably. Thank you. The more brave voices gather here from all over the world, the easier the struggle will be.
Ken Leslie
Yes, you are correct that the EU will collapse, as it is nothing more than an empire of private bankers. However, it is debatable if the EU is “German Europe”. Back in 1989 both Britain and the US tried to prevent German reunification. They failed. After that both stated that they would recognize German reunification if Germany accepted the euro. This led German university professors to jump up and scream against such a demand, as German finances would then be dependent of the European Central Bank, controlled by private bankers.
However, it is true that Germany is trying to influence continental Europe. A few years ago private analysts were stating that Germany was working on reducing the number of EU member states, leaving out south European countries. I don’t know if this is still German policy. However, it would be naive to think that Germany would relinquish the temptation of either controlling or influencing continental Europe.
BF, I must say I agree with what Ken said. Germany rules the EU, at least on the surface. “Miss Germany” at least as it appears serfs the masters well and drives all European countries to extinction.
Chess players… excellent. Americans generally are not good chess players. Fully one quarter of them according to Gallop polls think the Sun goes around the Earth. I kid you not, Google it. Many of those folks are people of faith. Sadly, they elect presidents. Trump will be reelected because of them. He is a con man extraordinaire. He has bamboozled Americans into thinking that he’s some kind of populist. Total BS. He’s a Zionist shill who has aspirations to become King of the USA. Many Americans want that. Bad chess move.
Putin knows how to play chess. So does Xi Jinping. If we get into a war with them we’re doomed. It will be the end of the USA as we know it. Guess that’s what “people of faith” want. That’s why they voted for him in the first place. Not good chess players, those folks…
Tommy, not generally but some time ago Mr. Fisher drove Russians nuts and psychologically finished the off while achieving the top chess position. Interestingly enough my children’s God Father played against him as well. Fisher won by using excellent psy-op games, dirty or not he did succeed. Perhaps Russian champs arrogantly discounted his chances for the top spot. This is why VPP is so good, as Katherine says, he weighs each of his steps carefully.
So, this analysis, or whatever it wants to be, is some 3 years late. I do not get what’s the reason to publish it?
Yours is a cynical response but i understand where you are coming from….some of us have been armchair geopolitical experts for longer than Katherine… i too was once a brainwashed youth …and then i went to the USA in 1974 as a student, full of enthusiasm to see it for myself ….and woke up… so please allow Katherine her own voyage of discovery and her analysis. She is not wrong… Today i fight back against the lack of perception, with reasoning…and my biggest hurdle is to convince particularly my ultra-brainwashed German friends to be more introspective about where their Russophobia originates from….
This article has to do with the attempt by the Germans to trigger a color revolution in Belarus and Putin is not letting himself be provoked by it. Yes i said Germans, the Americans are not behind this, their target is currently China. This is not the Maidan revolution when the Germans/EU and American cookies were involved.
So it is just a coincidence that chubby Pompeo was in Belarus shortly before this started? The Department of State is absolutely involved in this as is the so called U.S. diplomat.
The Americans are not that much involved as the Germans are. You think it is a coincidence Navalny flew to Germany?! Do you think the White House is involved with the Navalny hoax if Trump says he did not see any evidence of poisoning, yet the Germans say they have evidence but it is state secret they say?! Do not underestimate the German Drang Nach Osten, it is a centuries old goal.
Germans were during most part of Russian history welcome in Russia. One of the lesser known period is the secred cooperation of the UDSSR (back than an international paria nation with the Weimar Republic a similar intnl. paria) Germany was able to test early military aircraft which was not allowed to have and Russian officers were trained by German instructors in military academies. Look up the Treaty of Rapallo
Now again over 800 German companies are doing Business in Russia. Daimler Benz has just opened a car assembly plant in Russia. There is “Lebensraum im Osten” for the Germans if they behave themself
The Germans wanted Belarus in exchange for North Stream II. Because they failed to liberate Belarus from Russia, now they are going to dump the North Stream II project. Coincidence? No
dave
Belarus does not need to be “liberated” from Russia, it is part of Russia. As for North Stream II, you do realise that Germany needs that MUCH more than Russia? Russia has other markets for it’s gas, very large markets indeed..
This, yet another provocation, orchestrated by imbecils from the “Land of imbecils”, is once again, will fail.
Well yeah, it really is a part of Russia and wants somehow to be even more of that kind?
To the extend that it is afraid of being eaten by Russian oligarchic scum which would tear the country’ s economy into pieces faster than any EU approaching. Lukashenko saved Belarus from Yeltzin alike in the 90’s. I d not doubt he is an egocentric maniac but still have to wonder who is better at checkers? However, it doesn’t matter as the Americans will take care of a blowing up the playboard. Yes, and the Chinese will sit at the river bank waiting to watch some corpses floating by. Any of them welcome: Russians, Belarusians, Americans, etc. Any of them will do, money is money. That is the only remaining ideology of the Beijing’s commies for decades already.
We shall wait, I still have the belief that common people will distinguish the winner, rejoy him, and then curse him – whoever it is. That is the human nature.
Remember Iosif Stalin? What a grandmaster of chess he was! Yet outplayed by a band of crooks around Chruschev and Zhukov… the gang from overseas didn’t even have to intervene. Will we ever learn the lesson?
Belarus is not part of Russia.
I am now convinced that Putin wants the situation in Belarus to get worse so that Lukashenko is forced to depend on Russia for security, which will provide the opportunity for Putin to force the annexation of Belarus and – of course – to sell off Belarus’ 80% state owned economy to capitalist cronies. The neoliberal capitalist Putinist regime and the neoliberal capitalist EUNATO gang are united in their common aim – they are enemies of socialism and they both want to profit from selling off the Belarus economy. They are both also keenly aware that the fact that the socialist Belarus economy is successful in providing its people with a good living standard, full employment, and under normal conditions law and order is a major problem for justifying their own capitalist dysfunctional systems. As such the only quarrel they have is which of them will profit from selling off the Belarus economy, nothing more. The EUNATO gang is of course the enemy, but the neoliberal capitalist Putinist regime is no real friend of Belarus either.
To Biswapriya Purkayastha
I truly wish that some people who decide to post a comment actually have some knowledge on the subject..
Do you know what name Belarus means? Belya Rossia as in White Russia. It has always been part of Russia, i.e. of Russian Empire and it will be once again . Same people, same language, same bloodline..
Why are Arab countries not one, since they have the same language, culture, and a shared history? Why aren’t even the seven component countries of the UAE one nation instead of a confederation, though three of them even share a single capital, the Sharjah Metropolitan Area? How do you explain this?
Are Bengalis and Kashmiris not both Indian?
Kathy, if I may. Ιn Greek it’s called “Λευκό Ρωσία – White Russia” just like in Russian. Unfortunately paid trolls are abound.
Pompeo …. Should anyone contain all the flaws of a Christian USA society that puports to bring justice and democracy to the world it is the ex CIA and current Sec. of Defence Mike ‘The Crusader’ Pompeo takes the cake This man is the complete satire of a human being.
https://youtu.be/AWLrryHJhrg or http://www.cowdisley.com/videos/pompeo.mp4
I would say, “master”(sic),, that as long as we still have those who shriek that Belarus is doomed because Putin is “tired”, and didn’t see it coming; that Navalny is allowed to go to Germany because Putin is bedazzled by Merkel, and has a blind spot about what she is; that Putins moves to cement relationships with China are because he can’t see that China intends to invade and take over Russia; that Putin works for “the Oligarchs”, and does nothing for the ‘little people”,; and that Turkey and Syria are at odds over the Kurdish question because Putin doesn’t understand about the need to prevent “loss of face” and the intense drive of religion — ALL views I have seen espoused by commentators and journalists alike recently, then there is no way this article can be said to be “3 years late”.
Late? – in what regard “late”?.
I’ve been saying exactly what Katrina is saying here for the last 6 years, till I’m tired, in fact I said it again only recently {and, dear Katrina, no, it’s not a ‘man” thing. INTJ’s tend to think this way, regardless of gender :-) } yet still there are those who refuse to see it.
It’s an Anglo thing, I think. “Either you see the world as I see it, or you are mentally deranged in some way”. Hah.
Simply a wonderful piece like the first one. As a Uruguayan expat living in Italy with very close contact with the US and interested in science and politics since my childhood, I can confirm how oppressive information has been distorted at a planetary level for a long time. The morons Katerina mentions are spread all over the world unfortunately because they have been brain washed by a quite efficient propaganda machine. Unless we get rid of the way information is delivered there are zero chances to change this situation. Very sad.
Regarding Putin, mistakes apart (if they actually were), I am convinced that he is actually the best statesman on the market today and the highest mark also goes for Lavrov who appears to me to have been born for the job.
Katrina please come back.
Thank you for the article, and your well-stated facts, Katerina..
After the recent back-stabbing by “dear partner” Merkel, VVP’s patience is being once again tested.. His pragmatic vision will undoubtedly see Russia through yet another provocation..
It should not be forgotten that, with the exception of occupied South Korea and Japan, Russia has many friends in all of Asia, representing 1/4 of the world’s population, and much more trustworthy “partners” than the West will ever be..
Cheers from China !
Guess I’m the only actual American commenting here so far. Can’t say more that I totally agree with you. Logic and common sense will eventually prevail. Otherwise, we’re doomed…
I am here too, Tommy. Thank you, Katherine! Putin and especially Lavrov are beacons of hope to those of us living in this dysfunctional ‘democracy’ and praying for peace. I hope my children’s children see the fruits of their labors for the world. It cannot come too soon!
Can’t say that your hope is well founded, Juliania, but I totally understand your wish for your children. I have children, too, and grandchildren. This whole scenario will eventually play itself out. I believe that logic and reason (the Logos) will ultimately prevail. We may have to go through a period of turmoil and dislocation, but ultimately logic will prevail.
The more they push the more it will energize us to push back. When we stop doing this they win. We must envision our detractors for what they are the most vile liars, cheaters and thieves.
I share your respect for VVP. Anyone who can do so much with so little deserves respect. (Russia’s GDP/capita was $11k while America’s was $60k.
I do question your view of history, however. Why was there a need to build a wall – to keep people in? I drove down through the former Yugoslavia into Greece in 1966. To say that it was backward would have been a gross understatement. Isn’t the reality that the Bolsheviks really did a job on Russia in 1917?
The one thing I simply shake my head about now, however, is that there is a powerful element here in the US who persist in treating Russia as the enemy. IMHO, we should be allies. I do feel that we might have been that these last few years except for those people here who cannot rid themselves of the investment they have in fighting a cold war that should have ended in 1989. We missed a grand opportunity at that time, and instead of taking advantage of it, we sat back laughing when greedy westerners tried to take control of Russia. What a loss!
To Kermit
The Berlin Wall was built for a simple reason – as you would know after the war Germany was divided and occupied, one half by USSR the other by USA. Russia ended it’s occupation couple or so decades later, hence the reason for the Wall to come down. The US occupying it still.
As you would also know the plans to attack USSR while it still lay in ruins were discussed by former wartime “allies” immidiately after the war. Churchill even proposed a plan for such attack. The Wall was not for “keeping people in”, it was to keep the enemies out.
I will agree with you unreservedly though, that the greatest opportunity to be genuine allies was missed..twice, that time and once again in 1989. Going back in history, Imperial Russia and US were strong allies – during your “War of Independence” with England Russia was firmly on your side and helped a great deal. Now, of course you wouldn’t find that in your new “history” books.
Civil War too, Russian fleet supported Union, which won the war, hence Russia supported USA again.
Ah, so all the people shot at the wall were trying to get IN?
Sorry, but I was over there in the vicinity in both 1962 and 1966. I know better than that.
But we agree on how at least the opportunity in 1989 was squandered by America. What a waste. We currently have a president who, in my opinion, really wants better relations with Russia. Unfortunately, there are elements here that have made that nearly impossible. I do have hopes that, in his second term, this might change. But, the Deep State here is very deep and powerful and entrenched.
My son has many Russian friends. The impression I have is that they mostly all like and respect VVP.
Kermit,
I have to mention that the wall was not built to keep people in, it was built to keep people from west Berlin from coming IN. Stalin, being a communist, started rebuilding Eastern Germany and everyday life was normalized much faster than in the west part of the city. Western Berlin was in total chaos, inflation, no food, no work, while Eastern part functioned more or less normally – no starvation, and speedy reconstruction of essential services – water, electricity, heat, medical. Many westerners were coming east for work, for shopping (Western German Mark was torpedoed by USA, and nothing could be bought in the western part of the city. Russians did not mind, until sabotages and diversions begun happening on their side. KGB promptly figured out how the sabotages happened. So the wall was built to control entry to Eastern Berlin. However, USA propaganda turned things upside down. USA announced to whole world that the wall was to prevent people escaping from east. At least at the beginning, when the wall was built, life in Eastern Berlin was way better than in the West.
As for GDP = Gross Domestic Product, you perhaps know that in USA each business transaction is counted twice for GDP. Plus, it is hard to understand how non-productive transactions count as GDP contribution. For example, Apple sues Microsoft, law firms on both sides make millions in fees, and that is neatly added to GDP.
:-)
Zidar
Your comment is fascinating. It is the first time that i have read that the eastern part was in reality better developed than the western part of Berlin. I had only heard that Stalin was initiially offered Marshall Aid but refused it… I knew at the time from reports that Ulbricht was accused of building the wall whilst officially denying it….i knew that tenders had been issued by the East Germans for concrete and barbed wire, which the east could not supply – and it was British and French organisations that supplied something as basic as the concrete for the wall and the barbed wire… I learnt that there was a high level agreement between the USA and Russia, since Kennedy was worried about the possibility for a flood of east germans to go west, which the US occupiers would not be able to cope with…and Kruschev pointing out that he needed the skilled workers to stay in place. In 1990 when the wall came down, my own travels brought me to Hungary on business …where i met a beautiful east German woman… and as she had worked for the MfS, the State Security services, she gave me some rich insights about the Russians …that she had been treated extremely kindly by all Russian soldiers, that Russians were kept in former Nazi barracks which were never rebuilt or improved and that the east Germans could see for themselves that Russia was in no fit shape to “attack the west.” Also, when the wall came down in 1989, she was one of the many who had by then, a nice home and a decent job to go back to, so why should she want to escape permanently to the west, when all that was missing was the ability to travel abroad sometimes (but return home where your roots are) ?. I also learnt from her back in the 1990s just how extremely well the Ukraine was doing within Comecon, in comparison to east Germany…
i agree with you about the GDP issue – on Purchasing Power Parity terms, Russia is doing fine….even in 2019 i was reading in the British press where journalists were bringing out the old canard that Russia is “a basket case with an economy no bigger than that of Italy, inspite of the vast size of the country”… same with China…no western journalist can bring himself to state that the Chinese economy is number 1 in Purchasing Power Parity terms, already since a while….the Dollar value is still touted as the only “real” value to measure by…
When the wall was built, 1961 if memory serves, Stalin was dead long ago and West-Berlin was at least stabilised.
True, Stalin died in 1953. The wall was built 1961. I only explained preventing people from coming in. And in 1961 USA and SSSR were not on friendliest terms… so somebody figured out it would be better to secure open border.
Western Berlin was built up later, in order to show how life is better in the west than in the east. In 1961 Eastern Berlin and whole DDR were not as posh as USA. But we should not forget that about that time, UK was suffering food shortages, coupons for food were in place. At least food was secure in eastern block, and some less important things – jobs, health care, education…. Just saying. However, Western Berlin had Coca Cola and one could buy blue jeans at any time. Traveling, of course. Westerners could travel anywhere, lots of them in my Yugoslavia. But I noticed also Poles, Czecs, Hungarians, even East Germans. And they were allowed to travel all over eastern block. Which includes beaches on Romanian and Bulgarian part of Black Sea, Crimea, Sochi. No need for travel health insurance. It was all included.
True, some people were shot in attempts to escape. It is normal that at least some will consider living under Russian ‘occupation’ unacceptable. After all, they were Germans, many had relatives killed in WWII, by the very Russians. Then they escaped to be occupied by Americans, to this day. It is also normal for Russians to be paranoid about spies and not trust anybody. After all, western berlin was an enclave faraway from USA zone in Western Germany, established exactly for purpose of – spying. Then in 1991 Russians left. Americans are still there. But hey, Coca Cola and jeans, that is life my friends. All shinny and glittery.
As for traveling through Yugoslavia and Greece 60 years ago, well, one can always see what they want and interpret it based on their experience and education. Greece was NATO, never part of Eastern block. One can tell that life in the west was not universally “better”. Depends on values important to people.
“As for traveling through Yugoslavia and Greece 60 years ago, well, one can always see what they want and interpret it based on their experience and education.”
Well, if you prefer a simple life that is decades behind other countries, yes, Yugoslavia seemed like a nice peaceful place back in the 60s. I will say that in my travels that included driving down to Dubrovnik, then inland over a mostly one lane mountainous road where my fastest speed was about 25 km/hr, and then down to Thessaloniki, Greece was quite a trip. Americans did not ever take that route. When the people found that I was American and not German, I was treated in a very friendly way. Note – this was when Americans still “wore white hats” and prior to when my country became so aggressive and were seen as “wearing black hats.”
However, since I have spent my life studying how markets and economies work – and don’t work – it is clear to me that Central Planning will always turn out to be a disaster. It is all about incentive. Take that away and you have nothing. Here in the US, I have always said that whenever the government gets involved in economics, they f*** it up. Almost always this is the case. This is why China moved more toward less Central Planning for everything – they realized that it did not work, and that they could never catch up if they didn’t change.
Years studying a topic mean little unless the breadth of taxonomies are explored, and ultimately a holistic perspective is ultimately achieved. The idea that there is some magic factor that makes things different when “government” does something as opposed to any other type of organization (such as private business/etc.) is something that evades me when I hear people voice this heuristic opposition to “government involvement”.
When you say “central planning”, is there some aspect of the communist-style countries’ approach to central planning that makes it different from and less good than the western style of central planning (allowing banks, planning commissions, private interests/rich people, etc. to make all* of the major decisions in an unaccountable and undemocratic way)?
I agree that in the US the government always ‘f***s up’ when it intervenes in the economy, but that is to say that the results of government intervention result in different circumstances than the purported intent of said intervention… If it simply lied about it’s intent and actually did achieve what it secretly intended to do, then it’s just a question of corruption and/or the gullibility of the people.
What rationale is there that supports the assumption that not* planning ahead is superior to planning ahead when a balanced, well-diversified economy is the desired result?
I ask this because in my country (America) the boomer generation and the Generation X (I’m a millennial) are still drunk on the reagonian rhetoric of “deregulation” and such ideas… but these people are also arrogantly anti-intellectual, hedonistic spuds… I’m used to hearing these neocon swine in America say things like that, but I’m surprised to hear that coming from a Yugoslav. I would like to know your rationale so I can differentiate it from the American talking points which sound similar.
Zidar
Fascinating keeping the West out. Pardon me for not taking you on your word. The history I learned was completely different. I do not mind revising my views but then you need to provide lots of proof. What you write would turn my beliefs upside down. So proof please.
The triumph of evil : the reality of the USA’s cold war victory
A. Murphy
https://orientalreview.org/2017/12/07/episode-20-put-berlin-wall/ by Nikolai Starikov
Yep, VVP just didn’t response the way PCR wished!
Putin is a professional manager, administrator and politician with a background in the security services, foreign and counter-intelligence and international affairs.
Anyone with solid experience, reaching an advanced stage in their professional career can tell you that it takes a lot of effort, dedication, patient, diplomacy and levelheadedness to reach that stage, let alone managing / running an entire major (super) power.
Being rash, emotional, arrogant or inpatient in such a role is very dangerous to say the least and destructive in the long run.
And this is the year especially mid October for the much vaunted “October Surprise”. Yes, perilous times.
Trump flew in to Sacramento on Monday and this is what the local paper had to report:
“..around 1 p.m., a CHP car reportedly struck a pedestrian who approached the law enforcement car with anti-Trump demonstrators rallying against police brutality. A video posted to social media showed one of the activists attempted to climb on the car, which then abruptly accelerated. Around 1:30p.m., an ambulance arrived in response to the incident and took away an unidentified individual.”
No one approaching or messing with a police car is being given a “pass”. The Sacramento Bee is very pro BLM. The above comes as close to non reporting of an actual event as that of a drug user relating his version of reality in disjointed fashion. To say nothing of the fact that by definition one ceases being a pedestrian when one jumps onto a car or into a car.
Which leads me to ask…what is happening in Al Tanaf? Is the CIA running this with adult supervision by
Centcom? Or is the dual citizen cell of Israeli aviators just left there to “do their own thing”. ? Are we talking a set up for plausible deniability? sigh so many questions, so few intelligible answers.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/October_surprise
It’s bound to be a trick and no way will it be a treat!
Dear Katerina,
thank you very much for this wonderful piece!
It’s a shame you went under my radar… I recommend to all your (first?) article:
/relentless-march/
Big cheers from Germany (Bavaria) and hope to read from you soon…
The destruction of flight MH17 over Ukraine was in fact a botched attempt to shoot down VVP’s presidential jet, that was returning from Rio de Janeiro to Moscow on the same day at the hour over Ukraine.
Never! For a start check the money trail. Najib Razak originally received $681Million from the Saudi Royal Family which covered MH370. The payments then increased to $1B, which suggests that the later payment was for something extra as in MH17. And then finally immediately afterwards the disifo mobs started to blame Putin stating that he ‘switched’ I.D. between his plane and MH17, and in reality that should tell you who the real perpetrators were.
Katerina,
Thank you for your voice and thoughts.
VVP is playing chess, seemingly several games as you point out.
He also is playing Go. Weiqi is a game of spatial control.
VVP is moving to rebuild the geopolitical space of the USSR with the Union State, CIS, CSTO, and EAEU.
He is also moving Russia back in geopolitical space in the ME. Syria is the locus of those moves. The Eastern Mediterranean now sees a dozen or more naval ships, of use along the shore of the Levant, near Cyprus to signal to Turkey, and southward to Egypt. Then there is North Africa (Libya) and Central Africa, and Cuba (the base at Lourdes soon to be Russian), as well as a large investment of rubles and specialists to brace up Venezuela. Over in the Far East, the Japanese have been stiff-armed by Russia over the Kuril Islands. And the US has been alerted that North Korea is not standing alone. Russia has returned to Vietnam, Singapore and is reaching out with its vaccine for Covid-19 to Duterte, guaranteeing the Philippines will get Russian medicine.
VVP is no passive leader. He plans, operates and succeeds in masterful ways.
Only the ignorant who know little to nothing speak of VVP in negative terms.
The evidence of his mastery is overwhelming.
To Larchmonter
Dear friend and fellow critical thinker, I always look forward to YOUR comments as those are the most astute and analitical on this site. In fact that was exactly why I kept coming back to Saker to see what your thoughts were on various developments. You are my hero. : )
Dearest Katerina,
Your words are too generous. So glad you have stayed with the Vineyard. We are enriched with your comments and articles.
I try to anchor my POV on facts. We have an obligation to know the truth and protect it by presenting it along with our take on the matters we discuss.
What sold me on VVP’s “cunning” ways was Minsk 2. Though to all on the face of it, it seems to have “failed”, what it did was tie Germany to Kiev and burden both with the Bandera ideologues and the impossibility of any compromise to Putin’s 13 steps to what would be the end of Ukraine if they went forward, or if they stood pat.
We see the Ukraine staring into the abyss. By Putin’s design. He avoided a war and is taking in Donbass.
Be well and thanks for the remarks.
Is VVP making any moves with regard to OSCE……seems that it blunders along..not sending observers to Belarus elections and back in 2016 seriously criticised the elections then so is it part of the plot against that country so to speak..I think a couple months ago Russia expressed its serious concern about how it deals with (or not)the Donbass situation….can someone do a writeup about the organisation?
Dear Katerina,
First, thanks for you great essay.
Second, any westerner who has taken the time to watch Mr. Putin’s unrehearsed, off-the-cuff press conferences instantly realized that he is the greatest national leader on planet earth. Mr. Lavrov is a poltical genius. Mr. Peskov and Ms. Zakharova are great spokespeople. No need to gild these lillies. The two R and D morons who are competing for POTUS, as well as their underlings and spokespeople are mice by comparison.
Third, I would suggest to Mr. Putin that he take a much more bellicose, threatening tone, in public, with the leader of any nation that does not show Russia the respect it deserves. I say this because if Mr. Putin does not do that NOW, the western transnational deep state will increase the frequency and, for lack of a better expression, intensity of their domestic false flag attacks (Skripals, for example) in order to maintain in the minds of their citizens that Russia is an enemy. False-flag military attacks are IMO likely in the near future. I suggest Mr. Putin use the old “we will bury you” line in the UN general assembly, maybe with a little shoe-pounding, or my very own suggestion — “in 20 minutes we’ll replace your great cities with deep, wide craters”. Until the millions of people who are happily employed by the US’s war corporations are “scared straight”, their bosses and their leaders will continue the US’s so-far-very-profitable march to a “completely unexpected”, “completely unprovoked” WWIII. The release of the recently-declassified video documentary of the Tsar Bomba was a good first-step in the right direction, but sometimes you have to spell everything out for the idiot-leaders and their brainwashed-from-birth herds.
Have a good one, Katerina.
This business of trying to surprise the mocking opposition with some stunning display of military power seems so
Western, so “nekulturny”. Very unlike Sun Tzu. Very unlike VV Putin.
Remember that the greatest merit is to subdue the enemy without fighting.
Appearing weak and somnambulant does marvelous things to the enemy’s psychology. He mocks you right up until he realizes his ship is sinking under his feet. The respect for you that he did not have before that moment, and the respect for you he feels after that moment, are each valueless. What is the value of respect from a fool?
“Third, I would suggest to Mr. Putin that he take a much more bellicose, threatening tone, in public,”
V.V. will NEVER do this you know. Why? Because he is himself NOT a “bellicose, threatening” person. Never, in his life, has anyone said he spoke like this, or even close.
IN fact, the teacher who met him with another student when he was in his teens said of her first impression ” I was struck his quiet manner, his courteousness, his shy smile and his shock of golden hair” !!
One thing that is Putins’ greatest strength is this – it is his strong sense of National and from this Personal Identity. To coin a phrase – he knows who he is. And he has always been true to this. It’s something all could learn from. To never “play games”. To never assume a stance, to be other than who you are in other words.
Putin doesn’t lie. That’s not who he is. {which, of course, doesn’t mean he cant very adroitly side step something he doesn’t want to address :-) }. He is never disloyal, because that’s not who he is.
He will never Assume a Bellicose threatening manner, because that’s not who he is. He is and can be very very firm, and hard hitting, but it’s also done in his way, which is subtle, and carries a message that maybe only the intended recipient fully “gets”.
Which is the problem for the many who dont’ understand why he does what he does – they dont understand this character, nor how it will always operate.
Pamela, my dear, you nailed it!
Excellent portrait of the Statesman .They disappeared from the political life long ago.
Charles De Gaulle was last Statesman in Europe. Western politicians are managers and technicians , and more and more actors and entertainers .
Putin is a Statesman – a leader with a vision . Wise , with personal integrity – his judgements are balanced. Russia finally has a Statesman that she deserves.
Thank you Katerina
I guess maybe Katerina is a newcomer here.
Her essays do provide a note of passion and some new overviews.
But most people who frequent this blog are already supporters of Russia, Putin, and I think Slavs in general and are critical of the West, Israel, Anglo-Zionism, etc. and have been for years.
Of course there are finer points of debate, but the argument is made already years ago, when the Saker blog started up.
Katerina is not a newcomer here, I have been coming to this blod for more than two years. The points and the comments that are being made here are the current, up-to-date developments, something that seem to have escape you.
It is fascinating to look at Russia vs US in terms of Good vs Evil.
Looking back at Soviet history, there is nothing worst than atheism in terms of religious beliefs. But something good came out of the bad, and those were the industrialisation, education, science research and socialism which were preserved during the change from Communist Russia to Christian Russia. The communist heritage enabled Russia to overtake the West and will dominate the West in future.
If we carry on with Good vs Evil analogy, there are two things which I consider when looking at geopolitical events.
1. The current Gog and Magog World Order. The Order of destruction and corruption. Asides from “normal” corruption, there is corruption in science, medicine, economy, politics, money, education. Anything you can think of. And Gog and Magog are very strong, but they can be stopped but not defeated.
2. The world is fated to come to the War of Armageddon, the Advent of the Antichrist and the Return of Jesus. And all that would come before these Events.
It is fair enough to analyse events without taking the above into consideration, but for me, I always keep those two in mind, in the background.
This may seem passive, but passive in the sense that it is where all of us are going, like it or not.
But individually, this is not passive. We still need to fight oppression, even if we lose. But we will never lose, fighting oppression. Not in the long run, anyway.
what did kissinger have to say regarding putin. why do both putin and trump and others welcome psychotic lubavitcher into photo ops? those questions seem more relevant
VVP simply used Kissinger to get some background that he needed. Do not forger VVP’s background..
Hi Katerina
I recall after the shooting down of the airliner, i reported that the UK media was full of front page articles blaming Russia…but tellingly Philip Hammond stated “Hah…that will teach Russia a lesson…” (self-incrimination? ) …and David Cameron stated that he “knew exactly where the bomb had been planted” (not surprising to those who followed long before, how the SAS were training the terrorists)…so David Camerons boast was also self-incrimination, as he stated this before any official investigation.
Two evil psychopaths in the service of the Empire.
John Kerry said immediately after the MH17 shoot down; “We saw the take-off. We saw the trajectory, we saw the hit. We saw this aeroplane disappear from the radar screens. So there is really no mystery about where it came from and where these weapons have come from.”
They all incriminated themselves.
I forgot to be more specific, to avoid misunderstandings – the airliner i am writing about is the one that came down over the Sinai.. “.On 31 October 2015 at 06:13 local time EST (04:13 UTC), an Airbus A321-231 operating the flight was destroyed by a bomb above the northern Sinai following its departure from Sharm El Sheikh International Airport, Egypt, en route to Pulkovo Airport, Saint Petersburg, Russia.
Flight origin: Sharm El Sheikh International Air…
Destination: Pulkovo Airport, Saint Petersburg, …
ICAO flight No: KGL9268”
Thank you very much for the analysis. I hadn’t understood how MH17 fit into things; I had read about the VV Putin’s plane theory, but I never really believed it.
As far as Martial Arts is concerned, JuDo is one of the most ‘intimate’ of thee Arts, as the opponents are in contact throughout. Understanding one’s opponent is fundamentally essential.
I believe the strategy which produced the spectacular results for the Russian economy came from Sergei Glazyev, sho seems to be a quite, modest, and extremely passionate tactician. The contrast between high- ranking Russian and American public servants cannot be nore stark. The Russians seem completely goal-oriented, thus the economy could be re-directed quickly, and the military could act as a coherent force, as was done in Crimea. In the U.S., the generals each try to carve out their own separate domains of influence, and thus lack a general focus. The non-military high ranking public servants are universally large campaign donors collecting on favors. All the Federal agencies are thus characterized by chaos, corruption, and ass-covering. Public Service to them is a cynical ploy, it’s only about Donor-Service, at public expense. American leaders see the U.S. in terms of assets to strip, exactly as they see business opportunities.
Personally, I feel the Russophobia will only end with the end of the empire. The function of the intelligence agencies is to perpetuate the economy of the U.S., which being built on fraud and fabrication, benefits only those for whom those agencies work. These are the same people (or derivatives thereof) who attempted a coup on FDR, and for whose benefit WW II was conducted. Their goal is and has always been, to rid the world of communism, which in FDR’s time was gaining in popularity. They have spent the last 100yrs brainwashing the American public, as they own the major media outlets, and control school curricula; and with great success. I am amazed at the number of intelligent, highly educated people with whom I speak, who fall for the Skripal, Nalvalny, Novochok BS.
It would have been interesting to read Katerina’s analysis of Belarus.
As an aside to Aki: mi esposa es Uruguaya.
To larry
Your comment is very perceptive, especially for an american. Please do not see this as patronising, this your comment is truly appreciated! I wish there were more americans like you. We have lots in common and the divide between us that has been manufactured by the so-called media is an obstacle that needs to be crushed. But how can one do that? There are just five media entities, owned by Anglo-Zionists, that put out this brainwashing, controlling “information” which is all pervasive and sadly most people in the “West” do not seem to realise that.. They still watch it, they still read it.. still believe it..
Dear Katerina, although I agree with much of your points and that you for the article, one important point is faulty in my opinion in your interpretation of historic context and it deserves comment. For some reason Russia and VVP derives current statehood from Soviet Union. But even VVP does not vindicate the occupation of Hungary and Czechoslovakia later. Eight years I was attending grammar school with Soviet occupational army base some 50 meters from its backyard. We called them Russians and dreamed of having no foreign army here. Only few now dream of having western armies “protecting” us.
Now in discussions here I try to explain that not all of them were Russians, Stalin, Lenin were not ethnical Russians and even Brezhnev came from Ukraine, afaik. Simply said – Russia was cheered here befor occupation for defeating Germans (now called nazis instead even in your article, but instead of Soviets the Russians are indicated as historical invaders by MSmedia and politicians, interestingly). A lot of people understand it and the fact that bolshevism was evil mainly for Russians works here. Russophobia is not that popular in Central Europe (perhaps Poland being obvious exception) as you could observe from MSM. In fact the Soviet imperium history from 1950-1970 is the main reason, why you hardly find Russophiles here.
Why so much Russians still love Lenin and Stalin murdering so many of them I cannot understand, but it is Russians internal problem. However you simply cannot expect Czechs, Slovaks and Hungarians to agree and start loving Russia after explaining the Soviet invasion as “… obviously those two had to be brought back in line. It was an alliance after all…” It corresponds to Skripal case or serbian guilt for all Balkan evils level of propaganda in my view… This is not the way to make Russia “sexy” again, which is btw. the point where Russia still has to learn a lot (not to lose the battle you described).
Dear Hojer,
Perhaps I can – I am not replying for Katerina but nevertheless. Remember that I have a bit of Czech blood so have affinity for the Czechs.
If you are a Czech, you should be very grateful to Stalin indeed. He tried his best to save you from the clutches of your western partnyors. You played the Slavophile card when it suited you but did all you could to spite Russia while permanently reconciling with the long-time enemy of the Slavs. Remember your industry during the Warsaw pact and look at it now.
How come you don’t remember the “adventures” of the Czech legions in Russia at the end of WWI?
What the Russians did (or didn’t do) is completely dwarfed by what the Germanics did to you. Amnesic much?
Who was the largest weapons supplier to the German Reich?
Russia does not need to be made “sexy”. It will never be sexy but when the chips are down, they are the only ones that will even think about saving your posteriors. Perhaps not this time – the stunt with the statue was an insult too far.
Please understand I admire Czech patriotism and insistence on retaining their Slav identity while surrounded by the Germans. It seems though that this time the Western Slavs will march in unison with their tormentors.
Dear Mr. Ken Leslie, thanks for the comment. You are right in guessing my nationality. Now I completely agree with just 2 of your points: 1. compared with Germans the Soviets/Russians were polite invaders (but still invaders). 2. Yes, the Russians did harm us to just lesser extent, I even did not express nothing like that, on the contrary, not sure why you indicated amnesy in that point…
My comment could also be shortened to – not Russians, but bolshevism did harm us all (including Russians), if you want to gain hearts of Central Europe (western Slavs), do not use icons of Lenin, Stalin and company and vindicate Soviet invasions… that would not work.
As for Stalin you mentioned we should be grateful to, if you wish we can discuss it separately, I do not have much clue what you mean, if not WW2 won – for which we should be grateful rather to Russian people (remember he even called pop out of gulags to help in this instance?).
As for Czech legions in Russia WW1 – the just wanted to defeat the Germans on behalf of Russia and get back home. After the coup bolsheviks made peace with almost defeated Germans/Central Powers and started hostility towards Czechs. As for atrocities, according to Czech legions chronicles bolsheviks started it (against domestic enemies and Czechs too).
As for Slavophile card playing when suited – not sure what you are speaking about again; Austro-Hungarian empire had majority slavic population and Czechs were first to try to unite and organise together https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prague_Slavic_Congress,_1848 . The only two faults towards the slavic nations I see are: 1. that we did not claim Lusatia from Germany after WW1 or WW2 to save the Sorbs from germanisation, but we were happy to claim our historical borders then. 2. Not vetoing NATO bombing of Yugoslavia in favor of Kosovo in time when we were accepted in the pact for two weeks, if I remember correctly. For number 2 I am still ashamed, however majority of Czechs did not approve it then not does it now; I know Czech who went to Belgrade then and spent few days/nights making human shield on the bridge there… The trouble is in electing weak leaders as is the case almost everywhere now. Well, Madeleine Albright was born here but AFAIK she is not Czech but…you know who I am talking about.
Too long comment, so to conclude: our disagreement is in bolsheviks/Stalin et. al. issue, not in Russian issue. Do not link Slavia to Stalin/bolshevism please as it may work; I wish it works.
Russia is not under Stalin now and yet, you are treating her like a leper!
I am sure the harder edge is right around the next bend. Things are picking up speed internationally so there should be hard edges appearing everywhere soon enough.
In the meanwhile when is anyone going to notice the major moves of the monster Macron?
Blows Beirut sky high and then descends like an angel three days later showering all around with love peace and hope.
Funny how all those fish died in Iraq a few days before the euro-messiah Macron shows up with love peace and hope.
Macron reestablished France as a world power.
Dear Katerina,
A lovely little post and one of the better I’ve read on this site in recent times.
You’ve stated that your husband is of Scottish stock; that being so he is lucky that you accepted him, and vice versa of course.
For me, one of the best examples of Putin’s intellect and control was when the American President Obama called Putin ‘a dick and a jackass’ and Putin never moved as much as a muscle on his face; total control , and far superior to the idiocy displayed by Obama.
Katerina, you asked this question: “Did you know that one of their main objectives in meddling in Ukraine was to remove the Russian Naval Base from Crimea and replace it with their own?” This objective was planned by General David Petraeus the former head of the CIA and was assisted by the FBI’s James Yacone, and the liaison officer between them was Lt. Colonel Paula Broadwell.
Again, you stated that; ” the Russian intelligence service is second to none” and it is, and actually the reason for this is quite simple; good leaders bring out the best in all of those under him.
In 2012 when the FBI agent, Tamerlan Tsarnaev came under the notice of your FSB, they reported the matter back to the FBI’s Legal Attaché’s office at the U.S. embassy in Moscow in March 2012. When this didn’t create the desired outcome the FSB in September 2012, issued their second alert to the CIA in regard to their suspicions about Tamerlan Tsarnaev.
This second alert did create a response, the Boston Bombing psy-op that saw Tamerlan Tsarnaev blamed for a created bombing where there were no casualties, and the Tsarnaev was arrested by the FBI and murdered, and then on the on the 20th May 2013, the suspected Russian informer,Ibragim Todashev was ‘interviewed and then murdered by an FBI agent, I believe to be James Yacone, at his home in Orlando, Florida.
And all of this tells me that the Russian FSB, and thus Putin were aware of what was to happen in the Ukraine two years before the event. And to reinforce that Russian belief were all of the other ridiculous moves such as advertising for the job of refurbishing Russian bases in Crimea.
And then there was that final move, the hijacking of the Malaysian airliner MH370, which I have mentioned previously, being hi-jacked by the CIA, with James Yacone of the FBI waiting in the wings in KL to lead the charge against Iran and then NATO as per Britain would need air bases in the Crimea to attack Iran, and the new Ukrainian parliament would offer ‘their services’.
But that never happened did it? Somebody picked MH370 out of the CIA’s pocket, and guess who? This may give you a clue.
https://au.news.yahoo.com/sa/a/23036893/exploration-company-believes-it-may-have-found-mh370/
An Adelaide-based exploration company believes it may have located the wreckage of Malaysia Airlines flight MH370, 5000km away from where authorities have been looking. The company, GeoResonance, says its research has identified elements on the ocean floor consistent with material from a plane.
Six weeks have now passed since the plane disappeared and extensive searches in the Indian Ocean have failed to locate any wreckage. GeoResonance believes authorities have been looking in the wrong place.
It started its own search for the missing aircraft on March 10. “The technology that we use was originally designed to find nuclear warheads, submarines… our team in the Ukraine decided we should try and help,” David Pope from GeoResonance said. The company surveyed over 2,000,000 square kilometres of the possible crash zone, using images obtained from satellites and aircraft.”
Now just who exactly were GeoResonance, out of the Ukraine, (read Crimea) with technology designed to find ‘nuclear warheads and submarines’? They wouldn’t have been Russian Naval Intelligence would they?
Putin does play chess, and very well too. What we can surmise from the reports on Tsarnaev in March 2012 is that the Russian FSB knew then what was being planned by Petraeus and company and Putin moved his chess pieces accordingly, and his chess pieces are the very best in the world.
And meantime, here am I stuck in Geelong in Victoria, Australia suffering under the dictatorship of a total Marxist clown in a ‘Police State’ that hasn’t been seen since the 1917 revolution in Russia.
Thanks for the opportunity to vent Katerina, and God Bless!
Dear Katerina, your essay is a joy to read!
I permit myself to add something on German’s role. There is no doubt many Germans who wish for a more independent Germany. But politicians and the media are controlled by the empire. The empire is controlled by a small class of ultra rich which is waging an economic warfare against the peoples of the countries under the empire. We are unfortunately all increasingly Latvians, Greeks and even Ukrainians now. Western Europe is committing economic suicide in the name of a green future and mandatory convictions and institutional force are suffocating all resistance.
A louder resistance is growing in Germany however, and partly because of the past, parts of the apparatus is reluctant to engage in open fascism, like the terror police against the yellow wests in France. I am not particularly optimistic about Germany, but now I see glimpses of hope. It is very exciting to see if the empire will succeed in stopping Nord Stream 2.
Thank you for these interesting points. I hope you’re right about these glimmers of hope. From where I stand, Germans do not look like they’re resisting. They are allowing Merkel & co to ridicule the country with all those farcical statements about the Navalny affair…
But I’m sure you’re better placed to assess the mood of the people.
Thankyou for another excellent article Katerina
Agree with your assessment of Putin. He is in the position to be seeing all the facts relevant to making critical decisions. At this time in world history theres 3 world leaders who are saving humankind from a devastating war of all against all – VVP, Xi & Khamenei
Just to show you how moronic these former Soviet republics are by joining the Eurozone Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, and Slovakia have
1. surrendered their monetary sovereignty (i.e. their ability to issue their own currency) to the European Central Bank (ECB) which is actually a bankers cartel
2. the ECB also sets the monetary policy (interest rates) for the Zone while fiscal policy (taxation) takes place through the Eurogroup – which makes political decisions regarding the eurozone and the €.
3. Worse still, the Eurozone has no legal provisions for a member state to leave or to be expelled – once in – currently there’s no legal way out! See: “Dutch PM: Eurozone needs exit clause”. Fox, Benjamin, 1 February 2013), EUobserver.com
How do you run a national economy if you cant get your hands on the brakes and the levers??? Madness!
In addition just look at the collapse in population from Soviet times to the present day:
– Latvia: 1989 – 2,666,567; 1,907,675 (2020 est) down 28.5%
– Lithuania: 1991 – 3,704,000; 2,794,000 (2019) down 24.5%
– Estonia: 1990 – 1,570,599; 1,328,976 (2020 est) down 15.3%
– Slovakia showed a minor increase from 1991 – 5,274,335 to 5,457,926 (2020 est) up 3.5%
For the Baltics, these are catastrophic reductions for a nation’s development over only 30 years or so
Throughout the history of humanity – countries can make mistakes
Regards
Katerina,
I have no argument with your article. I just want to say that when you talk about sanctions against Russia, as an Iranian, I have to wonder how real the animosity between the empire and Russia really is.
Notice I say the empire, and not the West, EU, US, etc. It is a well known strategy of the Zionist overlords to keep the satrapies of their empire in a state of competition. And if the competition escalates to all-out war, even world war, they do not seem to mind, and in fact, can find a way to benefit from it.
But regarding Russian sanctions. Is it possible to make purchases using a western credit card or debit card in Russia? Can Russians make purchases using their credit cards or debit cards in the rest of the world? Is it possible to wire transfer money to Russian bank accounts from the rest of the world?
If the answer to these questions is yes, then my follow up question is, what sanctions?
Russia is not cut off from the Zionist worldwide banking network. Russia is home to multiple Zionist Jewish billionaires who are perhaps as powerful and influential as Putin, if not more so.
If you want to know what real sanctions look like, I point you to Iran. It is near impossible to get money in or out of Iran. No credit card or debit card of any non-Iranian bank is any good in Iran, and vice versa, an Iranian credit/debit card will not work anywhere else in the world. No online company will ship anything to Iran, even if you found a way to make payment. Not Indian companies, not European, not anywhere. Try to export something from Iran. No one anywhere will touch it. And even if they do, you will be legally barred from taking the money from your sale back to Iran. If you try, your money will be blocked. Try to get a tourist visa for pretty much anywhere, as an Iranian. Good luck.
I could go on, but I’m sure you get the point.
So, why are we buying into this “fake” confrontation between the West and Russia, when both side are just provinces of the Zionist empire? We’ve already seen this show before.
Dear Jamshyd,
Your obsession with Zionism is understandable but if you are saying that Russia is somehow colluding with the West, you are going way too far and showing a lack of knowledge of history. Again, this is understandable – Iran has its own geopolitical stance (which should be respected) and any right-thinking person must oppose the cruel sanctions against the country. This should not be about comparing victimhoods but strengthening resistance.
I am not defending Russia – I am not privy to their decision making. At the same time, Iran was content to collaborate and support its own enemies (Americans, Sunni cutthroats and others) in the early 1990s in order to establish a presence in the Balkans. This doesn’t mean that Iran is a Zionist puppet or does it?
Thank you
No, they are not colluding with the west. That is not what I said. You are misunderstanding me.
From what I know of history, I say that a certain group of rich people, let’s not call them Zionists or Jews, let’s just say that a group of very rich and powerful people who were deeply dominating the affairs of the world around the turn of the last century, set up multiple competing systems. Capitalist, Socialist, Communist, etc.
They pitted these systems against each other, in order to divide and conquer, but also in order to dominate the world through the hegemon that would emerge from that competition.
I am not obsessed with Zionism. I just think it is unmistakably clear who is running the world right now. It is _their_ empire. And Russia is part of that empire. It does not matter whether Russia or the West come out on top, in my opinion. Because either way, it is our rich and powerful overlords who are coming out on top.
It isnt about comparing victimhood, as you say, because Russia is not a victim. Russia is on par with the West. It is a fair fight as far as I’m concerned. The empire has no quarrel with Russia.
They are simply watching Russia and the West duke it out, as if a gladiatorial match. And so are we. We are too distracted by the US vs Russia match to realize what is really going on.
The Achaemenid king of kings had the Greek city states battling each other over two thousand years ago. The Spartans, Athenians, Thebans, etc. really believed that they had some quarrel with each other and that their struggle mattered. It did not. It was all a waste of their time and resources, for the benefit of the Persian empire.
I said we’ve seen this show before. This is not the first time the West and Russia, USSR back then, are fighting it out. It is not the first time the world is divided and everyone’s blood is boiling over it. Like the Romans watching the gladiators.
Ken Leslie, there is no need for you to get annoyed at me. I am not insulting your favorite football team. I’m saying the whole league is rigged, and all the matches are simply for entertainment purposes.
No problem, Jamshyd,
“My team” lost up to 40 million people in 30 years to the tender mercies of their partners and I don’t take lightly anyone taking that lightly.
Why do you assume you know the truth?
You know that there are many who claim that Khomeini was a western plant (like Lenin – German trains, French planes etc.) whose task was to prevent Iran from achieving its full potential. Perhaps the Zionists themselves. The Shah had a nuclear programme that would have caused them real problems.
From Wikipedia:
“President Gerald Ford signed a directive in 1976 offering Tehran the chance to buy and operate a U.S.-built reprocessing facility for extracting plutonium from nuclear reactor fuel. The deal was for a complete ‘nuclear fuel cycle’.”[27] The Ford strategy paper said the “introduction of nuclear power will both provide for the growing needs of Iran’s economy and free remaining oil reserves for export or conversion to petrochemicals.”
A 1974 CIA proliferation assessment stated “If [the Shah] is alive in the mid-1980s … and if other countries [particularly India] have proceeded with weapons development we have no doubt Iran will follow suit.”[28]
Your wrath towards the West is misplaced, mate. The enemy likes to hide. And you are not seeing him.
Your wrath towards me is even more misplaced. I do not care about Khomeini or Iran. I only brought up Iran as an example of sanctions from the empire to show that Russia is not in fact under any sanctions that count. I have no country. My team is the human race, the trees, the birds, the animals, the fish…
I’ve lost more guys than you can count. And our enemy is cutting my team to bits while you cheer on Russia vs USA.
To Jamshyd
As an Iranian, do you actually live in Iran? I will have to enlighten you – Russia is not colluding with the West, it is also not a part of it, Russia, just like your country, is the one subjected to various western sanctions and it’s coping quite well with those. It is also helping Iran (together with China) to withstand the horrendous sanctions imposed on Iran, therefore I do not understand the purpose of your comment.
Yes Katerina, I live in Iran.
But you are not hearing me. Where did I say Russia is colluding with the West?
The West does not rule the world. The West, ie. USA, EU, Australia, etc. is part of a global empire that exists today. This empire’s central axis, its backbone, is a global banking network. Every citizen of the empire is connected to this network, and every one of them has credit and debt.
This global banking network, aka the empire, owns the USA. They also own Russia, and pretty much every other country in the world.
Sometimes it is in their interest to have their clients fight. Like WW1 and WW2. The clients emerge beat up, the empire emerges more powerful.
The true enemy of Russia is not the West. It is the imperial banking network, the true tyrant and oppressor of the world. The West is simply a puppet of that big bank.
But the reality is, Russia is also at the mercy of the bank, the empire.
Every country that is part of the empire is allowed to act freely to protect their interests against other countries, but not against the empire itself.
Going against the empire gets you severed from the global banking system, which means you cannot do trade with anyone.
Russia is part of this global banking system, which means they are subservient to the empire.
Russia vs USA is a ploy of the empire. It doesn’t matter who wins, nothing will change.
The real enemy of Russia, the enemy of all mankind, is the nameless faceless empire that has dominion over West and East, and no one can escape it.
I don’t know how to put it any more simply.
Hi, Jamshyd,
There is something to what you’re saying. What you are saying is that this dark empire cannot be seen but its effects are felt – like aether in physics. Unfortunately, that is not helpful because it leaves no room for hope. Again, perhaps that’s justified but if these invisible villains (zionists of some sort I presume) are so powerful as to pull our strings so masterfully that we are incapable of resisting, then we fully deserve our fate.
Second, how come they never made Russia invade and destroy the West? Or Iran invade and destroy Iraq?
Perhaps they are not as powerful as you think.
Ken, Have you read the protocols of the learned elders of Zion?
These people were drawing up roadmaps for world domination when my people were still herding sheep and goats in the hills.
Read the protocols. Everything in that book has come to pass. It will chill you to your bones.
Dear Jamshyd,
Yes I have. Please go to my article “The Last Taboo” and find the discussion in the comments. It’s been covered and please don’t be afraid. Just look at the tragic history of the Jews. When I point that out, people go – oh, but Rothschild funded the Nazis etc. They are powerful but not all-powerful. Here is the late hero of the resistance, president Milosevic of Serbia:
“A greater evil exists behind America
This is the evil I am fighting
There is something satanic
In that false American smile
That evil of theirs is not of this world.
I’ve seen it.
This is no longer the fight of a freedom-loving people
against imperialism.
This is the fight against the enemies of humanity.
The ancient tales are true.
They will grab one nation after another.
I am alone in my struggle
For the first time I’m afraid for my people.”
Slobodan Milošević
That is right on the mark, Ken. My hat’s off to Milosevic, and to you.
‘tragic history of the jews’…..messanicly exceptional; karma, is a bitch’n bastard.
Cheers, M
Katerina,
Russia is under sanctions by the West.
Iran is under sanctions by the empire.
Because of the empire’s sanctions, Iran cannot do business with Russia.
If Russia were not part of the empire, why would they not do business with Iran, the enemy of the West?
There is a distinction here, between the West and the empire.
Can you see it?
Hello Jamshyd,
you are right imo. Whole world turmoil is just a game played by some top notch Group. I would define them are revolutionary Globalists, followers of Lucipher/Sheitan who is their master and guiding them to achieve planetary control of everything and in the end of end times when the spiritual reality of things become more obvious people will worship Lucipher as a God. (which he is not, he is just an archangel who rebelled against Creator and his final demise is close as Creator never loses control in the game).
Also, in many ways Iran is a Zionist puppet, in so far as it is being manipulated by the empire. The vast scope and reach of today’s global empire is historically unprecedented. Their power boggles the mind. Their management skills are unfathomable.
They are running Iran’s affairs, indirectly from without, whereas they run other countries directly from within. Their power is like a mighty torrent.
Hence, the resistance.
We understand how strong they are. We know that reason says we cannot beat them. So all we can do is resist.
Jamshyd, you are speaking of the International Puppet Master Club, no borders, no country, loyal only to mammon. Every country on the planet, as you so rightly pointed out, has them. Great call. As for sanctions against Russia, that was an international MRGA play. It seems to be working, making your historical understanding of how the cream of the International Inbred Pedoelite work, truly commendable. Eyes wide open.
Cheers, M
To Jamshyd
Russia and China are working together to subvert this banking empire that you have described. It is not that easy and cannot be undone too fast, but it is happening. Slowly but surely. So, have faith, the “empire” is not going to win.
I do have faith that they are going to go down Katerina. As surely as spring comes and drives away the coldest, darkest, gloomiest winter.
I just want to be on the same page about what is going on, and who the real enemy is, pitting nation against nation, people against people, and the true horror of this winter we are in right now.
Cheers, and good luck to you and your fellow Russians!
I have right here in front of me, right now, a 500 gram packet of Aldi “Sweet Vine” branded dates, purchased very recently in Melbourne, labeled “Product of Iran”.
Its always the exception that *proves the rule!
Regards
T
As a Serb I am responsible, since your comments affects my people, to answer you. Maybe someone can correct me with the arguments he has. Thanks to Saker for making it possible say something for the Russian leadership.
1……. he will respond only when that response is absolutely required, as in retaliatory sanctions on EU, which apparently now costing them BILLIONS ……..
Russia has lost much more, and has not made European partners think about their mistakes because they are just vasals. Propaganda may be doing its thing, but it will not deceive anyone except the citizens of Russia. EU-robia with lack of one hundred billion is not affected so much, especially in addition to the ability of Dragi-Legard helicopter money. If Russia starts doing the same, it is a spiral from which there is no way out. Furthermore, Poland, for example, imported its goods through Belarus, Italy through Serbia. Russia thus got rid of ones with sanctions, and got the export import mafia of another type. She developed her own food production, but who had defended them this before? Better business loans to their own people? In addition to the Liberals, Putin’s government is so strong! after 20 years that he needed sanctions to make a difference? Furthermore, Russian companies, both small, medium and large, are under sanctions, while large joint-stock multicultural giants with foreign investments, such as Gazprom, are at the same time the sponsor of the Champions League in football. What is the estimate of foreign shareholders in all so-called Russian giant companies …… Gazprom, Rosneft, Rosatom, etc. Not to mention the sale of raw materials to the west through Deripaska’s consortium directly to MIC for the sake of Russians or the sale of rocket engines.
2:…. he looks far ahead and plans accordingly. Crimea is a very good example of that …….
Crimea was a good move from the beginning not to drag you into aggression, but to wait for the people to come to their senses under mass media treatment in the economic collapse that already happened two years ago, makes no sense. The people are losing confidence in Russia. its identity, moves out. The country collapses which the Russian people will again have to pay later as damage. By getting Crimea, you got as much from all of Russia as a Serb from Kosovo through four Trump municipalities in the north.
3. …..he south east of it, Mariupol and Odessa in the south (as Russian as it gets!) will eventually follow Donbass, and the rest, as far as Russia is concerned, can go to hell.
I can’t believe that a Russian can say something like this at all. This is what the Yugoslav cosmopolitan converts say, for whom their interests are the most important. Maybe it’s a woman’s fear of war or marrying Scott and living a few thousand miles away. Who knows?
4. …only Serbia so far has not sold itself out, but her government, unfortunately has, as was amply demonstrated by the latest developments, which I am sure made most Serbs cringe.
I see that some scared Russians still need to praise themselves, but then spit on the allies. Maybe you are to young, but someone need to remind you of something. While the Russians were despairing in the 1990s and letting the Americans and the British into their facilities through Yeltsin’s liberals, we were at war with the same people. For nine years, so-called Russian leaders had been stealing state property. First they lowered prices and then either sold them to foreigners or bought themself.
You see….We would like to get rid of Vucic as we wanted with Milosevic. From the first one to the second, Moscow has allways deal with the West to ease the pressure on itself. Vucic received from Putin support every time before the elections. Each time your leadership said that it was behind Resolution 1244, and then confirmed that it would recognize everything that the Serbian government accepts? What does that mean? Is that what force does? Gives medals to traitors. Since when? The ally probably asks what the Serbian people need. Milosevic’s wife and family fled to Moscow with billions looted from Cyprus and through Zagreb Bank. Moscow has not finished it’s job anywhere, not because it can not, but does NOT want to. Not in Syria, not in Libya, not in the Balkans. Do not forget that they were a support to Montenegrins when they left the alliance with Serbia. Again, for the benefit of obtaining information, selling goods, making allies in EU bodies. Showing fine manners over Serbian backs.
5. …this, your sad quisling “government” needs to be replaced, and fast
You see, we would like to change it, but there is no logistics from the Russian side. In fact, our service works together with yours, our army works together with yours. How is it possible that the Russians decided to be so nice. Americans can change the regime, but the Russians can not? It would also be nice if someone delivered weapons to allies, and not smeared honey around our mouths. To send us some old bins on credit. If they are allies, let them not worry about credit repayment, let them deliver what is requested and they will not need to fight our thing. Maybe the Russian government is afraid that we will disappear :), so there will be no one to repay the loan. They may be afraid of our hot heads of what we might cause, while doing business with EU partners. Mybe they decided to keep our souls from the interenational devil?
6. …..What makes the Russian President stand head and shoulders above those Western politicians
Like with the vaccine of globalists? They had a peak at May this year and a vaccine in August for sale? Funny. Also, in addition to sanctions blocking the construction of non-nuclear power plants, arms sales outside Russia’s borders, we will see whether the gas flows on which Putin’s policy and Lavrov’s diplomacy are largely based will pass. Otherwise, waiting in vain in Ukraine-Belarus was for nothing. Some dissatisfied people in Russia could start thinking other way around.
7……hegemon is collapsing in front of our eyes and this is one of the most dangerous moments, but as I have pointed out in one of my previous comments, there is a very wise saying, I believe by SUN TZU – why disturb your enemy when it’s self- destructing.
It is the truth on the ground that denies what you write down. Trump need the BLM protesters more than Biden to win the election. Why else did they choose Biden, an unsuitable candidate in addition to all capable people in the Democratic Party. And then the hegemon will not fall without dragging the whole world into the abyss. Your optimistic thoughts deny the facts and events in history. Furthermore, this Sun Tzu to whom you refer is certainly not this one in Russia. In his time, there was no red and black international. The red fascist bourgeoisie and their interests.
To djole
You shouldn’t have bothered..
I hope Saker gives me a chance to answer you for the sake of other people on the site to give their comments.
Serbs today like Russians, have parades even though the people do not live in the system of values that their ancestors wanted. We left Serbs from the surrounding area to their fate and international factor for the sake of international future. We still don’t have listed victims of wars, we dont have the public register. Services are hiding information like a snake’s legs. Also from the First World War things have not been clarified. What is the situation in Russia? We have no lawsuit for GENOCIDE in World War II. We do not have a memorial center like the Jewish Yad Vassem. Do you have? What about your lawsuit against the Nazis for genocide? Against the so-called brothers.
Vucic appears as a protector of children in snowy areas, helps animals, he is pictured next to our company FAP trucks, next to our military weapons. Which are not like russian “best in world”, but “the best in the region”. In the same time our people in surounding are suffering. Amazing, isn’t it? He doesn’t go down in the sea by submarine because we don’t have one or he doesn’t ride a horse on vacation because this one should probably be realy big to hold “upper one”, but that’s why he does other things. He gives passports to Hollywood actors and some political asylum seekers while an ordinary Serb from abroad waits several years for citizenship. Today, Vucic is the biggest protector of the region, explaining that Serbs will no longer go to war, trying to flatter Western European partners. Who does that remind you of?
By the way, people in Serbia do dirty work for salaries of 200-300 euros. Serbia is becoming a camp for jobs that others will not do. Once we had own production of everything, now we import stuff. We even import fruits and vegetables. Our ancestors turn in the grave. Bin Zayed from the Emirates is opening shopping malls and skyscrapers that are gaping empty like in Russia. Masonic bridges are being built that cost billions of taxpayers’ money where they don’t need it, and there are none where they need it. Stadiums for football championships are being built (bread and games), while schools and hospitals in smaller communities are being neglected. The Marrakesh Agreement is signed and migrants arrive. AFTER ALL VICTIMS, a regional union is planned, something similar to the Lisbon Vladivostok transversal, but at the local level.
You’re welcome……
Djole,
I understand your (mainly justified) anger. The most important thing now is to understand that Russia MUST survive because without it there will be no Serbs. Do you agree? Everything else are family squabbles.
Second, I fully endorse your idea for an All-Russian (or All-Slav) memorial to the victims of the Slav Holocide to be located in Moscow (with branches elsewhere) – with a special accent on WWII.
To survive next to 7500 nuclear warheads?Next to all wealth they have in the biggest land on the earth?
Sorry, but that’s frivolous and unobjective Leslie. An American can comfortably say that he planned to assassinate the president of another state … yesterday Trump … Russians allow themselves to be drag into some games around Skripalj. American would level another country to the ground for a couple of dead people, the Russian leadership does not spare Russian lives. Why? if they are equal to the power of America as they claim it so? The Russian leadership “gave the football ball to the volley” to the Germans, by sending Navalny (a liberal on duty – double agent) to Berlin. Would that be what the German government or the British would do also? Would Stalin or some Imperial tzaristic statesman who holds to the dignity of the country do that? Why do they allow themselves to be humiliated? For the interests of the Russian fugitive oligarchy in London? Because of failed flows? Well, as a pure layman, I wrote two years ago that Americans will first let the Russians wear out pockets on pipes construction, but that they will not allow to finish gas flows at any cost and gas to pass through them. What does the Russian service do? Where is the security check? In 2018/2019, the Russian leadership and services allowed over 800 members of oligarchic families to buy Maltese citizenship for a million dollars and thus transfer themselves to England. Putin asked them to return and offered them forgiveness for the investment of stolen money in Russia? I do not understand. Are they outside the laws and Constitution? Putin put Medvedev away half a year ago, so that he can let the same man take over the Arctic business now? What about the Russian central bank?
Otherwise, let me inform you. We also FINALY get a large monument to the great Christian ruler Nemanja, with which Vucic will certanly buy a time from right-wing monarchists for a while. Again. Please remind me, when did Russians get Vladimir’s monument in the center of Moscow? What a good managers of mass psychology, huh?
I think that your criticism comes from love and so I understand it.
That is best addressed to the Russians but I agree that the response to Skripal, plane crash, Navalny etc. has been weak and inviting further humiliations. Actually I am preparing a piece on whether a different strategy is possible. Then again, what’s possible is possible. If they are doing it this way it is they can’t do anything else.
Ruling a huge and highly complex country is difficult and calls for many compromises.
Second, Russia is weaker now than it was and cannot afford open confrontation – full stop (it couldn’t as a Soviet Union either).
This doesn’t mean that it’s helpless.
I am all for the Stalin’s method of dealing with oligarchs but apparently that’s not possible.
The cult of personality is not good for any country. Putin is not Russia. Russia has many smart, wise people. Bigger patriots. I put the question whether the Russian services and the army respect the Constitution of Russia and whether they serve the people of Russia? I post the same question to serbian servicemen on Serbian networks.
About two weeks ago, I read an article about corruption at the Vostochny cosmodrome, where billions of dollars have already been thrown away and they are still planning to build it for another ten years. In the fifties of the last century, a couple of engineers arrived with the first railway sleepers in that part of the Kazakh desert and in six years sent a man into space.
That is why writing some hymns about the leadership without critical thinking is not good. It is a consequence of an old habit from the time of the empire and later communism. The Russians and Serbs must get rid of that. Presidents and prime ministers are there to SERVE THE PEOPLE. So do all the services in the state because the people pay them. Very simple. They should never be a ikebanas of corporations. Otherwise it is a fasist totalitarian system we are talking about. The combination of state services, crime and big capital.
Yes, Djole,
But unlike the West, Russia and Serbia are under a constant threat of attack – plus sanctions etc. Under such circumstances no country would function optimally. Imagine all the flavours of fascism the West would produce!
And yes I agree with you but that kind of “democracy” is a luxury. Serbia could afford it for a few years while supported by Russia, Britain and France. Most of the time it is a bloody struggle for power.
The best thing for you is to write about genocide to get a unique name for genocide over Slavs and Serbs. To get the western world acquainted with it. Some pan-Slavic unions are an impossible mission. By rejecting Kievan Rus’, Katarina gives you an example of how some people think about their own history, people and country, and not about someone else’s. Thank you.
All the best
To djole
You are mistaken – I have never ever rejected the Kievan Rus – it is the CRADLE of RUSSIA, has always been and will always remain. Now, unfortunately it is occupied by the “parasitic invader” and it’s up to people there, living with it, to find their true slavic roots.. and salvation. And to find these they most..
To Katerina (I did not find a reply below your answer)
The entire script from Serbia is copied to Russia or vice versa. This is impossible without the coordination of the foreign factor and services inside Russia and Serbia. I’ve already written about it, talk to Saker if he doesn’t think I’m some kind of lunatic or if he himself is not blackmailed by the services. Even the leaders of the battalion from Donbas were removed according to the same scenario when they wanted to settle the matter with the Ukros. The same was in Krajina. The Serbian services, in cooperation with their colleagues from the Croatian services, removed the battalion leaders I suspect. The interests of the international community are ahead of the nation and the state, unlike in our former brothers, where the imaginary national is emphasized in order to weak us. Individuals are paid for a making our people ignorant sleepers, by stealing from the state weakening the nation. See how many criminals were convicted with name and surname and for what imprisoned time in Serbia or Russia and you will see as a layman that something is wrong. From a judical perspective very small number for all malversations of 30 years period. To me, as someone who looks at it from the side, it seems as if every time our leaders do stupid things to the detriment of the nation, the services stage reason why coconuts gather around a rooster defending its inviolability. They turn people into fans, and statesmen into team leaders that you have to support even when they lose. And they lose because of a bad tactic or strategy set out by leader aka couch. But since he is a project of interest groups, he is not changed, but rather they explain how bad the team is or the field conditions, or the ball, etc, etc.
I agreed the BLM/Antifa fake protests only benefit Trump and no one else. And the Dems are pushing for Trump’s 2nd term by nominating a cadaver. Everything is a very carefully choreographed theater. So I am expecting landslide for Trump in November.
Splendid rant! And right on target. Thank you, Katerina.
East has ancient philosophy regarding political activity far superior to ordinary political activity of any sort, no matter how well intentioned such ordinary political activity may be, capitalism, socialism. How is said when someone asks how he can help others: “Whatever you will the other will too, act accordingly”.
Dear Katerina, thank you again for your essay. It’s another great essay. The one thing is nobody should doubt WP/Xi’s chess playing capabilities. but the big setback is that they just keep on playing by the rules for too long, while knowing their mischievous opponent breaks all the rules and gets away with it. I personally think that it is long overdue for Russia, China and Iran to play the vital endgame move – now that they still have a chance to make that move – namely controlling and securing the energy flow from the Persian Gulf from Strait of Hormuz – Bab el Mandeb, with payments directly in non-US currency through their respective financial networks bypassing the western Swift system and insurance agencies.
In this way, the consumers in advanced Western European communities would enjoy a steady and sure supply of oil and gas from Russia and the Middle east, so that they could continue their own version of happiness, however they define it.
To Maskazer
You are right on some things, on others, that are also very important, not so much. Strait of Hormuz is quite obviously a choke point but Iran would only resort to that as the last option! Iran would use that when everything else is exhausted. Israel is the main enemy and as such it is absolutely TARGETED!
So, what you are saying is that Russia, together with it’s allies, should play the “endgame” now? Please get your thinking cap on! Israel in it’s present governing is absolutely corrupt and totally dependant on their “sponsor”. Just think what would happen if that sponsor is gone!! Please use your “God given brains” to actually UNDERSTAND what if happenning here. Thank you.
Concerning chess players:
Putin is a good chess strategist, for shure, But I’d like to add a few points about the Chinese,
In China, there are three games called chess (qí, pronounced /tsji/ in Mandarin, /kì/ in Cantonese, /gei/ in Shânghâi — and /go/ in Japanese:
1: Wêiqí, known as “go” in English. Consist of each party putting down their stones in turn, The object is to surround the opponent so as to control and conquer land (area). The one who ends up with most or all territory has won. May be played by two or several players. The first leader of the national Wêiqí assosciation in The People’s Republic of China Was grand marshal Zhū Dé’ (Chu Teh), who had been a warlored in SW Chine before kicking his opium addiction, travelled to France and Germany Europe to study and joined the CCP while returning to China via the Trans Siberian Railroad. During the height of The Great Proletarian Cultrural Revolution he retreated temporarily to cultivate miniature orchedies i THe Summer Palace — but having two stone chessboards in his flower nursery.
2: Chinese Chess (guó-qí/xiàng-qí): Two prince-lings struggle to control all of the territory and mount the imperial throne. — or kill/control the opponent. This would be a Zhōu Ènlái type of game, meseems. Here the pieces are differentiated in a fashion akin to International/Western chess.
3: International Chess (guó’jì-qí): I cannot remember any national politician in China being associated with this game — maybe following Putin’s ascent?
The rules of strife change when you enter enemy territory by crossing
,
Dèng Xiâopíng was a ,aster bridge player.
.
What is called “Chinese Chess” and “Checkers” in English has never been observed being playd in China — except possibly figuratively by political leaders from the North Atlantic Ulema amongst themselves.
I’m from Czechoslovakia and I have to agree with this article absolutely.
But who will succeed Putin to carry out his legacy? It would be a real pity if the next President undid his work. In Oliver Stone’s excellent interview Putin revealed himself to be a micromanager, this would tend to suppress the visibility of talent in the central province around Moscow. I know that Russia is very large and that there may be examples of good leadership in other provinces but I don’t know if they could get support nationally in elections. I don’t know if province is the correct word.
While people were frustrated by Putin’s passivity, Putin looked to be frustrated by Medvedev. Just giving Medvedev as an example of how legacies can start to unravel.
On the bright side, Putin’s patience and passivity with the west allowed Russian voters to get a good long look at western bad faith. I do not believe they will be voting for Atlantacists any time soon. They got the “Clockwork Orange” therapy on that.
“But who will succeed Putin to carry out his legacy? ”
Some are prone to frame hypotheses from holograms of their own expectation.
The Russian Federation has and has always had, collective co-ordination/participation not restricted to “leadership” which you apparently interpret as ” Putin revealed himself to be a micromanager..”
Thank you for your illustration of the Cassandra gambit where the “truth” is told but few believe it, prefering to engage in dances/trances around fixed points intoning mantras.
“In Oliver Stone’s excellent interview Putin revealed himself to be a micromanager,”
I could not disagree more. IN answer to the matter of security, Putin said that Castro told him “the only reason I am still alive, is that I do my security myself”. Putin then said “I do my job, and the security service do theirs”.
A micro-manage would insist he had control.
A secretary of V.V. from his days a deputy major in St. Petersberg said “he didn’t care how you did your job, or what problems, you had — it just had to get it done, that’s all”.
Neither of those demonstrate a “micro-manager”. Moreover, how on earth could a micro-manager manager all of the vast and complex issues in a country like Russia?. It’s rather ludicrous to even suggest it.
In fact, I’ve long said the opposite – that one of the secrets of Putin’s success is that he is NOT a “micro-manager”. He is the hub of a gigantic wheel. He is aware from the centre of what is happening. But the details to make it happen it leaves to the appointment ones, to either do it, or get fired!!!
“He is the hub of a gigantic wheel.”
Mr. Putin was elected using a “constitution” generously donated by others in emulation of their perception of themselves, and hence your metaphor was to some degree encouraged through apparent participation (playing chessness, a.k.a as enmazed in the paradigm), and hence the half-life of your metaphor is understandable.
However when the generously donated by others constitution had served its purposes, a lateral process of metamorphosis transcending the “old constitution” by a new constitution more closely akin to previous and on-going practice was further catalysed, since time is laterally dynamic and nothing ever is, but only becoming.
Perhaps a more “representative” description would read “The Russian Federation has and has always had, collective co-ordination/participation not restricted to “leadership” given that some who help facilitate The Russian Federation were not restricted by/to emulated practices as default.
Some perceive cups as half-empty, and some perceive cups as half-full, whilst some don’t perceive cups.
Some experienced/perceived the 1990’s in Russia as “tragic”, and others perceived the 1990’s in Russia as understandable adverse consequences to be minimised but not capable of total avoidance, of the implosion of the Soviet Union and the attempts at mischief of others, perceived by a growing sum of some from the 1970’s onwards, including some opportunities of transcendence thereby facilitated, by not playing chess whilst appearing to be playing chess..
There are those of us whose ancestors came from Galicia and fully believe that we are part of the Russian nation.
The Poles are interlopers and Ukrainianism is a fable constructed for the sole purpose of tearing the Russian people apart.
Other than that, couldn’t agree more.
Bravo, Johann,
It was about time someone punctured the false narrative.
With contributors like you, we can be hopeful of a better tomorrow.
I think Johann that there are others who might feel like you but have been
scared witless by the Catholic oppression and propaganda.
You are the first but hopefully not the last voice of Galicia to be heard here!
Ken, if you have an opportunity to find a copy of the book, “A Short History of Carpatho-Russia” by Simeon Pysh, and translated into English by my great-uncle, Andrew Yurkovsky back in the 1970s, it will reveal a long-standing sentiment that has existed amongst our people for centuries but only forgotten or ignored in more recent times.
Our memory is long and at least some of us remember what our grandparents taught us.
I should also point out as something of a tangent that there was a time when Ruthenian Uniatism was a sort of crypto-Orthodoxy. It was either that, convert to the Latin Rite, or face martyrdom (which despite being the high road is not what all are called to, especially if families and children are involved). In some ways it was a precursor to the Sergianism our Russian Church is accused of succumbing to during the Soviet era. Historically, despite its use as a tool of deception and coercion by Polish and Austrian Roman Catholics, it did serve a purpose in preserving the memory of Orthodoxy amongst our people.
Thank you Katerina for this wrap-up. For the life of me, I don’t understand why an informed person from eastern European or Slavic countries would want to be anywhere near the west. Arm twisting, threats and bribes I suspect. The western powers are very cunning and will plant poison into the very midst of the people to catch the unwary.
Nobody has to say you are a Putin fan. I’m a Putin fan! I don’t know of another leader on this planet to match him. He is an honorable man, very well educated in history. There is no comparison between him and the tweeter in chief of the U.S., nor for that matter anyone else who might want to sit in the pretty white house. Now is the big debate as to whether Americans should vote for Trump just to slow down the collapse. This is a man who, if he has any control at all, appears more like a Mafia Don sitting behind the big desk. He hasn’t said ‘you’re fired’ nearly enough. But he has no problem ordering the murder of foreign generals on a diplomatic mission. The latest is that he wanted President Assad murdered also but General Mattis did not approve. If anything, Trump is now just a common killer and knows little else. And people are supposed to vote for this!
The intent of the empire has long been to subjugate the entire world. They are still trying hard in Belarus. I trust the leadership there with Russia’s help is all over this event. As I have long expected, this subjugation is now turning against it’s own people. I believe this is one of the reasons for the scamdemic. They are determined to have their citizens isolated, broke, dependent, submissive and tracked and traced. All this while the financial stability of the U.S. and other 5 eyes countries in particular are rapidly going into the toilet.
“Presidents that play chess”
Some are of the view that chess or game theory are indicators of “intellectual and/or strategic sophistication” – a hypothesis undermined by Mr. Kasparov’s attempts in matters strategic outside chess during the 1990’s – ,
whilst some are of the view that game playing is primarily a recreational activity, thereby facilitating transcendence of those enmazed in the view that “chess or game theory are indicators of “intellectual and/or strategic sophistication”.
“In addition, he is also of course a judo master and for these who are not familiar with this particular form of martial art, the objective is to defeat your opponent by using THEIR OWN bulk and strength against them to get them off balance and then throw them on the floor.”
Aikido – (overcome/transcend (not defeat since this is disrespectful to opponents and not sustainable)) your opponent by using THEIR OWN bulk and strength against them to get them off balance (continual change not balance/stasis is held to be a constant, hence encouraged trajectories of change are held to be the purpose) is not restricted to judo, but is a component part of many “martial arts” including wu shu, as acknowleged by Tsun Tsu and various tsensais.
Many “martial arts” are not games to play, but cultures to practice.
Enmazement in cultures of games to play precludes opportunities of some cultures to practice, including respect for opponents.
“Sometimes I feel really sorry for both Putin and Lavrov as to what kind of people they have to deal with.”
Evaluation is a function of purpose, and as functions of facility, not all share or perceive the same purpose including but not restricted to – have-to-deal-withness.
To paraphrase a slightly segued Yiddish/Japanese saying “May you be blessed with intelligent friends and self-absorbed opponents” with a question posed by some after the Tet offensive in 1968/69 when Mr. Giap was directed by “politicians” – “how to drown a drowning man with the minimum of blowback” – since such facilitates aikido in minimising blowback.
An added component in facilitation is “..does not respond to western provocations the way some people would like him to and it seems to bother them, especially those who see the perceived lack of response on his part as an indication of some weakness and indecisiveness..” – the attempts of opponents at “strategies of tension” often being undermined by their enmazements in the can do/must do conflation, and in time-and-tide-wait-for-no-manness.
“By the way, these politicians in Germany that are actually promoting this, do they comprehend as to how utterly stupid they come across with this idiotic accusation? Feel like saying to them – for crying out loud, give it a rest!”
Be sure they won’t, Katerina, not with Merkel at the helm or any of these plonkers of the transatlanticist crowd in Berlin for that matter. Merkel’s working very hard on bringing to life the United States of Europe as planned a hundred years ago by this guy Richard Coudenhove-Kalergi. At the same time, her stringpullers are trying very hard to break up Russia. They don’t mind being pathetic by acting out the script of the Eau de Porton Down farce of 2018 they borrowed from the Brits.
Dear Birgit,
Sorry to interrupt. Coudenhove-Kalergi’s vision of a united Europe was rejected by the CIA (its principal sponsor).What they preferred was a right-wing Catholic Russophobic vision (note that RCK was not a Russophobe) of Otto von Habsburg, Franz Josef Strauss, Hans Huyn, Klaus Kinkel, Helmut Kohl and other German “patriots” (and French fascists – Alexandre de Marenches and Attila the Hun Tories – George Kennedy Young etc.). This is an important point that I shall be shedding light on soon.
Thank you
Interesting times….Lavrov has to remind-!- Maas of a joint Convention to respond to Ruusian requests re what is required from Germany re Navalny…that claims by Germany that other government depts are not subservient to this Convention are obstruction….but both Ministers agree to continue their dialogue…..uhuh.
Meanwhile….The Ukraine once again dodges by withdrawal its July 22 agreement with Donbass re special measures for deconfliction over its continuing shelling and extension of military engineering works.So back to “normal” …. Donbass may have the right to actually now go in and destroy such works….interesting times.Uhuh. Action….after all the words are again exhausted.
True, Stalin died in 1953. The wall was built 1961. I only explained preventing people from coming in. And in 1961 USA and SSSR were not on friendliest terms… so somebody figured out it would be better to secure open border.
Western Berlin was built up later, in order to show how life is better in the west than in the east. In 1961 Eastern Berlin and whole DDR were not as posh as USA. But we should not forget that about that time, UK was suffering food shortages, coupons for food were in place. At least food was secure in eastern block, and some less important things – jobs, health care, education…. Just saying. However, Western Berlin had Coca Cola and one could buy blue jeans at any time. Traveling, of course. Westerners could travel anywhere, lots of them in my Yugoslavia. But I noticed also Poles, Czecs, Hungarians, even East Germans. And they were allowed to travel all over eastern block. Which includes beaches on Romanian and Bulgarian part of Black Sea, Crimea, Sochi. No need for travel health insurance. It was all included.
True, some people were shot in attempts to escape. It is normal that at least some will consider living under Russian ‘occupation’ unacceptable. After all, they were Germans, many had relatives killed in WWII, by the very Russians. Then they escaped to be occupied by Americans, to this day. It is also normal for Russians to be paranoid about spies and not trust anybody. After all, western berlin was an enclave faraway from USA zone in Western Germany, established exactly for purpose of – spying. Then in 1991 Russians left. Americans are still there. But hey, Coca Cola and jeans, that is life my friends. All shinny and glittery.
As for traveling through Yugoslavia and Greece 60 years ago, well, one can always see what they want and interpret it based on their experience and education. Greece was NATO, never part of Eastern block. One can tell that life in the west was not universally “better”. Depends on values important to people.
”Did you know that one of their main objectives in meddling in Ukraine was to remove the Russian Naval Base from Crimea and replace it with their own?”
Hell, yes — that’s a no-brainer. They had set their greedy eyes on Crimea in general and Sevastopol in particular and were counting on their Ukronazi polecats to carry out anti-Russian genocide; the template being the Anglos’ heinous crime in Diego Garcia (1967) to build the military base there.
Shame on Putin for his bloody ’annexation’ of Crimea /sarc off/.
Regarding the West’s wishful thinking about Crimea:
”They actually thought that they could pull that off!! Beyond belief.”
Actually, were it not for Putin and Shoigu, the scum maybe would have tried in earnest to grab Crimea (conspiring with the Russian liberals). If so, the bloodshed would have been staggering given the fighting spirit of the Crimean people. Even without the Russian government’s firm commitment to the cause, NATO could very well have been routed by determined anti-fascist forces. But with the Russian government taking action, the offal hadn’t the slightest chance of succeeding.
To Nussiminen
The imbecils would not have had any chance to even get close to Crimea! They would have been feeding the fishes at the bottom of Black Sea..
**
Chess has its rules. And if it is played, both sides must follow the rules. I don’t see that being the case here. Trump plays chess. He has already “removed” a couple of “figures” from the game with his drones and ambushes in Syria and Iraq. I think it is unfair to compare this geopolitical competition of the Russian Federation and the rest of the “free world” (snark!) With chess. From WWII until today, Russia has been alone against all other “free” but not with its own wish and now the same “free world” is trying to maintain the same status for Russia. No one can be against the whole world. Absolutely no one. Not even the USA. I believe that VVP is a Christian and that it certainly influences his reflections. I also believe that he is not stupid since he shows great knowledge. The problem is another. And that in American behavior. Trump’s peace efforts, to call them that, I know it sounds ridiculous, are aimed at denying future alliances of Middle East countries and securing free air corridors for Israeli aviation and attacking Iran, or perhaps just denying any strategic advantage Iran has now that it is partly in Syria. I believe that the Russians understand this and are counting on creating a new strategic balance and new conditions for peace. Personally, I think that’s nonsense after all. Trump is violent and dangerous. And it will probably be for the next 4 years. Second, the greatest risk to Russia and world peace; NATO and American aviation, if they want to attack, do not have to enter the airspace of the Russian Federation. So, any approach of NATO and American aviation to the airspace of the Russian Federation is gambling. Hence the real danger. I can only conclude that Putin is not playing chess. He is a very good and successful gambler. All U.S. military action, since the assassination of Soleimani and long before that, the shooting on the streets of Iraq of anything suspiciously moving, now in Syrian settlements on east part o country, is based on perceived (!) danger. The Russians don’t do that. They only shoot when their general dies …
And other countries that play civilization and that everyone should count on as important factors in maintaining peace are actually tribal-oriented societies with understandable corruption, can never become stable states and will always be subject to blackmail and will always be tempted to betray principles. and alliances. That is why I think that pampering various states and lamenting their historical destiny is wrong. That is why in such societies, the imposition of wise and noble leaders has a limited period of use. The wise are in the minority, and most are a well-fed and well-dressed crowd who, on a beautiful sunny day, make a mess in the cities and carry out all sorts of revolutions instead of going on a picnic with their children and grandchildren. And now someone should be counting on them as allies. The Russians are polite and always say that only their interests are important to them. Because other things like devotion, brotherhood and alliance as a solid template on which to build a long and prosperous future generally do not exist, but it is ugly to say it out loud.
Hello Katerina.
Thank you for this fine piece. Many of us here have been trying to explain VVP’s apparent ‘inaction’ in the face of the Empire’s provocations for years but you put it best in this piece. VVP is obviously in a class of his own as the leader of a great power. I’m so happy the Russians voted to let him carry on beyond his current term. He’s put an end to so much bloodletting, in Chechnya, Ossetia, Novorussia, Syria, perhaps prevented one in Venezuela and South Asia. He doesn’t react impetuously; instead he acts calculatingly to events. He’s informed by history and culture — I once watched a Vesti video where he chided a minister for blithely suggesting that RF export tinned pork to Indonesia, a predominantly Muslim country. And speaking of Indonesia, RF is slowly but surely expanding its relations not only with its traditional partners, Vietnam and Indonesia, but the wider Asia-Pacific region (AP to ROW, ‘Indo-Pacific’ to the Empire and India). RF have also managed to prise that US outpost in Southeast Asia, the Philippines, from the USAian teat. In contrast, his partners in the Empire are still learning how to differentiate Australia from Austria. ‘Nuff said.
Your mention of your Scottish (and obviously astute — both in love and war — it seems to me) husband as well as the imbeciles/exceptionals currently running the US remind me of a Robert Burns poem, one about a louse. The parasite had lodged itself onto the hair of a fashionable lady during church service, who, completely unaware of the matter, became the subject of much winking and finger-pointing amongst the congregation. Piety without self-awareness — apt description of the imbeciles.
“O wad some Pow’r the giftie gie us
To see oursels as others see us!
It wad frae monie a blunder free us
An’ foolish notion:
What airs in dress an’ gait wad lea’e us,
An’ ev’n Devotion! “
To Stand Easy
Bravo!! That’s all I can say. And Thank You! : )
Russland und China im Verbund sind militärisch den JewSA weit überlegen. Wirtschaftlich ebenso. Einziges Problem ist in Russland der Neoliberalismus.
Google translation,MOD:
Russia and China together are militarily superior to the JewSA. Economically as well. The only problem in Russia is neoliberalism.
“The only problem in Russia is neoliberalism.”
Evaluation is a function of purpose, and hence if you don’t know the purpose of those whose practices you seek to evaluate, you can’t evaluate, but you do have the choice to bridge doubt by belief to attain comfort/certainty as apparently some have resorted ( a process of visiting a resort – sometimes known as going on holiday).
Dear Katerina,
A very timely article, thank you. I would like to take your chess metaphor or analogy as a springboard, but that would take too long. So, to the reason why your article is timely.
Just a couple of days ago, the german-foreign-policy group published an analysis of EU (which means German, as the dominant factor) schemes for eastern European countries. https://www.german-foreign-policy.com/news/detail/8379/ Auf dem Weg in die “De-Dollarisierung” — Die deutsche Debatte über einen möglichen Aufstieg des Euro zur Weltleitwährung dauert an. On the way to dedollarization, the German debate ab out a potential elevation of the Euro to the rank for a world reserve currency continues.
A lot of people will naively tend to jump on this with a reaction such as, “Hey, great idea. Dump the dollar, dump the US empire”. The article, however, draws on the former German EU Commissioner Oettinger, who says Europe can shoot for world-currency-reserve status *on condition* that “EU expansion” is forced ahead: that means new EU members such as Croatia and Bulgaria should be tied into the Euro system, i.e., accept the Euro as their own currency within two years, and recalcitrant countries such as Poland, the Czech Republic, Hungry and Romania should also accept the Euro as their currency because “they would profit from the dynamic of the common currency area.”
The so-called “dynamic” does not look good, Germany exploits cheap labor and exports to east European countries, building up their debt. The article claims that these countries have so far refused to convert to the Euro because of the experience of the “great Euro crisis”. That is nonsense: these countries have had some decent economists who know that converting to the Euro means allowing asset-stripping and the impoverishment of national economies more than is already the case.
Nevertheless, Oettinger is cited speculating about the advantages of a world-reserve role for the Euro: The USA was able to run up a national debt of over 27 trillion dollars and print its own fiat money without limit because other countries invested in dollar reserves. “This option would be of essential interest for the Federal Republic of Germany”, Oettinger says. Please note, “for Germany,” not for EU countries. Basically, as globalism collapses or disappears, the Germans want to save it and profit. The gfp article fails to mention that the US policy depended on the IMF and World Bank for external looting schemes. Given the developing world’s experience with this “Washington consensus” system, any country would be crazy to adopt a “Berlin-Brussels consensus”- replacement.
We can therefore expect an immense pressure campaign from Germany against the recalcitrant countries… at a time when the EU-System lost Belarus as a source of loot and Ukraine is an unmitigated mess. The feasibility of a Berlin-Brussels consensus system is in any case meager.
Trump knows the EU-German policy and he is against it, which is one reason I have problems understanding why people are against Trump, but I am not in the business of trying to persuade anyone. Trump says EU trade policy is “worse than China”.
Thanks, Katerina, for a well-considered and heart-felt article. Reading you is like meeting a kindred spirit in a cafe. Looking forward to more from you.
I like your words “controlled demolition”, evoking the picture of an old, decrepit, obsolete skyscraper collapsing into its own footprint under expert control so that it does not damage its neighbours. However, the US collapse that we are privileged to watch today is more “uncontrolled (uncontrollable?)” than controlled, and so collateral damage can befall neighbours. Thusly, I agree that great caution needs to be exercised by neighbours Russia and China, firstly, not to obstruct the ongoing harakiri, and secondly, to avoid the emissions of toxic bodily fluids spewed about.
I too have noticed that Lavrov has lately been more pointed, direct and blunt. When the world’s best foreign minister talks at you like that, the end of the diplomatic road is at hand. I guess that is why Putin, the world’s best national leader today, warned recently that he will make it unfeasible for any nation to war on Russia.
Russia is blessed to have leadership of such high calibre.
to kiwiklown
You have given me an absolute and undeniable belief in a smart, intelligent kiwis! I always knew there are some exceptional ones and you are proving me right!
Russian intelligence is also unsurpassed because for hundreds of years they have been the target of the masters of conspiracy and grudge.
From Zerohedge:
So this is what Putinist regime “restraint” has achieved: a NATO threat at Russia’s underbelly, aimed at, among other things, compelling Russia to bare its air defence electronic abilities to NATO. Congratulations, Putin.
So this is what Putinist regime “restraint” has achieved: a NATO threat at Russia’s underbelly, aimed at, among other things, compelling Russia to bare its air defence electronic abilities to NATO. Congratulations, Putin.
Well, that’s one way to see it Biswa — a show of force and a probing sortie to intimidate the adversary and unearth his defences. Nato gains the initiative and Russia, once again, is on the back foot. Another great victory for the Empire.
But the Russians are not exactly novices at this kind of game. I’m willing to bet RF have been tracking those B-52s — they are after all, “strategic” assets much like nuclear submarines — the moment they left the hangar at their home base, and are pretty sure of their payload (if any) when they left the UK for the Ukraine.
You know, sometimes we have to dig a bitter deeper to understand this game of ‘chicken.’ Things are not always what they seem and, more importantly, what really counts is what the Russian generals and political leadership think, not what we think. The main reason being, we don’t have the info they have. And their response to that info sometimes betrays a penchant for lateral thinking — several years ago, when asked a question about what RF was going to do about the new and much vaunted F-35 should things got real, an RF air force general — I think it was — suggested that they kill all the F-35 pilots; they take years to train and there’re not many of them. At that time, he noted, that there were less than a hundred of them in the whole of UK and Nato (Su -57 was yet to make an appearance over a war zone, so he could’ve changed his mind now that it or its technology is tested and available). But see how he thinks.
And here’s the bigger question regarding your comment: Is the premise that a “tougher” response from Russia would deter Nato correct? I think not. There are enough loonies in Nato, starting with the effete but aggressive secretary general, who want to start a war with RF. They operate on the principle that a fire has to be extinguished before it gets too big to handle and there’s only a small window of opportunity to do so — good for firefighters but bad for generals with nuclear weapons. They desperately need a casus belli and will act according to their plan to find one. A “tougher” response can be turned into an excuse for war quite easily. A “restrained” response denies them that opportunity. It’s like a knife fight with a drunk. He’s loud, kicks chairs, smashes things and calls your mother names. You remain calm and just circle him until he either passes out or makes a dangerous lunge in which case you, to borrow a famous Prussian’s phrase, “throw him”. Once and for all.
Cheers.
That Sneaky Putin
While the western world(read fascist) was going ape over novichok-you know the Russian bio-weapon that is the most dangerous chemical known to man except it fails to kill anyone-Putin had developed and infected the entire political and mass media leaders of the west with a new bio-weapon that he created himself. It’s called Notajoke and it makes those infected become babbling idiots and anyone can see that it has worked. Trump got his dose from some Las Vegas hookers who the FSB infected and they in turn pissed on him. Even worse, it eventually gives every infected person a Hitler mustache that cannot be gotten rid of. These babbling idiots are aware something is wrong but they are not sure of whats happening and they have developed a strategum. They are going to emulate certain successful comics from the past and make their adversaries die laughing. Trump becomes Moe, Boris becomes Larry and Angela becomes Curly-wise guy eh? They plan to resort to slapstick, where upon they slap you with sanctions and then stick it to you, bomb your country and everyone is in stitches(in the hospital) “Yeah that’ what we’ll do eh Moe?”. As part of the plan the G7 mental 7 dwarfs are on board with Moe(Trump-coc) as their leader followed by Larry(Boris-sleezy) and Curly(Angela-frumpy) with those idiots True-dough(dopey) Canada, Cunte(bashful) Italy, Macaroon(creepy) France and the Jap chap Ape Abe(jappy). What a team folks- I may die of laughter before I’m finished this tirade. Their latest brilliant stroke is to put an end to Nordstream 2 so that their citizens can pay double thereby aiding Moe and getting rid of their excess money. The Baltic states are on board as well. They are afraid that Russia will steal their technology- ooops they don’t have any, their natural resources- ooops ditto, their dirt-ya that’s it, their dirt. Poland is worried about the theft of their telecommunications technology developed by Alexander Graham Kowalski better known as “The Telephone Pole”. Ukraine got on board and has now elevated itself to the poorest country in Europe. Moe thought Putin may be behind all this so he offered a challenge. Putin responded with chess?, judo?, hockey?, Moe had in mind a pie throwing contest. “wise guy eh?”
Pompeo and Abrahms not to be outdone have become Ollie and Stan as Ollie admonishes Stan-”this is another fine mess you’ve gotten me into” over Venezuela and proceed to bump into one another. To add a little “stiff” competition in comes Joe “the stiff” Biden to out stupid them all.
To gary jackson
That made my day! This is EXACTLY what the world needs right now – a biting, wicked, merciless sitire that clearly shows to the world as to what these creatures are.. We desperately need another George Carlin!!
gary jackson
Typing error – the word is of course -satire, I was still laughing as I was typing : )
So…..how can Russia deal with such absolute twerps as Ursula von der Leyen
.some kind of leader in the Eu ….saying today that Russia meddled in Georgia…Ukraine…Syria and elections all around the world? Let her pass by….personally reply to her and all similar with truthful rebuttals…..impose sanctions and any other action on such similar peoples? We hear plees from Russia for EU to not politicise issues….not to interfere eg in Belarus…..but nothing much else from Russia recently….so when additional sanctions are applied perhaps….what are the ones that Russia has left to counter with reciprocally….cut the gas? Was it really worth back paying dues of millions to PACE to get some kind of Russian presence there….it seems so pointless.
To JJ
Russia will just ignore those. As for Belarus, the West has already been warned not to pursue anything, otherwise it will come back at them big time.. And if they persist in that interferance, they will learn a very harsh lesson..
VVP has one inestimable advantage not granted to most Western politicians: longevity of tenure.
The only Western figurehead with comparable experience to the Russian President is the UK Sovereign. She has been dealing with global leaders for nearly 60 years. Merkel comes close but is starting to show signs of susceptibility to challenge. Nowhere else can compete with Putin’s experience through time in office.
Putin’s second great advantage is that he really owes his power to kicking the oligarchs into touch and putting the Russian people at least second in line rather than at the back of the queue. That makes him a very rare leader indeed in Western terms, since I cannot remember the last time we had one of those in the UK, let alone a US President that gave a monkeys about the bottom 40% of Americans.
The third advantage Putin has is that his most effective international gambits will involve being nice to those angered at US bullying. When people are immensely grateful to you being nice to them, it makes being nice to them much easier. Putin has enough adversaries in Russia he has to be nasty to without being an international b***ard too. At least he will feel he does not have to be a metaphorical tyrant all the time….and he has built quite an international following of allied friends the past 20 years.
It does have to be said, however, that much of the best leadership to be found at a nation state level tends to occur when that nation feels threatened and has to defend itself. A common sense of pulling together to survive emerges and that makes governing much simpler. When in the west you get to a position of competing stands of greed pulling in different directions, appealing to higher values becomes a vote loser. Putin as yet has not had to face that dilemma quite as overtly as Western politicians…and so far as I am aware, he also does not have media stations, newspapers and radios constantly fomenting foreign conquest and wars to satiate the needs of arms suppliers, the egos of military generals and the perverted psychologies of security services stooges.
Even with all those favourable winds in his favour, Putin could still have completely screwed up. He seems to have avoided the dipsomania of Yeltsin, the megalomania of Thatcher and sexual degeneracy of Berlusconi.
And for whatever reason, he seems to have set Russia up using the concepts of sound money backed by large reserves of gold.
It must be really galling for all the scribblers in the West trying to make out that Putin has stolen all of Russia’s reserves to have to face up to the fact that taxes in Russia are lower than in the West; Sovereign Wealth Funds put the UK to shame; gold reserves put Gordon Brown to shame; and purchasing power of Russian Citizens in 2020 is vastly higher than in 2000 when he took office.
Perhaps if those scribblers actually went and lived in Russia for 10 years and talked to thousands of real Russians, they might get a greater insight into what the true downsides to Russian life are, rather than being prostitutes serving unaccountable Western masters scribbling nonsensical drivel year after year?
To Rhys Jagger
I was going to say that you are so wrong on so many levels until I read your very last sentence. But please do not attempt to compare Russian President to anyone else, he is in the class of his own.
“…he is in the class of his own.”
A more representative rendition may read he is equal and different as are all in collectives, and this facilitates co-operation.
The constitution that was donated by others tried to minimise/preclude co-operation by a “Presidential model” where “self-interest is held to balance self-interests, and this is a component of why the old constitution is in process of being transcended and why the new constitution was subject to vote, instead of being subject to the assertion that “We the people hold these truths to be self-evident…”
“This rather useless idiot, Navalny”
The existence of phenomena is not dependent on their perception by others.
Hence the useful foolery of Mr. Navalny and others are facilitated, but rarely by those immersed in “emotional responses”, reliance on intuition, or resort to other forms of attempting to bridge doubt by belief.
By now, almost everyone has heard of Vladimir Putin and the responsible way he directed Russia to operate in the world. He has shown to the average person Russia is a responsible and trustworthy country that cannot be blackmailed. One can hope there are others like him in Russia.