by Dmitry Steshin (Komsomolskaya Pravda)
Translated from Russian by Gleb Bazov
I understand and share in the bitterness and resentment of those who found out this morning that the Militia has left Slavyansk. The news washed over everyone – the hoorah-patriots, the all-is-lost-patriots and even the cold analytical types. And now, please listen to a person who spent the last month and a half in Slavyansk. From the time of the very first checkpoints on the outskirts and to the almost complete encirclement of the city. When we broke out of Slavyansk along the by-pass “guerilla” road in the middle of June, a few hours later a Ukrainian army checkpoint appears there. That’s it; the city was blockaded on all sides. Supplying the garrison turned into a constant headache incommensurate with its tactical advantage. And, despite all the despair coming through in the public statements made by Igor Ivanovich, when he told the entire world that “we could not hold any longer than July 12th,” I am more than certain that, if NazGuard [Note: National Guard] did manage, on New Year’s eve, finally to enter Slavyansk, leveled to a cement pancake, from every other basement there would have been automatic rifles and grenade launchers hitting the Ukrainian troops.
In reality, the fate of Slavyansk was being decided in April-May, when Karachun Mount was taken. It is impossible to conduct a fulsome and active defence when you are faced with a strategic dominant height overhanging the city, several kilometres in length, seized by the adversary and laden with enemy artillery. And to fight, moreover, without any means of counter-battery warfare. Impossible, and, yet, Igor Ivanovich and the Militia managed to resist anyways. And not only to resist, but, in a mere few days, to disabuse the many-times superior enemy of any desire to engage the Militia in a direct confrontation. As far as I can tell, they abandoned any intention to assault the city as soon as the Militia returned Semyonovka under its control.
Undoubtedly, Slavyansk became the symbol of the “Russian Spring,” moreover – it entered history. Forever. But the purpose of the city was different. Slavyansk attracted to itself all the battle-worthy forces of the Ukrainian army, it enabled the mobilization of the Militia in Lugansk and Donetsk. Slavyansk gave Mozgovoi an opportunity to crack the border on land and in the air. Whereby something real (you do not need to tell me about virtual YouTube armoured columns) actually made it into the region, by dribs and drabs, including “Tunguskas” purchased at the GUM [Note: GUM, or “State Universal Market,” in Moscow]. Slavyansk enabled the rest of the region to set up almost a dozen reinforced centres of resistance. Finally, it was Slavyansk that brought down the majority of Ukrainian fliers. And the “Slavic Sky” came true in every regard. Finally, Slavyansk gave the South-East time to create political centres of power, allowed to legitimize them, and, of course, provided covering fire for the referendum. And, one last thing, – thousands of untried militiamen and volunteers passed through the trenches of Slavyansk, all with minimal losses.
By the middle of June, Slavyansk outlived itself. Having drawn and bound to itself an enormous army grouping, the city, at the same time, required an ever-larger garrison, and, in return, started to tie up the not inexhaustible human and technical resources of the Donbass People’s Army. Besides, being the legal Commander-in-Chief of the Militia, Igor Ivanovich could not provide fulsome guidance to his army from a besieged city. He had a direct line to the DPR government (I do not know about LPR), but this was, understandably, not enough for adequate control over the Militia units, each of which was beholden to the charisma of its direct commander. In a situation like that you need a “mega-Batka” [Note: Batka – an Old Man], but “mega-Batka” was forced to sit in Slavyansk and wax melancholy. I won’t be afraid of this word – he grew bored with blowing up endless ammunitions store on Karachun and pummeling Ukrainian checkpoints on the near and far outskirts of the city. Igor Ivanovich needed operational freedom, and, this night, he finally found it. Don’t forget – he came to Slavyansk some time ago with a few battered automatic rifles and even smoothbore “Saiga” and “Vepr.” He left with a column of armoured vehicles. No need to even mention the loads of other equipment. This, undoubtedly, is yet another testimony to the dizzying victory of the Ukrainian army, which got a mousetrap instead of a trophy. Well, not an empty mousetrap. As I understand it, the Ukrainian army has yet to enter the city. Igor Ivanovich, a veteran of two Chechen wars, naturally made sure to leave behind enough maneuverable groups with grenade launchers and cover. And it is no accident that Messr. Tymchuk has been squealing about thousands of militiamen breaking through from Kramatorsk to Donetsk. Messr. Tymchuk has no idea that the road from Kramatorsk to Donetsk is absolutely free. But what Messr. Tymchuk should really think about is his fighters, sitting dejected at the Kramatorsk airfield and in the Donetsk airport. As I understand it, in the next few hours they will be added to the number of the “Heavenly Hundred.” And, in addition, Messr. Tymchuk will soon have to explain to his readers – why did the Ukrainian army spend two months battling with Slavyansk and what will it do with the city now?
Dmitry Steshin
Komsomolskaya Pravda
How many Slavyansks fell to Wehrmacht till they came to Stalingrad?
Partisant units have fled before artillery and mechanised assault, as they should`ve long ago.
And its only gross incompetence of ukr/us forces that allowed the clownery go for so long.
They will regroup, re-organise and counterattack.
My first comment. Watching Ukie forces build up over the cease fire made it clear that these two cities could no longer be held. As bad as it is, the Self Defense Fighters are men, not gods. They can only stand up to so much force and so many tanks, planes, artillery, rockets and armored infantry. I see it that they had to pull out in order to carry on the fight. Lack of support for these men from Russia is becoming very disturbing. Will they all be left to die in combat with nothing for help?
Saudi’s formented to some degree the bloody
wars in Chechnyu
Set upon Syria and now Iraq
Difficult to picture the bear cringing before
the bearded grinning vultures wearing sun glasses
but there it is
Teflon vulture….is there a wikipedia entry yet?
I am so glad to read this, and I thank Dmitry Steshin for these truths, which I hope and assume many people in Russia are reading also. His admiration for Strelkov, and his understanding of the man’s confined position are very apparent.
The Killdeer is a bird that fakes a broken wing to lure predators away from its nest. I believe Commander Strelkov has some of the Killdeer blood in him ;)
The “fall” of Slavyansk marks the rise of the Donbass Army. Now the true fight begins. And Strelkov can stretch his legs a little.
Hideous war crimes and the mass death of civilians have taken place, but it was all one side that did this – and to stop it requires defeating the entire side. This is a war between the Donbass and whatever we call the illegal regime that holds sway over most of Ukraine. I am no military analyst but it seems clear to me that Donbass can win this war, and that history has given the task to Donbass to go to Kiev and throw down the tyrant. It’s the only security for Donbass.
Odessa, among other areas, has not yet made its position in this war clear. It seems very early days in a national civil war. By contrast, the days seem numbered for the shaky regime in Kiev.
Sometime after Crimea was safe, President Putin was able to tell the world something of the moves that Russia made during that time. Sometime in the future, he will be able to tell us some of the ways Russia has acted here.
Russia could not save the Ukrainian Russians simply by coming to the relief of Slavyansk – if this had been possible, Russia may well have done so. As so wisely stated here, the battlefield determines the time. And the field is still shaping itself. We in this forum are all too close to the villages and towns being massacred. But this is only part of the war.
I have learned, largely from the Saker, many reasons to respect and admire President Putin, and the Russian deep state that he represents. I remain unshaken in this regard.
I believe that Russia is fighting a war against its sworn and deadly enemy, the United States. Apart from a few advisors and proxies, the US doesn’t show itself much in Ukraine, it has no military presence here.
I have heard that Russian ships ready with nuclear weapons stood down the US fleet over Syria, and that Russian missiles stand ready to shoot down US planes if they attack.
I don’t see Russia fleeing from its enemies or its responsibilities. And now, apparently, I also don’t see Russia crippling its effectiveness over no-win tactical maneuvers in Ukraine. I believe one day President Putin will be able also to tell us why he had to go back on his words that offered hope and encouragement to Donbass. I will give him the time to explain, and not judge him prematurely.
Meanwhile, on the ground, the Donbass Army celebrate a grim yet stunning victory. As illustrated in this article, it exists, and its Republic exists, and the enemy exists, and shows clearly that it can be defeated. The day of mourning is not yet. A civil war to establish the victory of justice over evil is still being born.
So, Strelkov did something he had made everyone believe a) he was never going to do and b) was impossible anyway. That was a smart move. Though the fans who made him into a knight in shining armor are going to be disappointed. Problem is, many people have been using Strelkov’s statements for judging the situation, and we now know they are highly suspect (not that there had not been hints before, but most chose to ignore them). Now it is uncertain how much of what we have been told is complete rubbish (or manipulated truth). I think figuring this out will take some time.
Slavyansk = Vukovar
Excellent in propaganda terms; he turned a defeat into a victory with words.
To Dmitry Steshin:
Thank you for the encouraging words and the broader view.
Every week since February I was going from joy to despair and back, depending on the situation. And every time when it looked as if everything fails, a small miracle happened, and the hope was back.
And hope arrives!
It should be obvious that Strelkov cannot afford to post accurate info on operations and his intentions on the net.
Anonymous said…
Slavyansk = Vukovar
Exactly.Buying time for the rebels to regroup and rearm.Lets wait till the end to see who will win the war.Personaly I think hunta is up for a suprise when they attack Doneck and Gorlovka
President Putin does NOT want to destroy Russia by engaging it into war – he wants Russia to become a major economical and political player on the international arena. He will make Russia strong by not responding to USA/NATO provocations. President Putin is a very pragmatic, rational man, a great Russian patriot who will do everything in his power to increase Russia’s influence in the world. War is NOT an option for president Putin. He is way too smart to fall for NATO’s stupid game.
We have to wait and see… it is not over yet. President Putin has a plan – but he will let us know when the time will come.