Okay, I carefully read all your comments and have come to something of a conclusion.
First, almost everything I post in unverified and often unverifiable. Which compares advantageously with the main stream media which deliberately lies and whose reporter and editors simply don’t care about the truth.
Second, I really don’t feel like singling out one story or source for the typical “this is an unconfirmed report” or the like like the MSM does because typically these caveats are used to cast a doubt on the info itself, or to discredit the source, and all for political ideological reasons. Besides, this is the Internet and the blogosphere – I never met *any* of my contacts face to face, not one, nor do I personally know any of the people who are helping me with this blog (the French teams, the interpreters, the sobcors, Juan, Mindfriedo, Auslander, etc.). My personal vetting system is based on the words of Christ “Ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?” (Matt 7:16). If I find out that somebody deliberately lied or is a untrustworthy source I will simply not post info from that person again and I might even post a correction.
Third, I don’t buy the “too far” argument. Wars are horrible and atrocities are the norm, not the exception. Especially wars waged on the basis of an ideology which de-humanizes the other side. The Ukrainian Nazis call the Russians “insects” (колорады), “jackets” (ватники) while their leader called Russian subhumans. And since on top of that, these Banderites are ideologically a mix of Nazis, Uniat crusaders and rabid xenophobes I see absolutely no reason at all to doubt the story of Berezin. Does it mean that I trust him? No. But I have no reason to dis-trust him either. I certainly trust him more than I would trust any western newspaper or TV channel.
Fourth, in what concerns the credibility of this blog, or me personally, I think that it should not depend on a single or even a few posts. Everybody can be mislead, and I have a long history of being wrong and I have never pretended otherwise. I don’t claim to be infallible, I only claim to be honest.
Fifth, there is a good possibility that Berezin wrote this report with a great deal of pain and distress in his heart, and it is possible that what he says is true. Who am I to reject it on the basis that it could be false? His text was an appeal for help, for justice, I could not sit on it and do nothing.
Sixth, in my experience all sides lie during a war. The only exception to this rule is, as far as I know, Hassan Nasrallah. Many continue to think that a good lie is a smart way to fight the information war. I disagree, but I know that that notion is out there. And, just for the record, Putin did say that no Russian troops were involved in the move to liberate Crimea while Strelkov did say that it was men under his command which wiped out the Ukrainian checkpoint even though in both cases there was overwhelming evidence to the contrary. If I had to rate Putin and Strelkov as sources I would rate Putin as a ‘B’ and Strelkov as a ‘C’, which is on par with the very best corporate media. If there is a Russian Nasrallah out there, I have not met him yet, alas.
I guess that if/when I get the new website up I might include some kind of generic warning, but that is the best I can do. As long as a story sounds credible to me, I will have to post it, even if I cannot verify it (there will be one coming from Sweden in tomorrow’s SITREP which is also very interesting, but which I cannot verify. Still, I will post it).
Now if something is clearly wrong, fabricated, or truly non-credible, then I will include some kind of disclaimer (assuming I post it in the first place).
I hope that you guys can live with that :-)
Kind regards, thanks for the input,
The Saker
I really like the way you think things through, Saker. And respect you a lot for it, too. Your very openness about it all, your willingness to set it all out, seek our input and then reach and explain your conclusions is a big part of what is so uniquely wonderful about this blog.
I really like the way you think things through, Saker, and respect you a lot for it, too. Your very openness about it all, your willingness to set it all out, seek our input and then reach and explain your conclusions is a big part of what is so uniquely wonderful about this blog. Thank you.
Here is the info totally “verifiable”:
According to the World bank, in 1994 Iran posted GDP of $67B, while Israeli economy was $75B in size.
In 2012, Iran had GDP of $552B, and Israel – $257B.
This should put to rest the lie of Iran suffering horribly under US sanctions. If anything, they made the country stronger.
I hope Putin is well aware of it.
Report Here (http://dnrepublic.info/news/aehroport_donecka_vzjat_pod_kontrol_armiej_dnr/2014-06-25-551) that Donetsk airport now in control of self defence force.
I could not ask for anything more.
Repression of anti-fascist groups in Ukraine continues. The organisation Borotba suffered a series of illegal raids on its offices in Kiev, Kharkov and Odessa and was finally forced to go underground. They now report the kidnapping of their activist :“The apartment of our activist from Dnepropetrovsk Maria Matyushenko was raided. Unknown people (according to preliminary information from the SBU security service) ransacked her home and took her.”
Thanks to RT for eporting this at the right time:
74% of Germans oppose permanent NATO bases in Poland and Baltics
http://rt.com/news/168400-germany-opposes-nato-bases/
Thanks also to The Saker for having reported about Austria yesterday (Austria is a german-speaking country south of germany, and technically not more different from germany, than Bavaria [which is part of germany]).
I hope you now accept me as your comrade. My only destination is RUSSIA. Only finances and private matters are so far the problem. Also there is still much demand for improving my language skills.
Who hides behind anonymity while I provide my full name, should never in his life dare to call me a liar again.
I paid a high price for loving Russia.
Because if you live in a US colony and try to survive, it is a revolutionary act, to post all this to the OpenSXCE.org community sites, as I did.
I don’t have a huge quantity of followers, but those that I do have, would never in 1000 years have read or watched anything from the Russian perspective. My approach was,, to spam them with articles from RT, the Saker etc. Maybe I could manage to achieve a minimal shift in thinking in the USA and germany’s Software Developer’s communities. maybe yes, maybe not. I tried it and by doing so destroyed most of my income and former friendships.
I don’t do it for anonymous bloggers who claim, they know everything. (It is important not to get trapped in the own “beliefs”. I re-check my own beliefs every day again, until I find out more and get either verified confirmation, or need to correct myself.)
I do it because of Odessa, Mariupol and Lugansk.
*****I do it for her: *****
http://opensxce.blogspot.de/2014/06/the-west-supported-ukrainian-army-su-25.html
I got ridiculed, because I had written, 2014 is a pure NIGHTMARE. You know: Everytime I see the victims of the Empire, especially now in Novorossyia, it depresses me a piece more. This shows, that I’m still a human being.
But on the other hand it is not the right reaction to generalize: Who says, “the germans” or “the Ukies” or “the Poles” makes a mistake.
I said before: Shadows of grey”.
It is better if you write “Berlin, Kiev, Warszaw” (‘s pseudo-elite bitches).
Saker,
I trust your morality. It is what makes the blog valuable.
You bear witness . . .
The rest is up to us who come, read, participate.
Thank you Saker!!! Good call! I for one don’t want the glamorized version of war as the mainstream shoves down our throats on the daily. I do believe we can all handle it. If not you need to start handling it otherwise you can continue to live in the dark, pretending your not in the “know”. I for one never want to return to that nice place of ignorance. Although the story is heartbreaking how can we look away as we have done by design for so many many year? This affects all humanity as a whole, as horrifying as it is, we are all in this together. Bless you!
@Saker:
You’re writing about events that are still unfolding. There is no way to know with absolute certainty if something is true or not, unless you’re right there in the midst of the action, trying to describe this very action. In fact, the people who are fighting this war (Strelkov) often don’t have the entire picture of these events themselves, because they don’t have the necessary distance or the time to verify the veracity of this information. We’re still discovering the truth about the WW1 and WW2.
One of the reasons I come here, is because I want to read your opinions and not just witness yet another newscast. I don’t want to read something that is dispassionate, detached and therefore “objective” . I want to read things that are from your heart, sprinkled with intuition and educated guesses. Please, keep it exactly the way it is.
Corpses found at bottom of lake near Slavyansk.
http://translate.googleusercontent.com/translate_c?depth=1&hl=en&rurl=www.google.com&sl=ru&tl=en&u=http://rusvesna.su/news/1403737062&usg=ALkJrhgeJM_hHqX5KNkPsIPaR-WMbHgq9g
This is a probable example fo the morality Kiev coup side shows up until now.
Martin, thank you for your courage; bless you for your sacrifice. You have put your friends, your job and world on the line in order to stand or the values that make us all human.
There is pain in your voice, the pain that comes from seeing so much suffering. That pain and that sight, can destroy us if not handled rightly. May your heart continue to be sensitive, may you never get calloused or cynical.
The suffering you see and the pain you feel is but a glimpse of the pain that God the Father carries. He shares only a bit of it with us. Do not carry what He does not give and when it gets too heavy, leave it with Him for awhile before picking it back up.
May you continue to be a person of justice and compassion. As you have shown mercy, may you so receive it.
Saker, If you do not publish, who else?!
If any one can not stand of been told this kind atrocity commit in a war, then try hard stop the war. This is what happens when you go to war because you hate some one so bad, or you feel your Superior to others. What some history reference, try read rape of Nanking.
I think your work as a whole, and your stance on the quality and veracity of information you publish in your blog are both wise and noble.
One of the greatest obstacles on humankind’s path to freedom, spiritual and material develeopment and prosperity is the entrenched “culture” of lies and disinformation – I mean not only the blatant, in-your-face lies but lies by omission as well. Especially the latter. It has gone so far that one can rarely trust a clinical trial, a peer-reviewed article, or official statistics – everything goes in the name of greed, power and other nefarious purposes.
Your blog is one of the rare honest voices on the internet, and media in general. One of the reasons is you don’t censor information. Please, just ignore trolls and detractors, there are too many of them anyway. Carry on the fight for truth and freedom, Saker. We need you.
Vladimir from Bulgaria
The only Good is knowledge and the only Evil is ignorance – Socrates.
Saker, Keep fighting for Good, your work is deeply appreciated.
The only Good is knowledge and the only Evil is ignorance – Socrates.
Saker, Keep fighting for Good, your work is deeply appreciated.
Vladimir from Bulgaria,
” It has gone so far that one can rarely trust a clinical trial, a peer-reviewed article, or official statistics – everything goes in the name of greed, power and other nefarious purposes.”
sigh. Yes. We find ourselves asking “cui bono?” almost every time we look at one nowadays. The change from collegiality to competition/greed happened slowly but even the premier journals went downhill fast in the past 15 years or so.