Today I want to share a few musical gems with you with the hope that you will enjoy them as much as I do!
First, I want to share a superb version of “The Water is Wide” by Tommy Emmanuel and Stephen Bennett. Tommy Emmanuel is an accomplished multi-style guitarist whom I very much appreciate, especially when he plays acoustic (his electric guitar music is much less interesting). Before seeing this video, I did not know about Stephen Bennett, but I can tell you that I typically am very dubious of musicians who use fancy instruments or, for that matter, a looper. Some musicians have guitars with tons of strings, but can’t write a melody. Those who use and abuse the looper pedal are typically even worse. So when I see them I always want to say “if you are good, then six strings is all you need, and if you are bad, then even 10’000 strings – or a looper – won’t help you”. Well, Stephen Bennett is clearly an exception to this (totally subjective) “rule”. Yes, he plays a rather fancy looking harp-guitar, but the *manner* in which he uses it is superb and, crucially, he does not rely on the extra capabilities of his instrument, he only uses them to enhance his otherwise superb play. I absolutely love this interpretation of “The Water is Wide”, especially how Emmanuel and Bennett play the melody in two voices. I think that this is a true gem:
Next, a video+notes of the interpretation of Gordon Jenkins‘ superb and deeply moving composition “Goodbye” (which he wrote after the death of his first wife in childbirth) interpreted by Philip Catherine, my absolutely favorite guitarist and the man who most inspired my own guitar playing. I found a version with notes on YT, and this is the one I wanted to share with you. The style here is very minimalist, reserved, but deeply, deeply emotional and, I think, absolutely beautiful. This is improvised music (or Jazz) at its very best, imnsho.
Next, I want to introduce you to a young Russian guitarist, Anton Oparin, who interprets a composition by J.S. Bach (my absolutely favorite composer, bar none) on the electric guitar. Question: is it a sacrilege to play Bach’s music on a modern, electric, instrument? In my opinion, absolutely not! In fact, Bach’s immense popularity amongst so many modern guitarists (there is even a entire style of music called “Baroque Rock”) proves how timeless Bach’s genius was. See for yourself:
Lastly, I leave you with my favorite Manouche guitarist, Angelo Debarre and his superb interpretation of the tune “Valse d’Angelo“. I absolutely *love* Manouche music (especially waltzes!) and I think that Debarre is the best of the best in this style. Enjoy and have a great week-end!
Everything goes back to Bach. He is THE source (sorry about the caps). So there is zero sacrilege in electrifying his music. He would love it. After all, he once pulled a knife on a fellow musician (an oboist, I believe) in the town square. It’s music. An adventure. Take it where you will.
I agree that Bach is Da Man, but he is only the source for western music.
The rest of the planet has different musical roots.
My 2cts
Sure, but the rest of the planet is also playing and listening to Bach. My version of the cello suites is performed outstandingly by Jian Wang.
It does, while NOT considering him as the “source”
try Indian music for starters :-)
Maxx recorded a song with Al Di Meola in May which should be completed by October. Subsequent to that he was Steve Vai’s guest (Al and Steve are good friends) at a camp in Vegas two weeks ago featuring none other than Steve, Tommy Emmanuel, Nuno Bettencourt and others. Tommy performed a one hour solo set that was surreal on account of he plays the impossible. Super nice guy, very funny and he ended with his rendition of ‘Imagine’ by John Lennon (his favorite song of peace) which left Steve Vai and many others in tears. When it’s done I’ll send it to you. Btw, these musical posts are excellent and provide a breathing space from the intense themes that otherwise predominate this excellent site. Peace bro!
“western” music has also for centuries drawn on many musical roots.
Anyhow, my Russian friend sent me CDs of the guitarist Ivan Smirnov.
One of them is Strana, gdye nochuyet solntse
The Country Where the Sun Sleeps
I think he is pretty fantastic. He died way too young.
Here is a Youtube vid with the above song:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xl2RZ6GEk4M
I enjoy Bach as well as many other s of the Classical music. However, I really enjoy playing Donald MacLeod.
I would call Bach baroque, not classical, though the term “classical” is also used to cover various styles (romantic, modern, etc.).
Still, I have a weak spot for baroque, hence my picky comment :-)
Yes I agree about baroque, Bach on organ renderings, something about it.
How about this for Baroque? Sorry, don’t know how to insert videos.
Kathline Battle and Wynton Marsalis: Eternal Source of Light Divine.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2MuCCbg0
Yeah, but you can’t catch the incredible progressions, modulations, etc. on this electric guitar the way that you can with someone like Ana Vidovich on the classical guitar.
Why not?
Found all pieces interesting in their own right. LOL’d when Oparin goes “whoo!” at videos end. Re “Water is Wide”, politics aside, always liked the Dylan & J. Baez live version, I think it was off a Dylan Tribute event circa ’92, and might still be on YouTube.
Totally unrelated for those interested, YouTube has 1939 film version of “Stepan Razin” for viewing. No subtitles.
Joan Baez won me with her Birmingham Sunday back in the 60’s.
What a fantastic gift for the weekend. Thank you for the introduction to both the music and the musicians.
You are so welcome!!!
Enjoy and stay safe.
Kind regards
Andrei
Dear Saker,
We played ‘The River Is Wide’ for our ‘Pipee’s brother David who died of being cured of Leukemia. Not here is a different version called ‘When the Piper Plays.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YBqgGDlVw74&ab_channel=MusicShowScotland
Music, thank you Father for this wonderful gift of love while we grow through adversity down here.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gVYYwqco43c&list=RDgVYYwqco43c&index=1
For Batiushka
https://youtu.be/nkOiKy6sXfM
You can see why Georg Solti has a world wide reputation as a conductor.
Good stuff! Hey, Mr. Martyanov posted this a couple of months back. These girls are wonderful too. Andrei said their goodness could not be described. Their first tune, a rendition of Scarborough Fair, is rather soulful.
https://youtu.be/6xqTfMQz3GE
Thank you Saker for all that beautiful music. What would life be without it.
Tommy Emmanuel, John Jorgenson, Pedro Javier Gonzalez – Sultans of Swing;
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EFDFpS9_ZWY
Tipsy Gipsy – David Grisman, Tommy Emmanuel;
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hOt-cZIVvu0
Tommy Emmanuel in Russia;
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gkVsll3whR0
I was a friend of Tommy’s brother Phil who, was also an incredible guitarist.
He stayed at my house for 3 days once and played guitar for us almost the entire time telling stories as he went. He told us some great stories of how, when they were kids, the family toured outback Australia (it’s a very big place) and went from town to town playing and performing and sometimes, had to sleep under bridges when it rained.
Tommy is a great guitarist and performer as was Phil who died a few years back. Both of them are/were very down to earth people.
I know for a fact that Phils hero guitarist was Chet Atkins.
You are a very lucky person, I am a little jealous of you :-)
A little ‘lite’ Friday afternoon weekend music for our brothers and sisters in the UK.
https://fivegunswest.blogspot.com/2022/08/a-message-to-you-uk-cant-truss-it.html
Andrei, what about Al Di Meola? Don’t think you ever mentioned him. Member of legendary Return to Forever, guitar trio with JML and Paco De Lucia, with outstanding 50+ years solo career. In my biased opinion he’s playing one of the best singing guitars out there.
https://youtu.be/GRTVe5wGkz4
Al DiMeola is a brilliant guitarist for sure. I especially love his style of improvisation. As a composer, I would say that most of this stuff is pretty average with a few gems here and there. I REALLY like his interpretation of Astor Piazolla’s music. He was the best guitarists (in terms of impro) during his time with John McLaughlin and Paco de Lucia (both far superior composers, as opposed to improvisers, in my opinion).
There are plenty of superb guitarists I have not mentioned yet (Joe Beck, Larry Coryell, Pierre Bensusan, Ralph Towner, Raphael Rabello, Cacho Tirao, Pat Metheny, etc. etc. etc. and plenty of less famous ones).
That is what I plan to share with you in future week-ends :-)
Cheers
Thanks for these tasteful selections.
Here is another one to enjoy:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6zGBfPLFEbA
It’s called ‘Wide River To Cross’ and has that same folkiness as ‘The Water is Wide.’
Not exactly Bach or Beethoven, but lately I’ve been listening to “Two Steps From Hell”, the name alone is reflective of the times we’re in :-)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vbttZVTSJRU
But there are few side roads into the far east as well:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9zAzgc_74Cc
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yr1VUF_KFIg
Well someone may say it is not the type of music to relax, but that would be pure envy… lol and what about this lyric, written more than 30 years ago?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c7Z8Ww1EmMk
This song is very reminiscent of Carraigfergus, an Irish song, which when I went looking for it on Youtube, I found this one, with two of Irelands finest and most cherished musicians, Imelda May and Finbar Furey:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kwRkIlrGa6w
Dear Razor,
I once heard Cara Dillon singing ‘She moved through the fair’ at an Irish concert, I think in Blackpool. It was literally the best ever rendition of the song I have ever heard. She later did the same concert in Germany, but it was not as good as Blacktown. The BBC however, pulled the Youtube of Blacktown for whatever reason, and I bought a copy of her CD, but it was made in a studio, which rarely are as good as a live performance.
If you ever get the opportunity to listen live, it is so much better and the atmosphere can never be duplicated. by the way, I also have enjoyed Finbar Wright.
Thanks for the music, Saker.
Tommy Emanuel gave the greatest live performance I’ve ever seen (better even than Keith Emerson and Sinatra) — a medley of Classical Gas, Windy and Warm and Grieg’s In the Hall of the Mountain King at the Keswick Theater outside Philadelphia. Third song of the night and the tension and greatness were unbearable, an instant standing ovation and roaring. He has many definitive versions including Somewhere Over the Rainbow and, yes, he’s always best acoustic.
Young italian guitarist doing some Shorter and Holdsworth…]
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HrOfLmQgROc
very very nice, thank you!!
I have seen both Tommy Emmanuel and Stephen Bennett live, in person, multiple times at the Walnut Valley Festival in Winfield, Kansas. Every September, third weekend. Such a special experience. It’s called a bluegrass festival, but I am here to tell you, it is so much more than bluegrass.
Re: non-Western musical roots, Tommy Emmanuel knows a thing or two about those…. One year at Winfield, he did a long, long piece evoking the land and worldview of Australia’s aboriginal people. It was one of the most remarkable pieces of music I ever heard, and nothing like Western music at all. He made sounds come out of that battered guitar of his that I never even knew a guitar could make. It was INTENSE. My whole body trembled with chills, and tears streamed down my face. It was an EXPERIENCE like no other. And the hundreds or maybe a couple thousand other people who witnessed it felt the same way. When he finished the piece, everyone was so overwhelmed that there were a couple seconds of stunned silence. And then — a loud, prolonged standing ovation. Friends looked at each other as if truly seeing each other for the first time, and strangers looked around at each other as if they were long-lost friends.
I think Tommy might have recorded it at some point, but I can tell you right now: It’s not the same. Some things just have to be experienced live. I will always be grateful that I was there that day, in that place, at that time. And I will always have a special place in my heart for Tommy Emmanuel.
Andrei, Thank you. The Philip Catherine chart was such a joy!! I think Philip was one of the few Direct to disk albums I bought years ago.
Mr Martyanov had a comment on youtube of his today’s video that caught my attention. “I Russian” by Russian pop tenor Shaman. This song has 10 million hits in three weeks. Today Yaroslavl the artist thanked everyone for finding his work. This young man has to be the best pop tenor singing. a real real world class singer. The timing is now and this reminds me of a Joe Ely song which I thought should have been Bill Clinton’s choice for his run “Start the Car”. Joe Ely. Enjoy!! Peace!!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ug8b8EmJDhU&t=175 – A little Irish flavour.
Andrei, I think you’ll like these 2 dudes from the Balkans: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kyFwwIHw6nw&ab_channel=sslavi
Or + 1 with a Bulgarian kaval https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a_ccWKhFXDE&ab_channel=zirafabandera
A lot of rock and metal bands seek inspiration in Bach’s music. Mostly because of his unique, melancholic and awe inspiring style.
So Bach and electric guitar go hand in hand like knife and butter.
My local classical station blessed me with Alexander Borodin’s “In the Steppes of Central Asia” this morning. I was worried they were going to go along with the trend of censoring Russian composers, conductors and musicians but thankfully that is not the case.
If you like Baroque and if you like rock there isn’t only Bach, but my master is Vivaldi. And if you need to hear a masterpiece hear this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uw0lsrOTMaE
Hi Andrei, as a guitarist myself I enjoyed listening to your choices of music. Have you heard Olafur Arnolds ‘Saman’ ?- imo one of the most beautiful pieces of music ever composed. There is a tab for guitar on ‘Ultimate guitar’.
Keep up the good work brother. Regards, Pavlos.
No I never heard of him.
Got a link to this composition and to the tabs?
Thank you
Wonderful musical selections from everybody. With a friend I went to a performance in Auckland a few weeks ago with the NZSO and visiting US violinist Hilary Hahn.
A nearly all Russian programme in these latter days of deranged cancel culture, with the Prokofiev violin concerto No 1 D Major and in the second half Shostakovich’s Symphony No 1 in D Minor.
I’m unexpectedly beginning to relish the classical repertoire all over again with more understanding because of the genius of some women like Hilary Hahn, Yuja Wang and Khatia Buniatishvili.
These musicians are extending and reinvigorating the classical tradition. They are all beautiful with stunning clothing to match.
Brahms Piano No 2 BFlat major
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BszBccYHuA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SyFQwiAqDS4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LUp2u9wI1fY
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kdbzJChaDyo
Thu Le is a fabulous guitarist.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ojBYW3ycVTE
Edson Lopez is another fabulous guitarist. In spirit of this thread, here he performs Bach, which I think is unsurpassed. Recommended; his performances of his native Brasil music.
Andrei, I just want to thank you for these little treasure nuggets of music that you post. I have been your follower for a long time and a avoid/afraid of commenting, but I am so overwhelmed by the beauty of music selection that you post that I cannot stop myself from typing this thank you note. Please, do it as often as you can, these are not just delight but needed education. Огромное спасибо!!!
First and only time I heard “The Water is Wide” was a beautiful rendition sung by Esther & Somebody Ofarim. Tommy Emmanuel is a wonder & a great personality. Electric guitar is a little harsh for Bach, personally. Never heard of Manouche but Wow! And I thought you had to have burned 2 fingers off one hand as a kid before you could play like this! Django must be smiling.
Let’s try this
Recorded almost at her 20th birthday
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5E2IA9PD-IU
Many thanks, not just to Andrei but also to the many links and introductions into a completely unknown universe of guitar virtuosos, As a totally addicted classical guitar student for the last twenty one years I never cease to be awed by new technical accomplishments coupled with each artist artistic sensitivities.
Music, guitar music in particular, opens to my mind an exploration into the links between finger dexterity, cognitive development and interpersonal commutative potentials not seemingly available to laryngeally developed communication.
You made my weekend Saker, thanks again.
Excellent guitarists all over the world, in many and totally different incomparable styles of music. Comparable to Anton Oparin there’s some good music coming from the Baltics as well: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D8-T09qB6PI – Laura Lace.
Since I left a link , I imposed on me to take a peek at every other links
This should be a rule
Nope not sacrilege. Crossroads was a great movie. :)
Hoping to see/hear some Radio KAOS or Pros and Cons of Hitch-hiking at some stage ;)
Kind regards
Thank you. I liked Goodbye and La Gitane, but I was hoping for original, Russian sourced, contemporary instrumental music. I am a great fan of Mussorgsky (all works), Rachmaninoff (Sym #2 and Piano Sonatas 2-3), and Tchaikovsky (ballet music) …
Dear Saker,
this is the first time I comment afaik. I did refrain because I had little to say – which might be the case now, again – that would surpass nodding silently (at best), or adding more trash to current (worst).
But now I have something to add. I humbly propose you to look at and hear a gem in Bach’s work which isn’t known by the general public, and if so, rarely understood.
Let me draw your attention to Four Duets, BWV 802-805. These are part o “Clavierübung Theil III” and key to understanding the meaning of that compendium. “Theil III” consists of a prelude and a fugue, and in between these there are lotsa “Choralvorspiele”, choral preludes. Just before the great fugue, also called “Trinitatis Fugue”, those four duets appear – and they seem to have nothing to do with the rest, as if just lumped in. This is not the case.The keys are ascending – e,F,G,a – and just the fact that they are placed just before the trinitatis fugue tells us, that they do have an easterly, a passion meaning.
They are musical expressions of key topics in the life of Christ, as seen by Christ himself, from the inside.
I would add to them these titles:
1. e minor – the daily work of the masters: ascension, descension, salvation and resurrection, ascension
2. F mayor – the master an his chela
3. G mayor – joy of life, love, and teaching
4. a minor – passion and forgiveness
Probably the best interpretation of those pieces on piano that I heard up to now is by Evgeni Koroliov (ha! a russian)
Check these out on youtube, start here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XJDb00Go7vE&list=PL87A9AC9D1632EB58
Last not least, these pieces carry a gematric inscription of the litany “victimae paschalis laude” from Wipo of Burgund, 9th century.
I have written a short essay about those pieces some years ago, I might rework that and translate it for you, if you are interested.
blessings, and keep up the good work
0–gg-