source: https://vc.ru/finance/379827-kuda-delis-rossiyskie-zolotovalyutnye-rezervy-i-budet-li-defolt
translated by the Saker Translation community
Part of our gold and currency reserves was frozen in other countries, mainly the US and EU member states, due to sanctions imposed against Russia’s Central Bank (RCB).
Therefore, Russians are naturally asking why are our strategic reserves NOT stored on Russia’s territory but on the territory of our economic adversaries?
We’ll try to explain how much was stored where, how much is left, can it be returned, how the freeze will affect the economy and ordinary Russians, and also who’s to blame.
What do the RCB reserves consist of:
RCB publishes an annual report on its assets and a weekly one on its volume. It stopped publishing on March 4. As of that date reserves consisted of $643 billion, but the data on the structure go back to June 30, 2021, when it was as follows:
$311 billion: financial instruments by foreign issuers.
$152 billion: cash in foreign deposits.
$132 billion: gold in Russia.
$30 billion: International Monetary Fund.
Thus, 80% of Russia’s reserves are outside of Russia. We’ll explain why later, but first here’s the list of countries as of June 30, 2021:
Geography of Russian Central Bank (RCB) Reserves storage as of 30.06.2021
A reminder – this represents the allocation as of the end of June, 2021. After the publication of that report, the RCB reported it was moving part of the reserves from western countries to eastern ones, therefore the geographic distribution might not be accurate, but is a guide, since there have been no radical changes.
Thus, Russia is home to only 1/5 of the reserves, 13% are in China, 5% in IMF, and the rest are in Europe and United States. China is apparently friendly, some of the ‘other’ countries are as well, IMF is not about to block the reserves, but Western countries have decided to recall their “raider” past, therefore only half of the reserves proved resilient to arrest or potential arrest, and the rest we have no access to. The Minister of Finance, Anton Siluanov, named the figure of $300 million which is approximately the same as my calculations.
According to one explanation I’ve seen earlier, RCB transferred some of the reserves from the West to Eastern countries, in secrecy from the IMF, giving IMF a false report and therefore Western powers expected they’d be able to freeze a far larger sum than it turned out. But I have not seen any official confirmation (or refutation) of that explanation. One can only guess whether they thought this through or it came out the way it did by accident.
Nevertheless, some of our money was blocked, and that’s a fact. It’s remains our money, only RCB account transactions are blocked (it’s possible it’s our money for now, but one wants to believe they will release the funds).
If $300 billion were arrested, about $340 billion remain free, out of which $132 billion is monetary gold in the form of bullion. It is not known how much of the remaining money is cash, and how much is invested in securities.
But, I want to make a disclaimer right away — I’m not accusing anyone and I’m not defending anyone, however, the RCB and the Ministry of Finance did everything correctly, reducing the share of the dollar and the euro in favor of the currencies of eastern countries. However, our retaliatory move against blocking our reserves may be harder for the US and the EU, but more on that later.
The Central Bank began withdrawing money from dollar assets after 2017, when the United States froze about 40% of Kazakhstan’s reserves on far-fetched pretexts. Yes, regardless whatever pretexts there may be, no one has the right to prohibit the use of reserves accumulated by a sovereign country. This created a dangerous precedent, and our financial authorities reacted correctly to it, not just hoping that somehow, we would not be affected.
So, why are our reserves stored abroad?
Let’s see which ones – specifically cash currency and securities of foreign countries. The answer depends on it.
Securities. When you buy stock in a foreign company like Apple or Bank of America, you don’t receive these shares and nobody brings them to Russia as if it was cash. They are all stored in the country where they are issued. You don’t buy the stock but get a receipt that says you have ownership. And vice versa—when foreigners buy our stock, these obligations don’t leave Russia.
It’s the same with central bank reserves. Our RCB buys US government bonds and, in accordance with the rules, they are kept in the US. They cannot physically leave US territory, or the territory of other countries where RCB buys government bonds.
Cash. Storing money as money is the best way for it to lose its value – you know this yourself. Keeping money under the pillow means losing its purchasing power commensurate with annual inflation. You place your liquidity in a savings account so that you can earn some sort of interest and your losses are less than inflation.
The RCB (and other central banks) do the same. It places dollars, euros, yuan, yen, and franks and so forth in foreign banks at interest.
It could hardly be otherwise, and if it could be, then one could blame the RCB and the Finance Ministry for improper distribution of assets, because the value of the reserves ought to be sustained and not lost year to year by merely being kept in a huge safe.
Why can’t these assets be deposited with interest in Russian banks? Because Russia does not print another currency and banks do not earn money on it, respectively, banks cannot guarantee RCB income in foreign currency. There is enough money for the population, but not enough to ensure a profit on hundreds of billions of dollars at interest. Moreover, commercial banks also deposit foreign currency in foreign banks when you make such deposits, earning interest and sharing it with you.
RCB has cash reserves in order to react quickly, to intervene in order to support the ruble exchange rate and to pay debts, but cash is only a small portion of the assets.
Why is the RCB storing money in dollars, euro, pounds, and yen? Because, as of right now, these are the most stable currencies in the world, with minimal inflation. Therefore, their purchasing power does not decline as much as the Kazakh tenge, the Belorussian ruble, the Turkish lira, or other world currencies.
How to retrieve these assets?
As I already mentioned, right now only transactions are frozen. The Reserves have not been confiscated. Moreover, the government has a symmetrical response that will hurt the US and EU, much more than it will hurt us, if those restrictions are not lifted.
What has been done thus far:
A ban on dividend payments to non-residents (foreigners). Russia has forbidden paying any form of profit such as dividends to foreign owners, including private investors, international organizations, and governmental organizations which have invested in Russia. They will not be able to realize a profit.
A ban on transferring or transporting foreign currency out of Russia in large sums. Just as currency belongs in part to foreign citizens and organizations, its de-facto arrest on Russia’s territory “hurts” those who earned money in Russia while being abroad. The vast majority of these are foreign investors. Moreover, they will not be able to earn a profit from Russian financial instruments, which means that foreign countries could declare Russia in technical default since Russia is not fulfilling its obligations.
But there is a solution.
Here is the plan:
Paying debts in rubles. In the coming days, the Ministry of Finance will have to pay coupons on Eurobonds, which have to be paid in foreign currency. Anton Siluanov (the Minister of Finance) stated that all will be paid on time, but only in rubles, since we don’t have access to our “foreign currency wallet”, and in order to transfer rubles into dollars, those wallets will have to be unfrozen.
On the one hand, Russia would fulfill its obligations and pay its debts, but on the other, that might not satisfy “the other side”, since ruble payments are not in accordance with the terms of the deal. So, it’s a form of competent blackmail, and walking on ice at the same time.
In any event, Russia has money and, most importantly, levers of influence and pressure unlike Iran or Venezuela which also had their funds blocked. And there’s one more key issue:
What will happen to the economy if the reserves are not unblocked and will there be a default?
Naturally, one cannot rule out the possibility the reserves won’t be unblocked and our hundreds of billions will be used by Uncle Sam to cover his national debt, so let’s see what the consequences would be. I’ll say at once it won’t be like 1998.
For starters, let’s remember that a default is a country’s inability to fulfill its obligations, namely, debts. A default in Russia would occur if, when the time came to pay, there was no money. Government loans can be internal (must in their own currency) and external (must in foreign currency).
Russia has $119 billion in foreign debt of, including $39 billion in bonds, of which only $7 billion is by 2025. It must pay $2.1 billion by April 4. Pay with what? As we already explained, Russia has $643 billion in reserves, of which $340 billion are not frozen, or twice as much as the debt. Even if all the debt had to be paid all at once, that could be done without problems. As I already said, Russia’s debts will be paid in rubles since it does not have access to foreign currency savings. Russian companies (Gazprom, Yandex, Rosneft, and others) fulfill their obligations in hard currency.
Russia’s internal debt amounts to 16.5 trillion rubles, most of it in federal loan obligations and the payments stretch until 2044. How will that be paid? The National Welfare Fund has 13.7 trillion rubles. Seems like it is 3 trillion short, but over the course of 22 years the reserves will either increase or the needed quantity of rubles will be printed.
Incidentally, (a small digression) do you know that USA borrows only in dollars? Not because of boundless love toward its currency, but rather because one’s own currency can be created in whatever quantities needed in order to pay debts. Warren Buffett once said:
“If you are printing financial obligations in your own currency, the question arises – what will happen to the currency? The USA cleverly issues debt in its own currency. If I could issue “Buffett Coins”, had a printing press and I could borrow money – I would never stop paying my debts.”
The only thing that the West can do to Russia is place it in technical default. No need to panic, it has little to do with actual default. In order to understand technical default, imagine the following situation:
You ate at a café, asked for receipt, the waiter brought it to you but says that you can’t use your credit card here. You stick your hands into your pockets and realize you have no cash. Until you withdraw money from the nearest ATM, the café will hold you in technical default (naturally, this term is not applied to individuals, but you get the idea).
In other words, you have money and even desire to pay, but you physically cannot pay. Does it remind you of anything? Technical default does not pose serious threats to a country if money and willingness to pay exist.
How is this different from 1998? In 1998 there was no money, no ability to pay, and no particular desire either.
If Western countries seize Russian reserves, they will acquire the reputation of “plunderers”, and central banks of other countries will ask themselves the question whether it makes sense to keep one’s reserves in those countries if they can be snatched at any moment. Our country can be similarly branded if it decides to seize, as compensation, the property of foreign organizations, but at that point there will be nothing to lose.
I hope Russia will learn the necessary lessons from this situation and adopt measures aimed at better protecting its own capital. What thoughts do you have on that score?
And, as usual, if this was interesting for you, you may subscribe to my Telegram channel – there is even more useful information there, and it appears there more quickly.
A nation with a powerful military and nuclear weapons can forgive itself of any debt to foreign nations. Debt is only as good as the ability of a foreign power to make you pay it.
Please explain why Russia has been selling its natural resources in Empire’s private currencies ($, €,£,…).
No narrative fallacies, please. Nothing can camouflage this mistake of selling its resources in Empire’s private currencies. This weakens Russia’s position significantly and shows it doesn’t care about monetary sovereignty, and economic security.
The U$A sell its goods and services only in the US$. The U$A buys resources, manufacturing services,… only in the US$. It is the same with the EU. Russia sell its oil to the U$A in US$. Why? Russian media then brags about the U$A buying its oil. The U$A got that oil for FREE? Russia sells its gas to the EU in euros. Why? It will then have to keep the earned income at those Empire’s private banks. Why has Russia been funding its adversaries? Has Russia lost its minds?
Russia wants China to pay for its gas in the February deal in euros. Where will it keep that earned money? Why it didn’t structure that deal for payments in Renminbis or Rubles? Please explain the Russian rationale for these major bad decisions. These decisions were driving in which currency Russia will be paid and where it will have to keep the earned money. Individuals driving these decisions need to be held accountable as they ignored or purposely, challenged Russia’s economic security.
All valid questions. Some believe that RCB is part of a global monetary pyramid scheme. I wouldn’t go that far, but it is curious to see RCB behaving and playing by the western playbook.
A playbook with rules that they themselves don’t follow. It is time question every single rule.
@ Max
I completely agree with you Elvira ,Nabiulina and her entire team should be fired and tried for treason.
Some of the things that V. Putin overlook’s i don’t understant ,may be he is part of the Problem ,these people
Nabiuilina and gang are working for the Calba .
Tom 123
Nemirni & Tom 123, thanks for your perspectives and agreeing. Based on Vladimir Putin’s answers to questions in the monetary arena, it seems like he doesn’t have a good grasp on this subject. Unfortunately, his team is not advising him well and not being responsible with earned income and its investments. Most central bankers’ primary objective is maintaining the global financial system stability at a tremendous cost to the nation. Just read this book, “Currencies, Capital and Central Bank Balances” to understand how the Empire’s lackeys serve the System.
@ Tom 123
Elvira Nabiulina was named European Central Banker of the year in 2017 and made the Forbes “most powerful women” list. That does not happen unless you are a team player, and I don’t mean Team Russia.
And what would you prefer, Gazprom to sell oil for rubles?
If Gazprom wishes to be paid in RUB, the buyer (let’s say the US) would go to the foreign exchange market and buy rubles with dollars and then pay Gazprom in RUB.
As the ruble is not widely held by other countries (yet), the FX market would find a seller of rubles, who would likely be a Russian financial institution (lets say Russian Bank). So, once the transaction is complete what you have is:
Russian Bank
Sold RUB to US for USD
US
Sold USD to Russian Bank for RUB
Buy Oil from Gazprom with RUB
Gazprom
Sold Oil to US for RUB
Russia now has Gazprom with less oil and Russian Bank with more USD.
Since this is the same outcome as directly buying oil for dollars, everyone has decided to do is skip the foreign exchange market. Then Gazprom can go to the Russian bank and exchange the USD for rubles or whatever else they decide they want. Doesn’t matter which way you do it, it ends up the same. That’s how it with fiat currencies and a free market. Of course, with US locking down the markets, it is no longer a free market.
What is changing is that other countries will likely start buying oil with either their own home currency (if that is OK with Gazprom), or an emerging “global currency”, such as the Yuan (CNY).
You assume that the foreign exchange will always have plenty of rubles, willing to part with them in exchange for USD.
Sure, it could be a Russian bank. Already you have a more sovereign monetary system.
It also could be some other nation’s bank. Already someone else has to keep rubles instead of sitting only on US dollars. However you decide to put it, selling oil in russian currency is only a plus. If countries want russian oil and gas, they will have to find rubles somewhere. Or freeze to death.
Selling oil and other exports for Rubles makes sense because it will make the value/backing of rubles really worth something tangible on the fx market… And, it will weaken the dollar because it is loosing market share for oil and other international purchases. Or, preferably, sell oil for gold… and then sell the gold to cover production expenses and over time repatriate the profits to Russian company/commercial bank vaults from the exchanges.
PE Bird, banks are in a business of managing credit RISK. If they own US$10 billion financial instruments, their risk exposure is huge. Russian banks will do better by owning rubles risk then the dollar risk. Their central bank, RCB, can easily bail them out in the ruble risk scenario. In the dollar risk scenario they default. So they are better off holding the ruble credit risk. This is a core point. They limit their exposure to the dollar risk.
Let’s review your example. “If Gazprom wishes to be paid in RUB, the buyer (let’s say the US) would go to the foreign exchange market and buy rubles with dollars and then pay Gazprom in RUB.” This gives Russia a great LEVERAGE against the buyer. The one who has the leverage has the POWER. Russia is not holding any dollar risk. It can control how the buyer can get rubles. This is power.
“As the ruble is not widely held by other countries,” doesn’t matter. Russia can always create rubles out of thin air and do a currency swap deal. Just look at how the Fed provided the swap line against treasury bonds and prevented dumping of the bonds, and interest rate from going high. This ability to create sovereign money and do currency swaps, gives RCB immense leverage. Russian central bank can manage its currency VALUE only by creating demand, maintaining leverage and its stability.
“Russian Bank with more USD.” This increases the credit risk exposure for the Russian bank. Now it will buy UST bonds with those earned USD. The UST pays approx 1% interest, it was negative interest for euros. If they buy Russian bonds they would earn 8.5% interest. So low profitability and high risk. Where is the compensation for the risk that the Russian bank is taking?
Russia is rich in resources, natural and human. It doesn’t need too much foreign exchange credit risk as it has positive trade balance. In late 1940s, the U$A had positive trade balance and it promoted the usage of US$. Similarly, nations with positive trade balance, like Russia, China, Saudi Arabia,… need to promote their sovereign currencies, unless they are suckers or powerless. It is a different situation for nations with negative trade balance.
A shrewd capitalist will keep all the rewards and pass on all the risks to others, while increasing their leverage and power. This is the game that Sauron and Saruman are playing. They are playing with money created out of thin air and accumulating all the capital, leverage and power. They have captured nation’s currency creating apparatus, its allocation, payment networks and using interest and insider knowledge capturing super profits. The world paid $10 TRILLION in interest in 2021. Who got that money? So how much money are Sauron and Saruman making per year from their private monetary system?
We haven’t touched the topic of monetary and economic sovereignty. If anyone owns $10 billion worth of bonds then they have huge risk. The opposite party has higher leverage.
“People with leverage have dominance over people with less.”
Hi Max
Russia is (was??) prepared to sell its oil in US dollars because it values those dollars. Those dollars still have value and can be used to buy things that are useful or desirable. They could even be used to buy gold from other countries as those other countries still perceive the Dollar to have value.
Have you considered that Russia has been buying a lot of goods from Europe? They would need euros for that so again the Euros were worth something to Russia. This also ever so slightly opens the door to de-dollarisation by creating an alternative. More on this below.
Now consider if the Russians had sold the oil or gas for Rubles. They would then have to exchange Rubles for Euros to purchase things from Europe…
If the Russians could convince the Europeans to accept Rubles for European goods then the Europeans could use those Rubles to buy the oil. This would be the PetroRuble equivalent of the PetroDollar. It would be quite the trick to pull off as it is a bit of a chicken and the egg scenario.
You may notice that Russia is looking to sell oil for Indian Rupees now if Russia can either spend those Rupees or swap them for another currency to buy something it needs or wants then that works for Russia. Swapping / converting does entails costs although these can be low as a percentage on very large amounts they become significant. Regardless this is another step to removing the requirement
Similarly China is trying to convince Saudi Arabia to accept Chinese Yuan for its oil. If this happens then it will be a seismic shift in how value is transferred between countries. Suddenly not only China but anyone holding Yuan would be able to purchase oil from Saudi Arabia. This would create the PetroYuan and increase demand for the currency.
Now imagine the above comes to pass and Saudi Arabia has a lot of Yuan, more than it needs to find its purchases from China. It decides to purchase something from another country, for example air defense equipment from Russia or beef from Brazil. If either of those countries can use the Yuan for their trade their China then they would be prepared to accept it.
This is the position that the US has been enjoying for many years. Originally the value of the dollar was coupled to gold so the oil price was effectively priced in gold, albeit indirectly. With the move of the dollar away from gold this link was broken. However, momentum from the value of US exports and military might was enough to keep value in the dollar. After all if I get dollars and can buy gold, copper, iron and so on then why shouldn’t I expect them. Of course we see the prices of commodities increasing in dollar terms and the US share of world manufacturing decreasing as Asian manufacturing grows.
Things could be changing. We certainly live in interesting times and you may yet see oil and other commodities being sold in Rubles, Rupees, Yuan and so on. With computers the ability to near instantly calculate the price of a commodity across various currencies has been with us for many years.
Hi Liam,
You make many great points. Concur with most of those points. However, you’re missing the key element of LEVERAGE. In any relationship, the one who has the leverage dominates the relationship. This is an universal reality.
Let’s understand Russia’s characteristics. Russia has very low debt to gdp ratio. It has positive trade balance with the U$A, EU, UK, … So it doesn’t need to hold the private currencies of these entities, particularly after 2014, as they have been increasing sanctions on Russia. It did change its investment portfolio but still 60+% was in the Empire’s private currencies. This gives Empire a huge leverage. It should have lowered its investment risk.
Russia should have reduced the Empire’s holding to less than 40%. It looks like it was mistaken in an assumption that the EU won’t join the freezing of assets. Many of us have been openly stating that $, €, £, ¥,… are Empire’s private currencies and they follow Sauron’s orders.
The reason our world hasn’t developed alternate economic, monetary and financial systems is because of INERTIA. Hopefully, nation will see the risk to their sovereignty, security and prosperity, and reinvent the global financial system. It is time to destroy Sauron’s “Ring of Power.”
There are only two nations in the world that can challenge the Sauron’s power, and they’re Russia and the U$A. Unfortunately, the U$A has been captured like Saruman. Let’s hope Russia, China, India, Africa, Asia, ME, LATAM,… will join together to free humanity from enslavement and imperialism. The coming battles are between the West and REST.
That time has come and gone. Gazprom wants payment in rubles.
It may be possible for such a nation to refuse to pay its foreign debts, but good luck trying to borrow abroad in the future. In strictly financial terms, it’s a bad idea.
(Removed by mod) All international finance is debits and credits and Russia simply offsets its frozen Forex Reserves against Forex Liabilities.
Future Credits for Commodities though require real transfers in Non-Western asset classes for deposit in same jurisdictions. This is why Moscow Narodny created the Eurobond Market in late 1950s to protect against US sequestration – now it needs Bonds traded in Shanghai.
Finance is fungible
Paul.
great point. The EuroDollar and EuroBond financial markets are a good example of a solution to prevent sequestration. Finding a neutral and independent center is going to be difficult. Why not Moscow ?
True, but for how long?
Yugoslavia’s Tito was famous for refusing to pay his debts, or to pay them at a whim. Using the might of Yugoslav army (it really was strong at one point in time), he excused his coutry from it’s financial obligations.
Look at what that folly brought to Yugoslavia. Once Tito was dead, the country became weak and a prey for western inteligence agencies. Eventually, it collapsed in a bloody civil war where one side ended being supported by NATO.
Never underestimate the power of foreign debt noose.
No problem then –
“If $300 billion were arrested, about $340 billion remain free, out of which $132 billion is monetary gold in the form of bullion. It is not known how much of the remaining money is cash, and how much is invested in securities.”
… meaning, no gold was outside of Russia, and if it was, it remained untouched. Which I would not believe; for the greedy, ever gold-hungry Anglos it would be too much of a temptation, cf. Venezuela and Libya.
So basically everything frozen was a credit anyway, something digital, a mere receivable and, hence, another one’s liability, no real asset in itself. We know how the West “creates” currency out of thin air. It is intrinsically worthless.
Russia is certain to retrieve such values = receivables in a deal somewhere down the road. Her gold however is safe and secure, and will form the basis for trade in the new Asian monetary order.
They also snatched Ukrainian gold in 2014. As I recall 20 tonnes (half of its gold reserves) was flown out of the country following the Maidan Putsch. The remain gold will probably disappear very soon.
Seizure of foreign assets must not be ruled out by Russia, if, and when its reserves are stolen by the US and EU. Then, it should be open season in Russia on everything owned by any entity from those countries which have sanctioned Russia. And from then on, keep all wealth out of the US, EU, and any other country they have control over.
If anyone needs an explanation as to why the restoration of capitalism in Russia was a tragedy, just read this article. The suffering of the Russian people as a result of Yeltsin’s selling off Russian State assets and the naivety of the Atlanticist Integrationists surrounding Putin has left the Russian economy vulnerable to Western sanctions. Hopefully Russia will now turn East and forsake any economic ties which leave them open to harm by Western sanctions. Also, the Russian Central Bank can create Rubles solely for use in Russia.
Amen to that. Globohomo capitalism is quickly turning into a disaster. It brought suffering and debt trap to milions of people in the developing countries, only to feed the greed of a few.
It’s back to plain old bilateral alliances again. Maybe create some allied foreign fund (like they are currently trying), but don’t go any further than that. Never again.
Also, it might be time to revisit some lessions of hard-as-nails communism. Of all the people in the world, Russians should know how to do it.
Where is the rest of the gold and why was it not brought home previous to WAR?!? Anyone responsible for this needs to be in prison!
Essentially, what we have here is the exposure of the true source of western power, established via force of arms over hundreds of years – the international financial system. It is a system of blackmail from beginning to end, from A through to Z, if you wish to trade, if you wish to lift your country out of extreme poverty, you have to lock yourself into this system, use its currencies, bank with its banks, utilize its financial services, accept advice from its supposed experts, & so on. There will be many who criticize Russia & refer to its management of its reserves pure cretinism. The question though are what options did Russia have? Did it have any at all? I suspect not. I more or less know that to be the case – but there are many secret aspects of how the system functions at the highest levels us mere mortals are not privy to, although we can make an educated guess, & arrive at the conclusion that Russia ran its finances the way it had to, because there was no alternative. And now Russia & China seek to create an alternative, for the first time in hundreds of years, a system of trade & finance will exist that the west does not have a monopoly of control over. This is a tectonic shift.
Indeed. The Bretton-Woods Agreement (1944) and the SWIFT system, which established the US dollar as the international reserve currency, are the true source of US power. The combination of dollar hegemony backed by military hegemony has proven highly profitable for the Hegemon. That may change in the future, assuming that the world does not first get blown to pieces.
@ Srbalj
The first draft of the project for a new monetary and financial system will be available by the end of March — two weeks! Obviously, this is an urgent matter, as exchanges between many countries have been affected by the sanctions.
It seems that the new monetary and financial system will be based on a new international currency, which will be calculated as an index of the national currencies of the participating countries and commodity prices. A basket of currencies is also being considered.
https://kapital.kz/finance/103768/yeaes-i-knr-razrabotayut-proyekt-mezhdunarodnoy-finsistemy.html
I guess Russia will need to cope with the sanctions until the new financial system comes to the rescue…
Great translation, but who is the writer of the words (“I’m”, “I”, etc.)? In the Russian source, it’s not clear for other language speakers.
https://edwardslavsquat.substack.com/p/russias-gold-is-being-robbed?token=eyJ1c2VyX2lkIjo3Nzc2OTE4LCJwb3N0X2lkIjo0ODAzMTE1NywiXyI6ImpmaUtTIiwiaWF0IjoxNjQ3NDQ4ODM4LCJleHAiOjE2NDc0NTI0MzgsImlzcyI6InB1Yi01MjA5NjMiLCJzdWIiOiJwb3N0LXJlYWN0aW9uIn0.TsN8IiJjayh-UtBnp3f2OSUyWVouYoS-ya3vgYRAzuA
And as a result, a very strange decision was made: instead of conducting transactions with gold itself through the Central Bank, the Russian government, represented by Prime Minister Mishustin, allowed industrialists to sell gold abroad directly, bypassing the Central Bank and commercial banks. […]
And so Russian gold was sent abroad… And most importantly: now the sellers are not only able to independently sell gold abroad to anyone, but last year [in June 2021] Putin also made it so foreign exchange earnings from the sale of gold did not have to return to Russia. […]
If you carefully read a short note about Putin’s decree, then the following conclusions can be drawn from it: now it will become very easy for Russian miners of gold and diamonds to sell their products abroad. Previously, the state obliged all proceeds to be credited to accounts in Russian banks, now the currency from the sale of gold can be immediately credited to accounts in any banks convenient for the buyer and use the money at your discretion. Absolutely without any control from the state.
And yes, this money can be invested in anything. There, behind the cordon.
Well, if you look at all this from the side of a simple layman, then Mr. President simply legalized the export of capital from the country. To offshore, to foreign banks, anywhere. That is, now what they fought so hard against is legalized. […]
Now it will be easier for Russian companies to sell resources abroad. Previously, the proceeds had to first be transferred to accounts in Russia. Now they can simply transfer money to a foreign account and immediately start using it at their own discretion. […]
The gold reserve of the Russian state is administered by the Bank of Russia, which is not a Russian bank. This, let me remind you, is a legal entity about which we know nothing. No authorized capital, no property, no founders.
Stegiel, If true, all this is damning. Some kind of con game of the bankers, masters and Mr. Schwab?
@ Stegiel
This is a trade issue or an international finance issue. Who are the people on the top positions of those two areas in Russia at the moment? Can they be trusted?
“The gold reserve of the Russian state is administered by the Bank of Russia, which is not a Russian bank.”
No joke, it’s even in the name. Bank of Russia, not “The Russian Bank”.
Seriously, if you want to find the traitors, look at the financial system.
Nemirni, the western financial system is collapsing. A new one is being born. Hopefully, it will not mimic the western one.
As to Stegiel comment, it is based in information form a link he provided. I am not sure if I would trust everything he satted. I think that we cannot blame the central bank of a country for the gold sold abroad — it is a decision of the trade or international finance ministries.
Decent explanatory article. As I pointed out in the comments under the Escobar article, Russia’s gold is in Russia. BTW, Russia is one of the main miners of gold.
Gold mine production
https://www.gold.org/goldhub/data/historical-mine-production
Thanks for the great information. Russia’s gold must be safe as the vultures want them all.
Our Western Partners….Putin the CEO of Russia needs to be fired. What a dumb move. The chess master got checkmated.
Like a hurdy gurdy Putin constantly repeated “our western partner, our western partners, our western partners,……). Never ever heard that one of his western partners said “our russian partner”
Today reuters reported that Lavrov could imagine a neutrality model like Austria for the Ukraine!?
This would be really a cheap deal after all what happened and still will happen.
So many russian soldiers died for a ukraine like austria?
Hey come on…..
Prospector, if you do not have anything to say that is relevant, don’t say it.
not sure i agree with this assessment. You Russian guys are the best chess players in the world and I’m guessing your Cbankers are pretty smart. Just because the rcb has disclosed the make up of its reserves, and a certain % are in foreign currency, doesnt mean those amounts are frozen. Other than gold, all fx reserves are simply book entries on someone’s balance sheet. There must be an asset … say USD cash and a corresponding liability. The RCB must have USD accounts at friendly CBs (i.e., BOC or other) where they transferred USD/Euro, etc. I mean, Gazprom is getting paid $900mm usd per day (or euros, not sure) for its ngas every day and that money is going into a dollar account somewhere, surely not at JP Morgan the past 3 weeks. International CB is opaque and unaudited … CB’s pretty much do a lot of stuff in relative secrecy. I would bet the RCB moved its foreign currency reserves away from western CB’s in front of the war and it has access to a vast majority of those assets despite saying it doesnt.
Why would it not tell the truth? Because it may be in its interest to not let others know how much of a war chest it has to support the Ruble. I would bet the only material buyer of rubles these days outside of for trade purposes is the Russian CB trying to support the Ruble. Its appreciated back to under 100 and is now only down 30% from pre-war. Surely western speculators, with the support of their CBs and Treasuries are trying to crush the Ruble. If the RCB runs out of dollars/Euros etc. to buy Rubles they cant defend it anymore. As westerners think they are running out of reserves to defend the ruble with they will get more aggressive and short it aggressively. Then pow, RCB comes in with the additional reserves they told everyone they dont have and the speculators/western CBs/Treasuries get smacked in mother of all short covering. They have to scramble to cover their shorts and the ruble rips.
Thats my guess on it. RCB is hiding its fx reserves and given no one inside Russia can sell rubles to the outside there is gonna be a big imbalance in favor of the RCB and the ruble will rip.
Very interesting. I hopt you are right. Can I ask what is your speciality? Financial transactions? Trade? Investment? Thanks.
I always considered Putin and posse, master chess players who considered every possible scenario. It astounds me that they would allow US to stick it to them like this. They never seem to learn that America would rather see them starving or dead.
Pretty good grounds for treason charges against the people responsible for running the RCB, Russian Ministry of finance and CEOs of top Russian banks.
These kinds of mistakes must never happen again.
I believe Putin also have a black belt in Judo. The clue here is to let the advesarys use its own force against itself. The EoL made it’s move, not a wise one in my book. In the long run they will loose magnitudes more than they stole. Not worth it.
De dollarization is the solution and is happening while we speak. Global De dollarization will take a few years
China is the industrial production capital of the world, and China has use this clout to strengthen the Yuan overtime since the 80s. China is also a Nuclear power and no one can attack it. It only make sense to control its own destiny, which is why the west hates China, because it can control its own destiny. The Yuan is going from strength to strength as a result. Its also a reserve currency now. Even the IMF couldn’t deny the Yuan entry as a reserve currency.
Russia is the Mineral resources (energy capital of the world). with vast amount of undiscovered and untapped resources. Energy is currency. Energy is the true currency of the world, it as always been the true currency, but never been truly defined as such in the true sense, because the West lacks energy in considerable quantity. If you control energy, you control the world. Russia has been Raped and plundered since the fall of the USSR after the Soviet Union collapse, and the west has continued to use their financial clout to control Russia through pricing and buying energy from Russia, using both Dollar and Euro as the purchasing currency to get Russia Drunk on their currency and give Russia a false sense of belonging in the world. This has allowed the historically low value of the Ruble, which as been suffocated for a long long time.
Russia has the potential to be the No1 country in the world controlling the energy dynamics of the world, Selling their energy (Oil and Gas) only in Ruble only, especially with the EU, Trade in with direct currency exchange with other nations, strengthening their currency the Ruble and tell the EU to go take a hike if they don’t want to buy their energy. Watch the Ruble join the reserve currency list if Russia takes control of its resources.
Gas prices are approaching £2/litre in UK, and prices are going through the roof. If Russia stick to their guns, the EU would come begging quick as the populace cry foul over rising prices.
Russia Wake up from your slumber. You are blessed, but you realise this not.
This was posted a while back by an American journalist that has lived and worked in Moscow for about 7 years.
Why did Russia’s largest bank empty its gold vaults?
https://edwardslavsquat.substack.com/p/why-did-russias-largest-bank-empty?s=r
It is important to note a particularity in the Russian gold market: Unlike in other countries, Russian gold miners cannot directly sell their gold abroad.
The miners must use a domestic financial institution as an intermediary, eg Russian banks VTB and Sberbank.
These banks absorb the gold mined in Russia and then sell it on, either to the Central bank of Russia or to international bullion banks.
The Central Bank was at one point buying 100% of Russian gold production. If they reduced purchases, then it is possible that Sberbank (VTB was sanctioned during Crimea and turned to Shanghai Gold Exchange so I doubt it was them) was doing transactions on behalf of the Russian gold miners with the West..
We do not know whose hold was confiscated ( Sberbanks, miners?) Nor If it was paper or bullion…but its not very likely that this is Central Bank (ie sovereign) gold..
Article and most of replies are given me and Russia good sleep. The problem is inside countries of fake virtual economy. Namely the west.
Hahaha… :-))) YES! You really made me laugh. Have a good night! I will. Thanks.
It notes that prohibitions from Directive 4 related to the receipt of interest and maturity payments relating to debt or equity of specified entities issued before February 24, 2022 would be authorized only through May 25,2022.FAQ 981 then also notes that, beyond this date,a specific license would be required to keep receiving these payments. This all suggests that beyond May 25, it would not be possible for NYC banks to receive the interest payments, and that banks would need to ‘reject’ such transactions. This would therefore impact the interest payments due on May 27 for RUSSIA USD 2026 and EUR 2036.
For more see here: https://www.zerohedge.com/markets/historic-day-deck-powell-hikes-putin-defaults
Thanks for the article, Andrei.
I could not have made a more effective argument for all nations to develop go-it-alone economies versus continually attempting, to the vast majority of their own populations’ detriment, to remain in a so-called globalized economy. The reasons for this will in the near future become more and more obvious, unavoidably obvious, as the vast majority of belts in each economy must be adjusted tighter and tighter, and the vast majority of wallets in each economy get thinner and thinner.
Profit-based systems in which a microscopic percentage (an oligarchic class) of any nation’s population “privately” owns or controls the vital necessities of life for the vast majority of the population for the former’s astronomical profit (profit which must increase perpetually), will soon come to be seen by the increasingly oppressed latter as fatally flawed. In short, the vast majority will not be able to provide enough profit for the microscopic percentage’s astronomical investments and, rather than suffer any losses on those astronomical investments, the latter will, as if guided by an invisible hand, seek profit by “investing” in other imaginative enterprises — Emergency Economic Stabilization Acts, Great Resets, Global Wars Of Terror For Profit, or WWIII, to name just a few.
There is a 5th column in Russia. A faction of the 5th column runs Russia’s central bank and other financial institutions. This article above smells like an attempt by the 5th column to cover its ass. Let’s just hope this sabotage was not a fatal blow to the cause, and that Putin manages to clean up the stable one day.
/revisiting-russias-5th-and-especially-6th-columns/
It is obvious that Western finance capital wants to bring Russia to its knees, submit it to the orders of the IMF, and in this way force the sale of its profitable state-owned companies. They want to take over the Russian economy. A firm response is needed that affects the property of hostile countries.
Thx Saker for this report.
I would like to add that Gold bars produced by russian refiners are no longer LBMA eligible, which means they cannot be used for transactions with western financial institutions. Russia is a major gold producer, #2 in the world.
This production will be used to supply demand coming from russian private citizens, as Russia canceled the 20% VAT tax on the purchase of gold.
Bigben, you are right. Thanks for this insight – I had not realized it, andI bet most of us don’t. I am curious: what is your speciality? Do you work with finance? Banking?
Isn’t it possible to open a foreign currency account in the other BRICS states or Turkey.?
Otto Kern
You mean BIS countries, as Russia and China are included in the BRICS. I would say that the BIS countries are infiltrated by spies from CIA, Mossad, etc. Their banks are controlled by western puppets. They are not safe.
One of the difficulties of long-term finance in the international sphere is that it is almost impossible to ensure that the jurisdictions where you raise finance remain friendly nations throughout the term of the loans raised.
I remember 15-20 years ago being told that it was a tragedy that the City of London wouldn’t invest in UK biotechs but would invest in a Eurasian mine. Whether it was in Russia, Kazakhstan etc etc was irrelevant. The City loved everything from there, at the expense of home grown innovation. Now, Russians are animals we should have nothing to do with. I refuse to cooperate in that regard. But it does show how much the financial sentiment has changed.
One does tend to suggest that finding ways to repay obligations in full, having lined up identical obligations with more friendly banks/countries might be worthwhile? That way, the US/UK criminals can’t complain about defaults, indeed they have their money back early without risks. So long as the friendly nations are happy to take on the same obligations on behalf of Russian finance raisers, Russia will be fine too.
I really don’t understand the UK: it’s a relatively small nation, which wants to be a global financial centre. You can’t be a ‘global player’ when you go all out to piss off 75% of the world’s population. You can be the junior partner of Wall Street, but you can’t be an independent global player. It’s entirely nonsensical what the UK is doing.
It doesn’t take too much intellect to just switch Russian debt to the Chinese from the USA/Europe. The European banks can help to bail out Greece with their new cash. The USA can invest its cash in helping the homeless instead of buying weapons of murderous destruction.
The Western Banks are going to lose market share, big time, as a result of this. They are complete idiots….
Time to start sinking aircraft carriers if the gold is not returned.
$311 billion: financial instruments by foreign issuers: Digits on balance Sheets < PetroDollars
$152 billion: cash in foreign deposits: Digits on balance Sheets < PetroDollars
$132 billion: gold in Russia: Real Value
$30 billion: International Monetary Fund: Digits on balance Sheets < PetroDollars
Going foward: Trading and commodity Value: Yuan, Ruble (Gold Backed); PetroDollars.
The entire situation inside Russia comes down to this quote by a Duma member:
The logic is direct – the party in power in the Russian Federation broadcasts to Russian business: decide with whom you are – with your people, or with those who wish them harm.
United Russia, through the chairman of its General Council and the first deputy chairman of the Federation Council of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation, proposes to establish criminal liability for the management of companies for the implementation of Western sanctions in Russia.
This war has unleased an immense patriotic feeling inside Russia. I see countless photos of patriotic displays,and countless posts from Russians supporting the war. I’m not sure that Putin realizes what is happening there. His popularity is now close to 80%. But that is totally based on the feelings among people that he stands for Russia.And intends to really solve the issues of traitor elites,and bowing to the West. If he doesn’t really do those things. If he doesn’t curb the elites,and doesn’t conclude the war with total victory. The cheers he is getting now will quickly turn to boos. And from boos,turn to rocks. This is a watershed moment for Putin. The day’s when he could walk the tightrope between Atlanticism and Sovereignty ended on February 24th. But does he realize that,that is the question. Does he realize there is no going back now,time will tell.
https://sputniknews.com/20220316/russias-sovereign-debt-payment-sent-awaiting-clearance-finance-minister-says-1093934515.html
Payment on Russia’s sovereign debt made. It was due today. Now, the ball is in court’s hands.
thank you to Saker Translation community for something both eminently readable which also addressed the questions I had. excellent knowledge drop.
What a pile of horseshit!
There were many ways to store wealth so that the West wouldn’t be able to freeze it:
1. Government debt of non-Western countries denominated in their currencies, i.e. Indian rupee–denominated Indian government bonds, Brazilian real–denominated Brazilian government bonds, etc. Whatever value these currencies lose due to inflation is roughly compensated by their government bonds’ interest. Plus, it’s better to lose a few percent of your wealth that to lose all of your wealth.
2. Commercial debt and portfolio equity in non-Western countries: China, India, Brazil, Saudi Arabia, etc.
3. Direct investment in non-Western countries: businesses, land, real estate.
4. Storable commodities such as metals.
5. Large assets such as container ships.
Does the author of the article not know about these options? Or is he/she being paid by the traitors at the Central Bank of Russia and Russian Ministry of Finance who now want to cover their tracks?
There is much more than just distribute money abroad. There is politics. Russia was not challenging the system, until now. Russia was trying to avoid confrontation. The time was wrong to do otherwise as Russia needed time to build its strength. There were risks, yes, but certainly Russia knew which they were.
Sounds like Russia was borderline incompetent in storing so many reserves at the ECB and Fed. $300 billion in frozen reserves is much bigger than the “$119 billion in foreign debt that is owed”.
Russia could have used a large portion of their foreign reserves to buy rubles in advance of the invasion, thus supporting the currency and allowing more deficit spending after the invasion without triggering inflation. Or it could have purchased more gold, spent more money on internal development, etc.
Of course I may not understand the situation fully.
This was reported on RT today:
“Touching on the decision by several Western powers to freeze Russia’s central bank assets, Putin claimed that this would only serve to irreparably undermine trust in those nations, and make other countries think twice before placing their reserves in the care of those countries. According to him, nearly half of Moscow’s assets were “simply stolen” by the West.”
So apparently nearly half the reserves are now gone, according to President Putin, himself.
Could leaving the reserves in untrustworthy foreign banks be a ploy? It took Iran 3+ decades to get theirs back but they did get it back. Eventually Russia will get their money back. One way or the other.
What if Russia was willing to let their money sit in foreign banks “age” just to show everyone else how thievish the international banking cartel really is. Next step would be to roll out a regional currency like they just did.
I predict the Euro falls to third once the EurAsian currency gets minted and eventually the dollar falls to second (could be years to decades away).
“You place your liquidity in a savings account so that you can earn some sort of interest and your losses are less than inflation.”
This is a protection racket just like the Mafia. I can keep money in a mattress and watch it quickly lose value, or give it to banker and watch it slowly lose value, while the banker makes money off of my money, in his sleep.
Trouble is, once I put my money in a bank it is now their money, which they are supposed to give back, if they feel like it, and Uncle Sam lets them.
I keep thinking what will happen to the savings of millions of people in the west in the next months/years…
IMO no need at all to panic regarding the Rubel value or a default for Russia.
Consider following macroscopic views:
As of now Russia exports gas and oil to the EU/West in the amount of somewhat less than a billion USD in EVERY SINGLE DAY! More than enough to cover all of Russias liabilities in short and long term.
In the long run a exporting country can only be paid by goods and commodities for the stuff it exports. So if the West would not sell to Russia anything of any value for Russia (high tech, electronics, luxury items, etc.) or anything that Russia produces herself, why would Russia continue to sell them gas and oil, for just paper money and digits at foreign banks, which could be frozen at any time. Only if Russia could find this stuff in other countries, which were willing to accept these (now very risky) currencies in vast amounts (considering Russias trade surpluses). All of these countries have been already been “warned” by the west, that they should not trade with Russia and pressed join their sanctions. It is not hard to imagine that the West would freeze that billions of Euros/Dollars, when they got eg. in Chinas or Indias hands, to punish them for not being obedient.
So after Russia gets ridd off USD/Eur denominated liabilities, further trade between Russia and the west will be only in for Russia riskless currencies (Rubel/gold/Yuan/Rupies) or not at all! Russias trade with non western aligned countries will switch much sooner obviously, which will set an example for all. This most probably will be the starting of the end of the USD as the global reserve currency.
Money (except gold) has no intrinsic value, neither the dollar nor the yuan nor the Rubel. The real value is in commodities (incl energy), produced goods and real estate (in extreme situations only water, food and weapons have real value). Russia has lots of all of these and is the closest country to being a self sufficient country there is. Russia only lacks cutting edge semiconducters, luxury/fashion/entertainment goods and some fruits from warmer countries. This all is available outside the western world as well, maybe not the very latest tech or fashion goods, but more than good enough (when was the last time you updated your computer or smartphone, because the last one was honestly not fast enough? A decade ago? Two?).
– The conversion value of the Rubel to foreign currencies does not correspond to the real terms value of the Rubel inside Russia at all. It just shows that there is less demand for Rubels from abroad, i there were no exports from Russia (allowed). If the conversion rate theoretically tomorrow hit 10.000 Rubel per dollar because of the sanctions, this would not reduce the Russians wealth suddenly 100-fold. This would only be the case if ALL what Russians consume and buy were imported from aboard. The last waves of sanctions instead showed a contrary effect than was wished in the west, they increased Russian internal production and were a net benefit for Russia. Instead of being a net importer of food Russia became a major food exporter.
Also now that there are extensive sanctions in place from the west, thus they will export lessto Russia, wether Russian costumers like it or not, and since western companies are abandoning Russia,and will not continue to transfer their profits abroad (while selling the profited Rubles and buying dollars/euros), there will be a drastically reduced demand for the western currencies in Russia, thus there is no forseeable mechanism to weaken the Rubel in its outside value against USD/EUR in the long term, after a short term panic among some Russians trying to buy (only so called “hard” but in reality fiat currencies) USD/EUR.
Sure the sudden massive sanctions will send some shockwaves through the russian economy, but after some adaptation, and some growing pains in Russias import substituting industries it will turn to the better for Russia, than being lazy and just import stuff.
The only theoretical long term risk for a globally decoupled Russia could be, that because of economy of scales and a relatively small russian market, technical progress might start to increasingly lag behind the west. But this is only theoretically a risk after a superficial analysis, because Russia is not alone in Asia. It is a matter of fact, that Russia produces almost half a million engineers a year, which is almost double of what the US produces (they get mostly lawyers instead). Not to mention that India produces more than a million a year and China probably more than the rest of the world combined. Much of that non western brainpower currently is being harvested by the west. But this will only remain so, as long as the dollar stays the global reserve currency, alas not for very much longer… Future technologies will come from the east, not the west!
We hear people saying that the Eastern financial system that is coming means that we will have one world, two systems in the future. Your argument seems to show the unawareness of this thought.
Appreciate this analysis. Keep us informed on developments on this matter if possible.
There is something else going on here. I read in another article that one of Putin’s problems that he now has leverage on is working with the ROTHSCHILD CENTRAL BANK. We pay 2-3% interest on mortgage debt, their Rothchild Bank gets 20% from Russia. I guess they like us better than the Russians. Imagine giving away money at 2-3% for thirty years when inflation is raging at 10-20% in “Shadowstats.” They seem to need us desperately, but don’t seem to like Russia much. As I understand it, the Russians opened up accounts in Yuan that only require 8% interest. This is a much better deal. Also, we hear more and more about a gold backed ruble and not trading in dollars. What they did today was they apparently paid their debt with their reserves that are held in other countries and they can decide if they want to take payment or not. If not, I guess they won’t pay back their debts. I also note that they are confiscating property of parties abandoning Russia and not honoring patents of other countries so they can develop the Tesla stuff blocked by Obama. There have been patents on Tesla free energy since Searching for Zero Point.”
Please put a link to back up your statement above. Mod.
Free energy will destroy the west faster than losing a war with the east… ;-)
As you can see Russia reduced their holding of US treasuries not even on the main list
https://ticdata.treasury.gov/Publish/mfh.txt
What if China sells US Treasuries?
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=kpbC17O5PUc&feature=emb_imp_woyt
You have to understand why they have the US Treasuries in the first place.
Stop issuing monetary sovereign government debt securities. They are unnecessary. There is no compelling reason to issue them. They confuse people. They bias macroeconomic discourse, policy making and outcomes. They are an anachronism. They belong, alongside tally sticks, the gold standard, the London discount houses, and neoclassical macroeconomics, in the history books.
There is no need to issue public debt it is a left over from the gold standard and no longer applies.
http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/?p=31715
OMF Overt Monetary Financing – paranoia for many but a solution for all including Russia
http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/?p=26300
Sooner rather than later, the Bank of Japan is going to abandon its negative interest rate and QQE strategy because the evidence is clear – it doesn’t work.
The next cab off the rank will be OMF Overt Monetary financing. It will demonstrate categorically that fiscal stimulus supported by monetary expansion is the most direct and effective way to get out of a deficient demand malaise.
http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/?p=34055
When it comes to the UK – Sterling is an export product.
Here’s why Labour’s Keir Starmers idea won’t raise a single penny for the UK. Balance sheets included.
https://new-wayland.com/blog/bonds-wont-raise-a-single-penny/
They are bunch of lying idiots.
That the Hard of Accounting are out in force again pushing their fallacious line that Taxes Must Rise because we decided to use government to save the economy in the face of a nasty pandemic.
There must be Fire and Brimstone. The Sin must be Purged.
Clueless idiots the lot of them – particularly those at the ironically named Institute for Fiscal Studies who really ought to know better. (If they do study Fiscal they don’t do it very effectively).
Bonds pay for themselves
https://new-wayland.com/blog/bonds-pay-for-themselves/
It’s fascinating how the mainstream, and quite a few traditional Post Keynesians, struggle with “foreign”. The problem is the mental model they have been trained to analyse.
By focussing on a country, with fixed borders and a consolidated ‘Rest of World’, they appear to miss the subtleties in play that become apparent when you look at the issue from a different point of view.
The classic one is believing that foreign is quite different from domestic. It really isn’t that different at all.
Once you take the MMT view of the situation, you see that there is little difference between somebody holding, say, Sterling Savings in Birmingham, Alabama from somebody holding Sterling Savings in Birmingham, England.
Both are a drain from circulation in the Sterling currency area and free up capacity in the real economy within that area, because saving denies somebody an income further down the spending chain. Both may provide capacity to buy something in the future and, outside of cash or a basic deposit account, both are likely to provide some sort of income in Sterling.
Both can be taxed. Sterling accounts are all transitively linked to the Bank of England via chains of other Sterling accounts. That’s what makes them Sterling. (Yes that applies to Eurocurrency deposits as well — ultimately they have to clear via the Sterling banking system to be worth anything and that allows authorities to collect back taxes on a remittance basis).
Foreign entities are holding your currency as savings. Similarly, financial products denominated in your currency are held as savings. Savings are, in effect, an export product of your currency area.
Once you look at it this way, then savings are very similar to a barrel of oil in stock, or an aircraft engine. If your country relies upon oil exports and people stop wanting oil then you may have a problem. If you rely on aircraft engine exports and there are no orders for new aircraft, you may have a problem. If you rely upon people taking your savings (because they had an export-led policy — which implies a savings-import policy) and that changes (the export-led policy moves to a domestic-led policy, as we’re starting to see in China) then you may have a problem.
To mitigate, you would make sure your exports are sufficiently diversified and decoupled — including the level and global distribution of exported savings. In other words you take a portfolio approach as a matter of policy. Make sure you have your eggs in as many baskets as possible and don’t keep the baskets all in one continent.
Sovereign wealth funds rely upon your export of savings to exist. The Norwegian Wealth Fund allows Norway to supply oil (and the odd salmon) in exchange for savings products. The Wealth Fund has no policy other than to accumulate savings products over time — which gives it a huge amount on the asset side of its national balance sheet. Norges Bank can then discount this asset into Krone for its domestic money supply purposes.
And that is the first brake on the ‘what happens if they spend it all’ fear. Foreign financial assets are the balancing asset for the country’s own money supply. It makes the numbers at the national level look good. They won’t be getting rid of it in a hurry until that view changes. And that view is unlikely to change if the country is running an export-led policy since the two are part of the same ideology.
But let’s say the central bank purges its neo-liberal types and hires some people who realise central banks can’t go bust in their own denomination. They ignore the sovereign wealth fund, say it is a silly waste of time, and stop worrying about the inevitable mark up to ‘Other Assets’.
And let’s say the Norwegians elect the Hedonistic party that promises to swap their huge hoard of savings for actual stuff and blow it all on imports. What is all that spending going to do to your economy?
It is going to cause an export boom. (Which everybody is desperate for in the present, but apparently is a terrible thing in the future. Answers on a postcard…)
Will that stop or reduce domestic spending in your currency area?
Probably not, because if your investment expansion caused by the boom is insufficient to handle the load, you can always rely on that circuit breaker — more imports.
It goes something like this:
The Norwegians order stuff from your currency area backed with their hoard of savings.
Your economy ships stuff to the Norwegians in return for their savings in your currency.
Exporters have an income and pay people.
Those people then start to buy stuff, but everybody is working for exporters and there is nobody to make anything (allegedly).
Other nations on the planet — running export led policies — spot the wealth in your nation and turn up in droves to sell their wares.
You buy imports and they keep the profits as savings (possibly in their own sovereign wealth fund).
The net effect is that the Norwegians reduce their savings in your currency and other export-led economies run up savings in your currency. So you spread the Norwegian demand around the planet to the extent that you can’t satisfy it yourself.
But let’s say that, for some reason, nobody wants your savings — even though there is a boom on and everybody is making loads of money. So you can’t rely on imports, or foreign direct investment, because the rest of the world has developed ‘mainstream economics’ disease and desperately wants to preserve a dying model they fervently believe in even though it makes no rational sense whatsoever to expect multiple independent nations to behave in unison this way.
Surely now your domestic consumers are going to suffer under the relentless demands of hard partying Norwegians!
But what political party is going to favour foreigners over residents who actually vote for them? Only those no hopers who have zero chance of ever getting elected.
A party in government — having encouraged the private sector to automate, innovate and invest as much as it can — would put in place export restrictions. One such approach would be a volume restriction. You would issue Norwegian export licences to a set value in Sterling and auction them off to the highest bidder. That makes servicing export orders more expensive than servicing domestic orders and firms will start to take that into account when they decide to accept an order. There are many other approaches, including: restricting withdrawals from Sterling accounts owned by foreign entities, large fees for exports, and randomly delaying exports in customs so firms don’t know when they’ll get paid (this one may already be in place).
You’ll note that you could swap out Hedonistic Norwegian Foreigners and replace them with Wealthy Domestic Cotswolders and the results would be pretty much the same (slightly less Viking, slightly more Saxon perhaps). Rich people with lots of money might decide to spend everything as well. So should we ban pensions — just in case?
What about the currency effects, you might ask. Well if an economy is in boom time, exporting like crazy and making profit hand over fist, is the currency going to be strong or weak at that point? Exactly.
Now that the ‘bond market vigilantes myth’ has been slain, the ‘foreign debt holders’ myth has sprung up in its place. It’s just another excuse to maintain the globalist, creditor first viewpoint and to try and stop politicians being elected that put the public good of the domestic population first.
And what is really important to remember is sovereign wealth funds don’t give goverments more money to spend. It is a myth.
Removed. Please stop promoting the same site over and over – breaks site rules. Mod.
Sorry MOD my apologies will do.
Just so you know I am not Bill Mitchell from Australia who writes the MMT blog. He is an MMT founder and helped to create it.
So not promoting my own work.
I am Bill from London. Just in case having the same name leads to any confusion.
Thank you for the warning, very much appreciated.
It looks like Nabulina, Chubias and the rest of their Scum will be out on their a$$e$ and hopefully into the slammer. Then Mr Glaziev will be in the Driver’s Seat for a long while.
The payment order for the payment of coupon income on two issues of Russian Eurobonds, sent to the correspondent bank on March 14, has been executed, the Ministry of Finance reported.
We are talking about external loans maturing in 2023 (ISIN XS0971721450 / US78307ADG58) and 2043 (ISIN XS0971721963 / US78307ADH32) in the total amount of 117.2 million US dollars.
The “executed” mark means that the money has been debited from the account in favor of the desired counterparty.
See here: https://ria.ru/20220317/platezh-1778620677.html
There is a not trivial typo in this article. In the final sentence in the second paragraph following the pie chart, “$300 million” should be $300 billion.
Dollars held in foreign accounts bought nationalized assets liquidated in fall of USSR. The Russian oligarchs were representatives in Russia of the foreign capital held by foreign international bankers. But Foreign USD international banks set up system to control Russia by international bankers. The topic is too obscene to be discussed with peasants who lost control of their society to foreign international bankers while their country officially had worlds largest nuclear weapon inventory. The international bankers who looted Russia with foreign credit kept their assets abroad not in Russia.
So, the russian state has external debt (denominated in USD / EUR) of around USD 40bln. Let’s assume, that the private sector has around USD 460bln (I am not sure re this number, so take it with a grain of salt).
So, all-in Liabilities amount to USD 500bln.
Let’s assume that gold stays where it is. And let’s further assume that the other currency reserves stay where they are.
At the same time, the G7 has blocked around USD 300bln in Assets. Plus, each day russia realises around USD / EUR 1bln in Gas/Oil, etc. Sales. In half a year, that would translate to around USD 150bln or so. Let’s assume, that Russia cannot really use this, because of the sanctions. Then, in half a year or so, the net asset position of Russia would change from a net debtor to a net creditor. You may still be in technical default, but at least in theory, you have the ability to net of liabilities and assets.
At this stage, something significant could happen: Russia, with the help of others could introduce a commodity-based hybrid currency. Countries would contribute their Gold / Silver / Oil, etc. (currency) reserves / inventories and an international entity would issue currency units against their commodity contribution. Now, that all debts are paid off, Russia would ask the Europeans and the US to not pay in EUR / USD but in units of that commodity backed currency. …
It is worth noting that the attractiveness of this payment system is created by the instability of the world economy and national currencies, as well as the opportunity to make quick money. There were periods when its value grew by 400% per month. Although, there were not without rate drops. Bitcoin used to go up to $20,000, but then fell by more than half. The Winklevoss brothers were one of those who received a significant income due to the growth of the rate of Bitcoin. In the spring of 2013, they spent about $11 million on bitcoins, purchasing the currency at $120 per unit. By the fall, the combined value of their virtual assets was already valued at $90 million. Olga Buzova’s Buzcoin, which was even accused of fraud in connection with this, was called the most glamorous cryptocurrency aggregator by Scam bot reviews. In my opinion, one of the main disadvantages of cryptocurrencies is that instead of investing money and effort into the real economy, speculators inflate a new electronic bubble, which sooner or later will burst, which can lead to another worsening of the crisis. It is incomprehensible how it is possible to burn a huge amount of electricity for the sake of virtual profit